Is It Safe to Remove External Hemorrhoids in a Clinic? - Surgery

Share to:

Hemorrhoid issues


Hello doctor, I have an issue with external hemorrhoids.
I visited a clinic, and the doctor suggested that it can be excised in an outpatient setting since the external hemorrhoid is quite small.
I would like to know if it is safe to have it handled at the clinic, or if it would be better to go to a small hospital.
This is my first time experiencing external hemorrhoids, and I am a bit concerned about the local anesthesia for the excision.

Xiao Jun, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2016/04/28

Dr. Ke Fangxu reply Surgery


If external hemorrhoids are not causing pain, bleeding, or affecting daily life, surgery is generally not recommended.
If the hemorrhoids are small, there is even less reason to consider surgery.
Please carefully evaluate the necessity of the procedure and discuss it with your physician.
You may also seek a second opinion from another doctor for reference.
Personally, I believe there is no absolute need for surgical removal.

Reply Date: 2016/04/28

More Info


When considering the removal of external hemorrhoids, it is essential to weigh the safety and appropriateness of the procedure based on the setting in which it is performed. In general, the removal of external hemorrhoids can be safely performed in a clinic setting, especially if the hemorrhoids are small and uncomplicated. However, there are several factors to consider before proceeding.


Safety of Clinic-Based Hemorrhoid Removal
1. Experience of the Provider: The safety of the procedure largely depends on the experience and skill of the healthcare provider performing the removal. A qualified physician, such as a general surgeon or a proctologist, should be able to perform the procedure safely in an outpatient setting. It is advisable to inquire about the provider's experience with this specific procedure.

2. Size and Complexity of the Hemorrhoid: Small external hemorrhoids that are not thrombosed (clotted) can typically be removed in a clinic. If the hemorrhoid is larger, has significant complications, or if there are multiple hemorrhoids, it may be more appropriate to consider a hospital setting where more comprehensive care can be provided.

3. Anesthesia: The procedure is usually performed under local anesthesia, which numbs the area around the hemorrhoid. While this is generally safe, some patients may experience anxiety about the anesthesia or the procedure itself. Discussing your concerns with the physician can help alleviate fears and ensure you are comfortable with the process.

4. Post-Procedure Care: After the removal of an external hemorrhoid, proper post-operative care is crucial to prevent complications such as infection or excessive bleeding. Ensure that the clinic has a clear plan for post-operative care and follow-up. This includes instructions on wound care, pain management, and signs of complications to watch for.

5. Emergency Preparedness: While complications are rare, it is important to ensure that the clinic is equipped to handle any potential emergencies. This includes having access to necessary medical supplies and the ability to refer patients to a hospital if complications arise.


Considerations for Choosing a Setting
- Clinic vs. Hospital: If you feel more comfortable having the procedure done in a hospital setting, especially for your first experience with external hemorrhoids, it may be worth discussing this with your healthcare provider. Hospitals often have more resources and specialists available should any complications occur.

- Consultation: If you have any doubts, consider seeking a second opinion. A different provider may offer insights into the best setting for your specific case.

- Patient Reviews and Recommendations: Researching the clinic or hospital where you plan to have the procedure can provide additional peace of mind. Look for reviews or ask for recommendations from friends or family who may have undergone similar procedures.


Conclusion
In conclusion, the removal of external hemorrhoids can be safely performed in a clinic setting, provided that the procedure is conducted by an experienced healthcare professional and that the hemorrhoids are small and uncomplicated. However, if you have any reservations or if your hemorrhoids present any complexities, opting for a hospital setting may be a more prudent choice. Always communicate openly with your healthcare provider about your concerns and preferences to ensure that you receive the best possible care tailored to your needs.

Similar Q&A

Managing External Hemorrhoids: Treatment Options and Concerns

Hello Dr. Chen, I have a small question. Last year, I had an external hemorrhoid (on the left side of the anus) and my doctor treated it with topical ointment. It did go away, but there is still a piece of tissue that looks like excess skin remaining. When I consulted another doc...


Dr. Chen Shidian reply Gastroenterology and Hepatology
Hello, Miss. You don't need to worry too much; just apply the medication. If you feel very uncomfortable, you may need to consult with a surgeon to discuss the possibility of removal. Changhua Hospital cares about your health. Chen Shidian

[Read More] Managing External Hemorrhoids: Treatment Options and Concerns


Understanding External Hemorrhoids: Treatment Options and Lifestyle Changes

I would like to ask a few questions regarding my diagnosis of external hemorrhoids after a visit to the hospital. I have looked up information online, but I am still uncertain about a few points. Could you please help me with the following questions? Thank you: 1. Is surgical e...


Dr. Ke Fangxu reply Surgery
1. Yes. 2. Yes. 3. External hemorrhoids, if there is no pain or swelling, generally do not require surgical treatment. The definition of "healing" may vary from person to person; from a physician's perspective, as long as there are no uncomfortable symptoms, it can...

[Read More] Understanding External Hemorrhoids: Treatment Options and Lifestyle Changes


Understanding External Hemorrhoids: Symptoms, Treatments, and Surgery Options

The doctor mentioned that there is a small white area on top of my external hemorrhoid. If the medication does not help, I may need to have it surgically removed. What could this small white area indicate? If surgery is necessary, what type of procedure would be best? Thank you.


Dr. Zhang Shuhao reply Surgery
Surgical intervention for external hemorrhoids is recommended in two situations: one is when there are severe local symptoms, including pain, ischemic necrosis, incarceration, or purulent infection; the other is when there is a suspicion of malignancy. Surgery can involve local e...

[Read More] Understanding External Hemorrhoids: Symptoms, Treatments, and Surgery Options


Post-Surgery Care Tips for External Hemorrhoid Removal

Hello Dr. Hou, I have been experiencing symptoms of internal hemorrhoids combined with external hemorrhoids for a long time. Recently, I underwent a ligation procedure to address the internal hemorrhoids, and the physician advised that I should consider surgical excision for the...


Dr. Hou Yongji reply Surgery
Hello: The detailed precautions are related to the type of surgery you will undergo. You should discuss this with your surgeon. Generally, it is advised to avoid running and cycling for 3-4 weeks.

[Read More] Post-Surgery Care Tips for External Hemorrhoid Removal


Related FAQ