Clavicle Fractures: When Is Surgery Necessary?

Clavicle fracture?

Hello Doctor: I was in a car accident on October 27, 2016, and was taken to the emergency room where it was discovered that I had a fractured clavicle.
The doctor mentioned that surgery was not immediately necessary and that we would reassess with an X-ray at my next appointment.
If there was displacement, surgery would be required.
I was instructed to wear a figure-eight brace and a sling.
Today, on November 3, 2016, I returned for a follow-up and the X-ray showed displacement.
The doctor informed me that surgery could be performed, but it was not mandatory, and I should continue wearing the figure-eight brace and sling.
However, when I got home and tried to take a shower, I noticed a sharp, intermittent pain in my clavicle, along with a tight sensation in that area.
I would like to ask if this is normal.
Do you think surgery is necessary? What defines the need for surgery? I would appreciate your guidance as I am a bit anxious about the possibility of not having surgery and ending up with a noticeable bump, and I am concerned about potential long-term effects.

Mr. Shi, 10~19 year old female. Ask Date: 2016/11/03

Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics

Both surgical and non-surgical treatments for clavicle fractures can result in some prominence, which typically does not affect the long-term outcome and usually does not lead to significant complications.
A figure-eight brace should be worn for approximately two to three months until healing occurs.

Reply Date: 2016/11/03

More Info

Clavicle fractures, commonly known as collarbone fractures, are a frequent consequence of trauma, such as falls or vehicle accidents. Understanding when surgical intervention is necessary can be crucial for optimal recovery. Based on your situation, where you experienced a clavicle fracture on October 27, 2016, and subsequent X-rays revealed displacement, let’s delve into the considerations surrounding surgical options and the implications of your symptoms.

When is Surgery Necessary?
The decision to proceed with surgery for a clavicle fracture typically hinges on several factors:
1. Degree of Displacement: If the fracture is significantly displaced, meaning the bone ends are not aligned, surgery may be recommended. This is particularly true if the displacement is causing functional impairment or if the fracture is at risk of nonunion (failure to heal properly).

2. Type of Fracture: Clavicle fractures can be classified into three types based on their location:
- Type I: Fractures occurring in the middle third of the clavicle, which are the most common and often treated conservatively.

- Type II: Fractures at the lateral end (near the shoulder), which may require surgical intervention if displaced.

- Type III: Fractures at the medial end (near the sternum), which may also necessitate surgery depending on the displacement and associated injuries.

3. Patient Factors: Age, activity level, and overall health can influence the decision. Younger, more active individuals may benefit from surgical fixation to restore function and minimize long-term complications.

4. Symptoms and Pain: Persistent pain, especially if it worsens with movement or is accompanied by a feeling of instability, may indicate that surgical intervention is warranted.

Your Current Symptoms
You mentioned experiencing intermittent sharp pain and a tight sensation in the area of the fracture. While some discomfort is expected during the healing process, especially in the initial weeks, the nature of your pain could be indicative of several things:
- Healing Process: As the bone heals, it can be normal to experience pain, particularly if you are moving the shoulder or arm. However, if the pain is sharp and persistent, it may warrant further evaluation.

- Potential Complications: If the fracture is not healing properly or if there is significant displacement, you might be at risk for complications such as malunion (healing in an incorrect position) or nonunion.

Should You Consider Surgery?
Given that your X-ray results indicate displacement and you are experiencing notable discomfort, it is essential to weigh the benefits of surgery against the risks of conservative management. Here are some considerations:
- Surgical Benefits: Surgery can provide better alignment of the bone, potentially leading to a more stable and functional shoulder. It may also reduce the risk of long-term complications, such as a prominent bump at the fracture site (often referred to as a "bony prominence").

- Risks of Surgery: As with any surgical procedure, there are risks involved, including infection, nerve damage, and complications related to anesthesia. However, these risks are generally low and must be balanced against the potential for improved outcomes.

Conclusion
In summary, the decision to proceed with surgery for your clavicle fracture should be made in consultation with your orthopedic surgeon, who can assess the specifics of your fracture, your symptoms, and your overall health. If your pain persists or worsens, or if you have concerns about the healing process, it is crucial to communicate these to your healthcare provider. They may recommend further imaging or a referral to a specialist to discuss the potential for surgical intervention. Remember, the goal is to ensure proper healing and restore function, so do not hesitate to advocate for your health and seek clarity on your treatment options.

Similar Q&A

Do You Need Surgery for Clavicle Fractures? Expert Insights

Hello Dr. Shih: I suffered bilateral clavicle fractures in a car accident in mid-October and had previously consulted with you. The two X-rays of my clavicles are shown in the links above. I would like to ask if surgery is necessary for either side of my clavicles. If surgery is ...

Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
A clavicle fracture can be treated either surgically or conservatively, and you should discuss the options with your attending physician before making a decision. Typically, after healing, you can resume movement, which usually takes about three months.

Left Clavicle Fracture: Surgery Options and Recovery Timeline

On May 7th, I fractured my left clavicle due to a motorcycle accident. Since I am still in military service and have only one week left until my discharge, I am currently using a sling for stabilization. I have not yet had a second examination to determine if surgery is necessary...

Dr. Chen Yongxue reply Orthopedics
Hello, a clavicle fracture does not always require surgery to heal. Surgery is typically necessary in certain situations, such as open fractures, comminuted fractures, inability to use a figure-of-eight bandage, multiple fractures, or if there is compression of nerves or blood ve...

Clavicle Fracture: To Operate or Not? Understanding Risks and Recovery

Hello Dr. Shi: My friend had a car accident on June 2, resulting in a fractured clavicle. The doctor mentioned that surgery is optional, but undergoing surgery would require general anesthesia, which carries risks. Therefore, he returned home on his own. Another friend also had a...

Dr. Chen Xingyuan reply Orthopedics
Dear Ms. Hong, Surgical intervention for a clavicle fracture is necessary in cases of open fractures, associated neurovascular injuries, mid-shaft clavicle fractures with significant displacement, fractures with ends nearly penetrating the skin becoming open fractures, distal cl...

Do You Need Surgery for a Mid-Clavicle Fracture at Age 55?

A family member fell from a high bed on July 3rd and sustained a fracture of the right clavicle, approximately in the midshaft region. They are 55 years old and would like to know if surgery is necessary.

Dr. Wang Shouji reply Orthopedics
Hello, for a midshaft clavicle fracture, if the pain and discomfort are such that you cannot tolerate a displacement of more than 1 centimeter, surgery is recommended. Changhua Hospital cares about your health. Sincerely, Dr. Wang Shou-ji.