Switching Formula at One Year: Is Your Baby's Digestive Health Normal?

Switching to formula milk at one year old?

Originally, the baby was drinking hydrolyzed formula and has now switched to Karolotani milk powder at one year old.
Currently, the baby has bowel movements once or twice a day, and the transition to the new formula has resulted in somewhat loose stools, resembling a mixture between porridge and liquid, with yellow to golden colors.
The formula change has been ongoing for about two weeks.
Should we continue with this formula? Given that the baby typically has one bowel movement a day, is this considered normal? Should we continue with this brand or consider switching to another formula?

Bing'er, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2016/10/10

Dr. Xiao Kaiwen reply Pediatrics

If your baby’s stool has a significantly higher water content than their usual normal stools, it is defined as diarrhea.
If the diarrhea occurs due to an intolerance to a new formula, it typically happens within three days after the switch.
If you switch back to the original formula and the diarrhea resolves, but then reoccurs with a new formula, it may indicate an intolerance to the new formula.
In this case, you can try switching to a different brand of formula or continue using the old formula (there is no strict requirement to change formulas after the age of one).

Reply Date: 2016/10/10

More Info

When it comes to switching formula for a one-year-old, it’s essential to consider several factors related to your baby's digestive health and overall well-being. Based on your description, your baby has recently transitioned from a hydrolyzed formula (like Enfamil Nutramigen) to a new brand (like Karotani), and you are observing changes in bowel movements.
Firstly, it’s important to understand that changing a baby’s formula can lead to temporary digestive adjustments. The digestive system of infants is still maturing, and they can be sensitive to changes in their diet. The fact that your baby is having one to two bowel movements a day is generally within the normal range for a one-year-old. However, the consistency of the stools being somewhat loose or resembling a mix between liquid and porridge could indicate that your baby is experiencing mild diarrhea, especially if this is a new occurrence since the formula switch.

In terms of color, yellow to golden stools are typically normal for babies, especially those who are consuming a diet that includes both breast milk or formula and solid foods. However, if the stools are consistently watery or if there are other concerning symptoms such as fever, irritability, or signs of dehydration (like decreased urination or dry mouth), it would be prudent to consult your pediatrician.

Since you mentioned that you have been transitioning to the new formula for about two weeks, this is a reasonable timeframe to allow your baby’s digestive system to adjust. However, if the loose stools persist beyond this period or worsen, it may be wise to reconsider the formula choice. Some babies may not tolerate certain formulas well, and it could be beneficial to try a different brand or type of formula that is more suitable for your baby's digestive system.

In addition, when switching formulas, it is often recommended to do so gradually. This means mixing the new formula with the old one in increasing proportions over several days. This gradual transition can help minimize digestive upset. For example, you might start with a ratio of 25% new formula to 75% old formula, and then gradually increase the new formula to 50%, then 75%, and finally to 100% over a week or so.

It’s also essential to ensure that your baby is getting a balanced diet that includes a variety of solid foods, as this can help with digestion and overall health. At one year old, babies can start to eat more of the same foods as the rest of the family, focusing on whole foods that are rich in nutrients.

Lastly, if you are considering switching to another brand of formula, it might be helpful to consult with your pediatrician. They can provide personalized advice based on your baby's health history and current condition. They may also recommend specific formulas that are known to be gentle on the stomach or suitable for babies with sensitive digestive systems.

In summary, while one to two bowel movements a day can be normal, the consistency and any accompanying symptoms are crucial indicators of your baby's digestive health. If the loose stools persist or if you have any concerns, consulting your pediatrician is the best course of action to ensure your baby remains healthy and comfortable during this transition.

Similar Q&A

Switching from Lactose-Free to Regular Formula: Key Considerations for Parents

Hello Doctor: My baby is currently ten months old. He had diarrhea for over a month, and after seeing a doctor, he has been drinking lactose-free formula for about eight weeks. Two weeks ago, we stopped medication, and now he only takes probiotics (Bacillus coagulans) once a day....

Dr. Pei Rensheng reply Pediatrics
Hello, (1) Growth formula for children aged 1 to 3 years is not less nutritious than infant formula for those aged 6 to 12 months. Once a child turns one year old, they can start drinking the 1 to 3 years growth formula, which may even have a higher protein concentration compar...

Can I Switch My Baby's Formula Early Due to Constipation?

Hello, doctor: I would like to ask, my child is currently 11 months and 15 days old. He is experiencing constipation and is passing small, pellet-like stools. He is currently drinking Snow Brand formula for 0-12 months. I would like to switch him to Quaker's three probiotics...

Dr. Xiao Kaiwen reply Pediatrics
I think it should be fine. Of course, during the three days after the switch, pay attention to any gastrointestinal discomfort (usually diarrhea or skin rashes). If there are no significant adverse reactions, it should be okay. For infant constipation, increasing the intake of fi...

Switching from Hydrolyzed to Regular Formula: Pediatric Concerns

Dear Doctor: I was originally giving my child the Gold Nan En Hydrolyzed Formula No. 3 (occasionally experiencing constipation, so I have been giving probiotics to improve it). Since my child is almost 3 years old, I thought about trying a regular formula (the chain pharmacy ofte...

Dr. Zhang Yingwen reply Pediatrics
1. For a 1.3-year-old child, the diet is now closer to that of adults rather than being primarily milk-based. Therefore, milk is likely not the main cause of constipation. It is advisable to check if the intake of dietary fiber and fluids is sufficient for your child. 2. After ...

Can I Switch Back to Infant Formula for My 10-Month-Old?

My sister was born weighing 2400g, and now at ten months old, she weighs approximately 8600g. Since switching to a larger infant formula at six months, she has been experiencing constipation. I would like to know if I can switch her back to the infant formula for 0-6 months. She ...

Dr. Zhang Yingwen reply Pediatrics
1. It is possible to switch back to infant formula for a ten-month-old baby; however, the issue of constipation at this stage is not solely related to the formula but is more associated with the intake of vegetables, fruits, and fiber. If constipation is severe, it is important t...