Silicone Sheets vs. Scar Gel: Best Options for Burn Wound Care

Wound care for burns?

Hello, I recently suffered a burn from a motorcycle exhaust pipe, and I am currently using artificial skin on the wound, which is healing well.
To avoid scarring after the wound heals, would you recommend using silicone sheets or scar gel? What are the differences in the timing and suitability of silicone sheets and scar gel for different types of wounds?

Liao Xiaojie, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2016/10/11

Dr. Wu Yuxin reply Dermatology

Silicone sheets and scar gels have the same function; for areas that are difficult to adhere to, it is recommended to use scar gel.

Reply Date: 2016/10/11

More Info

When it comes to managing burn wounds and preventing scarring, both silicone sheets and scar gels are effective options, but they serve slightly different purposes and have unique applications. Understanding the differences between these two modalities can help you make an informed decision about which one might be best for your situation.

Silicone Sheets: These are thin, flexible sheets made from silicone that are applied directly to the healed skin. They work by creating a moist environment that promotes healing while also providing a protective barrier against external irritants. Silicone sheets are particularly effective for raised scars (hypertrophic scars and keloids) and are often recommended for use after the wound has fully healed, typically around 2-3 weeks post-injury. They should be worn for several hours a day, and consistent use over a period of weeks to months can significantly improve the appearance of scars.

Scar Gel: Scar gels, on the other hand, are topical treatments that can be applied directly to the scarred area. They often contain silicone as a primary ingredient, but may also include other components like vitamins or botanical extracts aimed at enhancing skin healing. Scar gels can be used on both fresh and mature scars, making them versatile. They are typically applied multiple times a day and can be massaged into the scar tissue, which may help to soften and flatten the scar over time.

When to Use Each:
- Silicone Sheets are best used once the wound has closed and is no longer weeping or oozing. They are ideal for larger areas or when you want to cover a significant scar. They can be particularly beneficial for scars that are raised or have the potential to become hypertrophic.

- Scar Gels can be used earlier in the healing process, as they can be applied to fresh scars. They are also more suitable for smaller areas or when you need a more flexible option that can be easily applied and removed.

Combination Use: In some cases, using both silicone sheets and scar gel can be beneficial. For instance, you might start with a scar gel on a fresh wound to promote healing and then transition to silicone sheets once the wound has closed. This combination can maximize the benefits of both treatments.

Additional Considerations:
- Always ensure that the wound is clean and dry before applying any treatment.
- If you notice any signs of infection, such as increased redness, swelling, or discharge, it’s important to consult a healthcare professional.

- The duration of treatment can vary; some individuals may see improvements within a few weeks, while others may require several months of consistent use.

In conclusion, both silicone sheets and scar gels are effective in managing scars from burn wounds. The choice between the two will depend on the stage of healing, the size and type of the scar, and personal preference. Consulting with a healthcare provider or a dermatologist can provide personalized recommendations based on your specific situation and needs.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Scar Treatment Options After Burns: Gels vs. Ointments

Hello Doctor: I had a burn with blisters a month ago, and I have been using artificial skin since then. The wound is healing, and the skin is red. I wear long pants and skirts for sun protection. I would like to ask about scar removal products, specifically the differences betwee...

Dr. Wu Yuxin reply Dermatology
It mainly depends on the area affected. If it is a joint, it is recommended to use ointments or gels rather than adhesive patches, as they may not adhere well.

Beauty Gels vs. Silicone Strips: Which is Better for Scar Healing?

Hello Dr. Lu: I would like to ask which is better for surgical scars, beauty gel or silicone tape, in order to make them less noticeable. Thank you.

Dr. Lu Daokuan reply Plastic Surgery
Beauty gels provide tension to the wound, making it less likely for scars to widen, while silicone adds compressive force. Silicone is more effective but is less convenient to use and tends to be more expensive.

Can Scar Creams Be Used on Cancer Surgery Wounds?

Hello, my wound has been healing for over a year (the wound from breast cancer). I used silicone gel sheets for about six months, but after that, the scar became red and thick, and sometimes it itches. I want to apply scar ointment but I'm worried about potential side effect...

Dr. Xu Wenming reply Pharmacology
Hello: Regarding the situation where a wound scar becomes red and thick, it is similar to a keloid after surgery. It is recommended to continue using silicone gel sheets or applying scar ointment, such as the scar gel you mentioned, or to return to the clinic to consult with a su...

Choosing the Right Scar Treatment After an Injury: A Guide

I previously had an injury and want to remove the scar, but there are many types available on the market, and I'm unsure which one to buy. Would it be better if I visit a dermatologist at the hospital to get a scar removal ointment? There are two types of scars: raised and f...

Dr. Lin Xinpeng reply Dermatology
Hello: I'm not sure what type of scar you are referring to. Scars can generally be classified into atrophic scars and hypertrophic scars. Currently, there are no effective topical medications for atrophic scars. For hypertrophic scars, scar gels or silicone sheets can be use...