Emotional instability
My attending physician has advised me to discontinue my medication, and I would like to understand the reasons behind this decision.
1: I am under 24 years old, and there is a risk of impulsivity when taking psychiatric medications.
2: I have not experienced improvement after taking the medication for eight months, during which I had a break of one and a half months.
3: The doctor mentioned that not only has there been no improvement, but the medication may also cause a range of side effects, and suggested switching to psychotherapy.
Recently, I consulted a new physician who provided advice, as I am concerned about the possibility of a depressive episode and suicidal thoughts.
Consequently, I requested the doctor to prescribe Xanax and Loxapine orally disintegrating tablets.
Niming, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2016/11/11
Dr. Liang Sunyuan reply Psychiatry
Hello: Since your physician knows your condition best, it is recommended to discuss these questions in person with your doctor, as this would be the best approach.
Wishing you well.
Reply Date: 2016/11/11
More Info
Discontinuing medication in mental health treatment is a significant decision that should be made with careful consideration and professional guidance. Your concerns about the reasons provided by your physician for discontinuing medication are valid and deserve a thorough exploration.
1. Age and Impulsivity: The concern regarding impulsivity in individuals under 24 years of age is rooted in research indicating that the brain continues to develop into the mid-20s. This ongoing development can influence decision-making and emotional regulation. While it is true that some psychiatric medications, particularly stimulants or certain antidepressants, may exacerbate impulsivity in younger patients, it is essential to assess the specific medication you are taking and its effects on your mental health. If your medication has been effective in managing your symptoms, this concern should be weighed against the benefits you have experienced.
2. Lack of Improvement: The fact that you have not noticed significant improvement after eight months of medication is a critical factor. It is not uncommon for patients to experience a trial-and-error process when it comes to finding the right medication. If you have also experienced a break in your medication regimen, this could have contributed to the lack of improvement. Consistency in medication is often crucial for effectiveness. If your current medication has not yielded results, it may be reasonable for your physician to consider alternative treatments, including psychotherapy.
3. Side Effects vs. Benefits: Your physician's point about the potential for side effects outweighing the benefits of medication is a common consideration in psychiatric treatment. Many psychiatric medications can have side effects that impact quality of life, and if the medication is not effectively managing symptoms, the rationale for continuing it diminishes. It is essential to have an open dialogue with your physician about the specific side effects you are experiencing and how they compare to your symptoms.
4. Transition to Psychotherapy: Transitioning to psychotherapy can be a beneficial approach, especially if medication has not been effective. Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) and other therapeutic modalities can provide tools to manage symptoms, develop coping strategies, and address underlying issues contributing to your mental health condition. However, it is crucial to ensure that you have a supportive therapeutic relationship and that you feel comfortable with the therapist you choose.
5. Concerns About Depression and Suicidal Thoughts: Your fear of experiencing a depressive episode or suicidal thoughts is a serious concern that should not be overlooked. If you are feeling overwhelmed or hopeless, it is vital to communicate this to your healthcare provider. They may consider a more gradual tapering of your medication rather than an abrupt discontinuation, especially if you have a history of severe symptoms. Additionally, having a safety plan in place and regular check-ins with your healthcare provider can help mitigate these risks.
In conclusion, the decision to discontinue medication should be made collaboratively with your healthcare provider, taking into account your unique circumstances, treatment history, and current mental health status. It is essential to voice your concerns and preferences, as well as to explore all available treatment options, including medication adjustments and psychotherapy. If you feel uncertain about your current treatment plan, seeking a second opinion from another mental health professional can also provide additional insights and reassurance. Remember, your mental health is a priority, and finding the right balance of treatment is crucial for your well-being.
Similar Q&A
Understanding Medication Management in Psychiatry: Key Questions Answered
Hello, Doctor: 1. If psychiatric medication is discontinued and the person becomes ill again, does that mean they have to start over? For example, if they were originally supposed to take medication for two years and stopped after a year and a half, only to become ill again, do...
Dr. Liang Sunyuan reply Psychiatry
Hello Jessie, Here are my suggestions: 1. If psychiatric medication is discontinued and the individual becomes ill again, does this mean starting over? For instance, if the medication was initially required for two years but was stopped after one and a half years, would the ind...[Read More] Understanding Medication Management in Psychiatry: Key Questions Answered
Understanding Medication Management in Schizophrenia: Risks of Stopping Treatment
If a patient with schizophrenia (auditory hallucinations) stops their medication, it may lead to a relapse characterized by the re-emergence of symptoms such as hallucinations, delusions, and disorganized thinking. The severity and timing of the relapse can vary among individuals...
Dr. Chen Guangpeng reply Psychiatry
Dear Chen, I am glad to hear from you again. Unfortunately, it seems you are still at a standstill—hesitating over whether to take medication or to stop it. In fact, you have asked similar questions on November 19, 23, and 27, and I have done my best to respond to you. Perhaps i...[Read More] Understanding Medication Management in Schizophrenia: Risks of Stopping Treatment
Navigating Mental Health: A Personal Journey Through Depression and Treatment
Doctor Liu: Hello, I have been dealing with depression for over two years, intermittently receiving treatment. In the past, many friends in the medical field, as well as others, advised me against seeing a psychiatrist, claiming that medication would worsen my condition or that i...
Dr. Liu Guangqi reply Psychiatry
When you stop taking psychiatric medications, you really feel unwell, and this is a problem that must be taken seriously and addressed. It may take some time, and the methods used may change frequently. You might consult different doctors, and what they say may vary somewhat, but...[Read More] Navigating Mental Health: A Personal Journey Through Depression and Treatment
Struggling to Quit: My 6-Year Journey with Psychiatric Medication
Since 2017, I have been taking psychiatric medication. Initially, I sought help from a psychiatrist due to severe stress and insomnia. After about two years on the medication, I attempted to quit but was unable to do so and resumed taking the medication. During this time, I discu...
Dr. Li Guanying reply Psychiatry
From your letter, it is clear that you are experiencing discomfort and distress due to insomnia and the pressure of medication. 1. Facing an uncertain future, psychosomatic disorders are common in modern society. This is a chronic condition that requires long-term treatment for...[Read More] Struggling to Quit: My 6-Year Journey with Psychiatric Medication
Related FAQ
(Psychiatry)
Involuntary Psychiatric Treatment(Psychiatry)
Compulsory Medical Treatment(Psychiatry)
Smoking Cessation(Psychiatry)
Psychiatric Care(Psychiatry)
Anti-Anxiety Medication(Psychiatry)
Sleeping Pills(Psychiatry)
Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy(Psychiatry)
Heartbreak(Psychiatry)
Consultation(Psychiatry)