The relationship between metal implants, such as steel nails, and MRI (Magnetic Resonance Imaging) involves considerations regarding safety and imaging quality. Generally, most modern metal implants are designed to
Hello Doctor: I need to undergo arthroscopic shoulder surgery due to habitual dislocations.
The choice of fixation devices includes steel screws and bioabsorbable screws.
The doctor mentioned that bioabsorbable screws are preferable because they can affect the results of future MRI scans.
However, the price difference is significant.
I would like to know what potential complications or concerns might arise from using steel screws.
Will it be impossible to perform an MRI, or could external forces impacting the steel screws cause bodily harm? Please, could you explain in detail any disadvantages of using steel screws and whether there are ways to address these issues? I don't want my family to spend too much money, but my parents want me to use the better option.
I'm worried about the financial impact on my family, so I would like to explain this to them and persuade them.
Thank you for your hard work, Doctor.
Lai Yu Long, 10~19 year old female. Ask Date: 2016/03/26
Dr. Chen Yongxue reply Orthopedics
Hello, after shoulder dislocation surgery, it is still possible to use MRI for follow-up.
However, if metal screws are used, they can cause significant image interference, making interpretation difficult.
Additionally, if the screws shift later on, they may directly wear down the shoulder joint.
Therefore, bioabsorbable screws are a more ideal option.
Reply Date: 2016/03/26
More Info
When considering the impact of steel pins on MRI results following orthopedic surgery, it is essential to understand both the technical aspects of MRI imaging and the implications of using different materials for surgical fixation.
MRI (Magnetic Resonance Imaging) is a powerful diagnostic tool that uses strong magnetic fields and radio waves to create detailed images of the body's internal structures. However, the presence of metal implants, such as steel pins, can significantly affect the quality of the images obtained. This is primarily due to the magnetic properties of the metal, which can create artifacts—distortions or inaccuracies in the images. These artifacts can obscure the area of interest, making it difficult for radiologists to accurately assess the condition of the joint or surrounding tissues.
Steel pins, commonly used in orthopedic surgeries, are ferromagnetic, meaning they can be attracted to magnets. This property raises concerns about not only the imaging quality but also the safety of the patient during an MRI scan. While most modern MRI machines are designed to accommodate patients with metal implants, the presence of ferromagnetic materials can still pose risks, such as movement of the implant or heating of the metal during the scan. This is particularly relevant if the steel pins are not securely anchored or if there is a risk of them shifting due to external forces.
In contrast, bioabsorbable pins or titanium implants are often recommended for their MRI compatibility. Titanium, for instance, is non-ferromagnetic and generally does not interfere with MRI imaging. This means that if you choose to use titanium or bioabsorbable materials, you are less likely to encounter issues with image quality or safety during future MRI scans. Additionally, bioabsorbable pins eliminate the need for a second surgery to remove the hardware, which can be an advantage in terms of recovery and overall patient experience.
Regarding your concerns about the cost of using bioabsorbable pins versus steel pins, it is important to weigh the potential long-term benefits against the initial expense. While bioabsorbable pins may be more expensive upfront, they could save you from additional costs associated with complications arising from poor imaging or the need for further interventions. Furthermore, if you experience ongoing issues with your shoulder joint that require imaging, the ability to obtain clear MRI results could be invaluable for guiding your treatment.
If you ultimately decide to proceed with steel pins, it is crucial to discuss this with your orthopedic surgeon. They can provide insights into the specific risks associated with your case and help you understand the implications for future imaging. Additionally, if you experience any unusual symptoms or complications post-surgery, such as pain or instability in the joint, it is essential to seek medical attention promptly.
In summary, while steel pins can be used in orthopedic surgery, they may complicate future MRI imaging and pose certain risks. Bioabsorbable or titanium options are generally preferred for their compatibility with MRI and lack of magnetic properties. It is advisable to have an open discussion with your healthcare provider about the best choice for your specific situation, considering both the financial implications and the potential impact on your health and recovery.
Similar Q&A
Impact of Retained Steel Pins on Knee Health After Patella Fracture
Hello Doctor: Two years ago, I had a car accident and suffered a patellar fracture, for which I underwent surgery and had two steel pins inserted for fixation. During my last follow-up appointment, the doctor mentioned that the pins could either be removed or left in place. I wou...
Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
If the steel pin does not protrude or affect the joint, it can be left in place. The pin is made of stainless steel, which is less prone to oxidation. However, if it has already protruded and is piercing the skin or subcutaneous tissue, it is advisable to have it removed.[Read More] Impact of Retained Steel Pins on Knee Health After Patella Fracture
Impact of Surgery on Osteoporosis: Concerns and Considerations
Dear Director, I previously underwent an ultrasound bone density test, which indicated that I have osteoporosis. You suggested that I get a more accurate measurement of my hip joint or spine through a full-body lying down scan. Additionally, I have a question regarding my upcomi...
Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
If the bone is too osteoporotic, the screws may not be able to secure properly during surgery. The physician should assess the condition, and if the bone is too fragile, it may not be suitable for this method. There are also other surgical options available to address the issue.[Read More] Impact of Surgery on Osteoporosis: Concerns and Considerations
Concerns About Steel Pins in Orthopedic Surgery: When to Seek Help?
Hello, I have a comminuted fracture of the proximal radius in my right arm, and I had three metal pins inserted. However, I have been experiencing inflammation, bleeding, and swelling recently (I have returned for follow-up). I noticed that one of the pins seems to be getting cov...
Dr. You Dianqi reply Orthopedics
Hello Mei Mei: Based on your description, it seems that you had a fracture of the radius and that three K-wires were inserted. The doctor left the wires exposed externally for easier removal in the outpatient setting later on. It appears that they may have gradually migrated into...[Read More] Concerns About Steel Pins in Orthopedic Surgery: When to Seek Help?
Impact of Anesthesia Techniques on Fracture Displacement in Orthopedic Surgery
If there is a comminuted fracture of the radial head with a steel plate implanted and one part has not yet healed, will the orthopedic specialist's manipulation during anesthesia cause displacement?
Dr. Wang Shouji reply Orthopedics
Hello: If the fracture has not healed but the steel pin is securely in place, performing a joint mobilization procedure should not significantly increase the risk of displacement. Thank you![Read More] Impact of Anesthesia Techniques on Fracture Displacement in Orthopedic Surgery
Related FAQ
(Orthopedics)
Postoperative(Orthopedics)
Wrist(Orthopedics)
Trigger Finger(Orthopedics)
Head(Orthopedics)
Femoral Fracture(Orthopedics)
Radius(Orthopedics)
Scaphoid Fracture(Orthopedics)
Dislocation(Orthopedics)
Hip Joint(Orthopedics)