Choosing the Right Ceramic Hip Implant: Durability and Noise Concerns

Q: Choosing the Right Ceramic Hip Implant: Durability and Noise Concerns

There are two types of liners： ceramic liners and ultra-wear-resistant liners. <br>Both can use full ceramic materials, which may produce unusual sounds, whereas the ultra-wear-resistant plastic gasket liners do not. <br>The wear resistance of both types is quite similar.

Materials for artificial hip joints?

Hello Doctor, I have developmental dysplasia of my left hip joint, and over the past year, the pain while walking has significantly worsened.
The doctor at the hospital has recommended that I undergo ceramic total hip arthroplasty.
I researched that the latest ceramic hip joint is the fourth generation pink ceramic, but the liners are divided into ceramic liners and ultra-high molecular weight polyethylene liners.
Which combination of ceramic head and liner would be more durable? If I use a ceramic liner with a ceramic head, will it be prone to producing noise during movement?

hsieh, 40~49 year old female. Ask Date: 2016/08/12

Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics

There are two types of liners: ceramic liners and ultra-wear-resistant liners.
Both can use full ceramic materials, which may produce unusual sounds, whereas the ultra-wear-resistant plastic gasket liners do not.
The wear resistance of both types is quite similar.

Reply Date: 2016/08/12

More Info

When considering a ceramic hip implant, particularly in the context of your left hip joint issues due to developmental dysplasia, it’s essential to evaluate both durability and potential noise concerns associated with different implant configurations.
Ceramic hip implants have gained popularity due to their excellent wear resistance and biocompatibility. The latest advancements, such as the fourth-generation pink ceramic, have improved the mechanical properties and longevity of these implants. When discussing the combinations of ceramic heads and liners, there are a few key points to consider.

1. Durability of Ceramic Heads and Liners:
- Ceramic-on-Ceramic (CoC): This combination involves a ceramic head paired with a ceramic liner. While this configuration offers excellent wear resistance and low friction, it can sometimes lead to noise during movement, often described as a "clicking" or "popping" sound. This noise is generally not indicative of a problem but can be a nuisance for some patients. However, the durability of CoC implants is among the highest, making them a popular choice for younger, more active patients.

- Ceramic-on-Polyethylene (CoP): In this setup, a ceramic head is used with a highly cross-linked polyethylene liner. This combination tends to produce less noise compared to CoC implants and offers good durability while reducing the risk of squeaking. The polyethylene liner can absorb some of the forces and vibrations, potentially leading to a quieter experience. However, the wear rate of polyethylene, while improved, is still higher than that of ceramic.

2. Noise Concerns:
- As mentioned, ceramic-on-ceramic implants may produce noise during movement. This is due to the hard surfaces interacting with each other. Some patients report that the noise diminishes over time as the surfaces wear in. In contrast, ceramic-on-polyethylene configurations are less likely to produce significant noise, making them a more appealing option for those concerned about sound during movement.

3. Choosing the Right Combination:
- The choice between ceramic-on-ceramic and ceramic-on-polyethylene should be made based on your lifestyle, activity level, and personal preferences. If you are highly active and prioritize durability, a ceramic-on-ceramic implant may be suitable despite the potential for noise. If you prefer a quieter option and are less concerned about the absolute maximum durability, a ceramic-on-polyethylene implant could be the better choice.

4. Consultation with Your Surgeon:
- It is crucial to discuss these options with your orthopedic surgeon. They can provide insights based on your specific condition, activity level, and the latest advancements in hip implant technology. They will also consider factors such as your age, weight, and overall health, which can influence the longevity and performance of the implant.

In conclusion, both ceramic-on-ceramic and ceramic-on-polyethylene implants have their advantages and disadvantages. The ceramic-on-ceramic option is highly durable but may produce noise, while the ceramic-on-polyethylene option is quieter but may not offer the same level of wear resistance. Your orthopedic surgeon will be the best resource to help you make an informed decision based on your unique circumstances and preferences.

Similar Q&A

Are Ceramic Hip Implants Prone to Fracture? Insights for Young Patients

Dear Dr. Shi, I am scheduled to undergo total hip arthroplasty soon, and I have consulted several major hospitals regarding the surgical options. I have noticed that there are preferences for either ceramic or ultra-high molecular weight polyethylene (UHMWPE) materials. I am cur...

Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
Currently, the use of ceramic artificial joints is most prevalent in Europe. While they are indeed more wear-resistant, most clinical reports indicate that their lifespan is not very long. However, the issue of brittleness is not a significant concern. The trend is to use them in...

Choosing the Right Hip Implant Material: Ceramic vs. Metal for Young Patients

Dear Dr. Shih, I am the patient who asked you a question on March 2nd. I had a right hip arthroplasty with a ceramic prosthesis last June and am about to undergo surgery for a left hip arthroplasty. I would like to know which is more suitable for younger patients: ceramic hip pr...

Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
The purpose of both is to reduce wear, and currently, the follow-up duration is not as long as that of traditional artificial joints, making comparisons difficult. However, both theoretical and experimental evidence demonstrate that their wear is indeed less. Both are suitable fo...

Can X-rays Distinguish Between Ceramic and Metal Hip Implants?

Hello, doctor. My father had a ceramic hip joint replacement three months ago. The surgery was performed in the northern part of Taiwan, and we live in Taichung, so we went to a local hospital in Taichung for an X-ray to check the healing status of the bones and muscles post-surg...

Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
Some commonly used artificial hip joints can be roughly identified by their material and brand from X-rays, and experienced physicians can often recognize them at a glance. However, the quality of the material cannot be determined solely from X-rays.

Understanding Creaking Sounds After Hip Replacement: Causes and Solutions

Hello, doctor. I had a hip replacement 10 years ago (made of metal). Since last year, I've been experiencing a clicking sound when I move. I went back to the hospital where the surgery was performed for an X-ray, and the doctor indicated that there was no dislocation, but co...

Dr. Chen Yongxue reply Orthopedics
Hello, after ten years post artificial hip joint surgery, the noise may be due to bone proliferation or wear of the metal joint. Metal artificial hip joints were once very popular, but subsequent issues arose, primarily due to wear occurring at a greater extent than expected. Cur...