Pleural Effusion Without Cough: Key Insights and Concerns - Pulmonology

Share to:

Pleural effusion without cough?


Hello Dr.
Yang: My mother is 47 years old and was admitted to Chang Gung Memorial Hospital last week due to pleural effusion.
She has undergone MRI, CT scans, fluid analysis, bronchoscopy, and a biopsy from her back, but only the fluid analysis revealed metastatic tumors.
The bronchi were too narrow to obtain a sample, and there was insufficient fluid for a biopsy from her back.

Q1: The doctor mentioned that the drainage tube will be removed once the fluid has been fully drained, but there are no further plans.
What other methods can be used for testing?
Q2: My mother does not exhibit the typical symptoms of lung cancer, such as coughing and sputum production.
Is it possible for lung cancer to be present without a cough, or should we suspect that the pleural effusion has other causes?
Q3: During the biopsy examination, the healthcare staff asked if my mother has liver issues.
Is there a connection between pleural effusion and the liver? My mother does not drink alcohol, and the doctor has not arranged for any liver tests.

I apologize for the many questions.
Thank you for your assistance.

AL, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2016/05/03

Dr. Yang Wenda reply Pulmonology


Hello: It can sometimes be challenging to identify the location of the primary tumor in cases of metastatic malignant effusion.
Chang Gung Memorial Hospital is well-equipped, and most of the necessary examinations have already been conducted.
If biopsy is difficult, we may request assistance from the thoracic surgery department for a thoracoscopic biopsy.
Nuclear medicine scans, including positron emission tomography (PET), can also aid in locating the primary tumor.
Please take this into consideration!

Reply Date: 2016/05/03

More Info


Understanding pleural effusion, especially in the absence of cough, can be complex and concerning, particularly when it is associated with serious conditions like metastatic cancer. Let’s address your questions one by one, providing insights based on medical knowledge.

Q1: What other methods can be used for examination after the drainage tube is removed?
After the drainage tube is removed, if further investigation is necessary, several options may be considered. One common approach is to perform a thoracentesis again if there is a significant amount of fluid accumulation. This procedure allows for the collection of pleural fluid for cytological analysis, which can help in identifying malignant cells or other abnormalities.

If thoracentesis is not feasible or if the fluid re-accumulates quickly, imaging studies such as a repeat chest ultrasound or CT scan can be useful to assess the pleural space and guide further interventions. Additionally, if there is a suspicion of a more complex underlying condition, a video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery (VATS) may be warranted. This minimally invasive surgical procedure allows for direct visualization of the pleural cavity and can facilitate biopsy of any suspicious lesions or the pleura itself.

Q2: Can lung cancer present without cough or sputum symptoms?
Yes, lung cancer can indeed present without the classic symptoms of cough or sputum production. While persistent cough, hemoptysis (coughing up blood), and sputum production are common symptoms associated with lung cancer, many patients may not exhibit these signs, particularly in the early stages of the disease. Other symptoms can include unexplained weight loss, fatigue, chest pain, or shortness of breath. In cases of pleural effusion, the fluid may accumulate without causing significant respiratory symptoms, especially if the effusion is small or develops gradually.

Given your mother's situation, it is essential to consider that the presence of pleural effusion can be due to various causes, including malignancy, heart failure, infections, or liver disease. Therefore, further investigation into the underlying cause of the pleural effusion is crucial.

Q3: Is there a relationship between pleural effusion and liver disease?
Yes, there is a significant relationship between pleural effusion and liver disease. One of the common causes of pleural effusion in patients with liver disease is hepatic hydrothorax, which occurs when fluid from the abdominal cavity (due to ascites) migrates into the pleural space. This can happen even in the absence of significant respiratory symptoms.
In your mother's case, the healthcare provider's inquiry about her liver function suggests they are considering this possibility. Liver function tests (LFTs) can help assess the liver's health, and imaging studies can evaluate for signs of cirrhosis or other liver conditions. Even though your mother does not consume alcohol, liver disease can arise from various causes, including viral hepatitis, fatty liver disease, or autoimmune conditions.

In summary, it is crucial to continue working closely with your mother's healthcare team to explore all potential causes of her pleural effusion and to ensure that appropriate diagnostic measures are taken. The absence of cough does not rule out serious conditions like lung cancer, and understanding the relationship between her liver health and pleural effusion is vital for her overall management. If further tests are needed, do not hesitate to advocate for them, as early detection and intervention can significantly impact outcomes.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Pleural Effusion: Causes, Treatment, and Prevention

Hello, Dr. Chou. My uncle is a police officer and a heavy smoker. He occasionally drinks alcohol. A few days ago, he was hospitalized due to a minor stroke. He was supposed to be discharged this Friday, but last night he suddenly experienced difficulty breathing and a slow heart ...


Dr. Zhou Ziguang reply Pulmonology
Hello: It is important to address the underlying cause of pulmonary edema; please discuss this with your physician.

[Read More] Understanding Pleural Effusion: Causes, Treatment, and Prevention


Managing Recurrence of Pleural Effusion: Insights on Immunity and Treatment

Seven years ago, Xiao Min was hospitalized due to a persistent high fever, which led to the discovery of pleural effusion in the thoracic cavity, diagnosed as pulmonary tuberculosis. He was treated and prescribed medication, and since then, he has returned to the hospital for fol...


Dr. Hong Yuanbin reply Internal Medicine
Hello, the factors influencing the occurrence of diseases are numerous and typically involve a combination of constitution, environment, personal health care, genetics, and other factors. Not smoking or drinking alcohol, maintaining a regular lifestyle, and consistently engaging ...

[Read More] Managing Recurrence of Pleural Effusion: Insights on Immunity and Treatment


Understanding Pleural Effusion: Is It a Serious Concern?

I have a severe cough due to a cold, but an X-ray showed no pneumonia. However, the doctor told me I have pleuritis. Is this a serious issue?


Dr. Yang Wenda reply Pulmonology
Hello, The X-ray shows pleuritis, indicated by whiteness in the lower left or lower right lung base, suggesting the possibility of pleural effusion (commonly referred to as pleuritis). To confirm the presence of pleuritis, an ultrasound is needed to determine if there is fluid ...

[Read More] Understanding Pleural Effusion: Is It a Serious Concern?


Understanding Pleural Effusion: Nutritional Needs and Recovery Time

My grandfather is 85 years old. After catching a cold recently, he has been experiencing difficulty breathing. Upon examination, the doctor diagnosed him with pulmonary edema due to malnutrition. My grandfather has a poor appetite and is very picky with his food. I would like to ...


Dr. Ke Zhengchang reply Pulmonology
Hello: Low levels of protein in the blood, particularly albumin, can lead to bilateral pleural effusion. Hospitalization for intravenous albumin administration is necessary, followed by diuretics to reduce pleural effusion. Once symptoms improve, it is essential to supplement die...

[Read More] Understanding Pleural Effusion: Nutritional Needs and Recovery Time


Related FAQ

Pleural Effusion

(Pulmonology)

Cough

(Pulmonology)

Breathing

(Pulmonology)

Throat

(Pulmonology)

Aspiration Pneumonia

(Pulmonology)

Pulmonary Fibrosis

(Pulmonology)

Chest Pain

(Pulmonology)

Bronchitis

(Pulmonology)

Choking

(Pulmonology)

Gerd

(Pulmonology)