Can a broken bone be manipulated?
What happens if I keep pressing on the area where the bone is fractured? (After switching to a brace, I occasionally take it off to massage the uninjured area.) I didn't know where it was before, and pressing on it caused pain.
I thought it was related to a sprain, but after a follow-up visit, I learned it was the area where the bone is fractured.
A Zhu, 10~19 year old female. Ask Date: 2016/05/26
Dr. Wang Shouji reply Orthopedics
Hello: As long as there is no severe pain, there should be no major issues.
However, if there is severe pain, be cautious of possible fractures or dislocations.
Thank you!
Reply Date: 2016/05/26
More Info
When dealing with a fractured bone, it is crucial to understand the implications of massage and pressure on the injured area. The primary concern with massaging a fractured bone is that it can potentially exacerbate the injury, delay healing, and lead to complications. Here’s a detailed explanation of the risks and considerations involved.
Understanding Bone Fractures
A fracture occurs when there is a break in the continuity of the bone. This can range from a hairline fracture to a complete break. The healing process involves several stages, including inflammation, bone production, and bone remodeling. During the initial healing phase, the body forms a blood clot around the fracture site, which is essential for healing. Applying pressure or massage to this area can disrupt this process.
Risks of Massaging a Fractured Bone
1. Increased Pain and Discomfort: Applying pressure to a fractured area can cause significant pain. This is because the fracture site is sensitive, and any manipulation can irritate the surrounding tissues, leading to increased discomfort.
2. Delayed Healing: Massage can disrupt the formation of the callus, which is the new bone tissue that forms around the fracture. If the healing process is interrupted, it may take longer for the bone to heal properly.
3. Misalignment of Fracture: If the fracture is not properly immobilized, massage can cause the broken ends of the bone to shift out of alignment. This misalignment can lead to improper healing, resulting in a malunion or nonunion of the fracture, which may require surgical intervention.
4. Risk of Complications: In some cases, excessive manipulation of a fractured area can lead to complications such as compartment syndrome, where swelling increases pressure within a muscle compartment, potentially leading to muscle and nerve damage.
5. Injury to Surrounding Structures: The area around the fracture may include muscles, tendons, and ligaments. Massaging the area can inadvertently cause injury to these structures, leading to additional complications.
Recommendations
Given these risks, it is generally advised to avoid massaging the area directly over a fractured bone. Instead, consider the following:
- Follow Medical Advice: Always adhere to the recommendations of your healthcare provider regarding the care of your fracture. If you have questions about rehabilitation or pain management, consult your doctor or a physical therapist.
- Use Protective Gear: If you are using a brace or splint, keep it on as directed. This immobilization is crucial for proper healing.
- Gentle Massage of Surrounding Areas: If you feel the need to massage, focus on the muscles and tissues surrounding the fracture site, but avoid direct pressure on the fracture itself. Gentle massage can help alleviate tension and promote circulation in the surrounding areas without risking the fracture.
- Pain Management: If you experience pain, consider using ice packs or over-the-counter pain relief medications as recommended by your doctor.
- Physical Therapy: Once the fracture has healed sufficiently, a physical therapist can guide you through safe exercises to regain strength and mobility without risking further injury.
In conclusion, while it may be tempting to massage an area that feels tense or painful, doing so over a fractured bone can lead to significant risks and complications. Always prioritize healing and consult with healthcare professionals for the best course of action.
Similar Q&A
Preventing Future Bone Pain and Spurs After a Fracture: Tips and Remedies
How can individuals with fractures prevent future bone pain and bone spurs? Can I perform some massage? Are there any specific foods I should eat? Is it advisable to apply topical ointments or patches on the fracture site?
Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
Typically, once a fracture has healed, there should not be any issues with soreness or pain. However, fractures that do not heal properly or heal incorrectly may lead to pain or discomfort. Additionally, if a fracture occurs on a joint surface and does not heal well or if there i...[Read More] Preventing Future Bone Pain and Spurs After a Fracture: Tips and Remedies
Can Heat Therapy or Massage Help with Post-Clavicle Fracture Recovery?
Hello, Doctor. It has been 55 days since my clavicle fracture surgery, and I am experiencing some numbness around the wound area. Is it safe to use a hot water bottle for warm compresses or to perform gentle massage? Thank you very much!
Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
Can be done.[Read More] Can Heat Therapy or Massage Help with Post-Clavicle Fracture Recovery?
Could Improper Massage Techniques Lead to Nerve Damage?
Hello, doctor. During the pandemic, my mother felt unwell after carrying heavy objects and has been experiencing persistent headaches. She used an old handheld massager for full-body massage (not a fascia massage gun), and during the massage, she felt a sudden sense of panic with...
Dr. Jiang Junyi reply Neurology
Dear Ms. Hu, Your mother is likely over 65 years old, and if she is experiencing an atypical fracture at the junction of the shoulder and chest, it may be necessary to consider osteoporosis. An evaluation for an elderly patient should include: bone density testing, metabolic syn...[Read More] Could Improper Massage Techniques Lead to Nerve Damage?
Can a Hard Hit Cause a Fracture? Understanding Arm Injuries
Doctor, I bumped my forearm the day before yesterday, and it's very painful. It hurts when I press on it, but there's no bruising. Could there be a fracture? Can I apply a medicated patch? Is it okay to use Yao Guo (a type of topical ointment)?
Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
A contusion or impact injury can be very painful, and if the pain is severe enough to prevent movement or lifting the affected area, it may indicate a fracture. If movement is still possible without significant pain, a fracture is less likely. Generally, rest and medication can h...[Read More] Can a Hard Hit Cause a Fracture? Understanding Arm Injuries
Related FAQ
(Orthopedics)
Fracture Healing(Orthopedics)
Hand Fracture(Orthopedics)
Metatarsal Fracture(Orthopedics)
Clavicle Fracture(Orthopedics)
Toe Fractures(Orthopedics)
Pelvic Fracture(Orthopedics)
Fibula Fracture(Orthopedics)
Elbow Fracture(Orthopedics)
Closed Fracture(Orthopedics)