Regarding issue #116219, after undergoing surgery on the first lumbar vertebra, is it necessary to perform minimally invasive surgery to remove it after one year?
Hello Dr.
Lai: First of all, thank you for being willing to respond to my questions.
You are truly knowledgeable and have identified that I have a burst fracture at the L1 vertebra.
If you determine that the bone has healed after a year, would you recommend removal? Additionally, what do you mean by "specific circumstances"? I had a car accident in Shengang, and I have forgotten the details due to a brain injury, so I apologize for asking you so many questions.
I was later sent to a hospital in Changhua.
Will I need rehabilitation after the removal? Do I need to wear a brace, or is there something else I should do to protect my spine? Some people say that having metal implants means I don't need to have it removed, which is quite confusing! Thank you for your hard work in addressing my complicated issues! Haha, I really appreciate it!
Bao Liú, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2016/12/13
Dr. Lai Zhaokang reply Neurosurgery
Hello,
1.
Generally, there is no need to remove the hardware, but if, for example, the screws have loosened, or if they are too rigid and causing discomfort, or for other reasons as determined by the physician, they can be removed.
2.
Typically, if it is confirmed that the bone has healed and fused properly, it is safer to remove the hardware and wear a back brace for 3 months afterward.
If there is no discomfort, there is no need to intentionally pursue rehabilitation.
3.
Some materials, such as titanium screws, generally do not need to be removed.
Best wishes to you.
Reply Date: 2016/12/13
More Info
Post-surgery considerations for lumbar spine surgery, particularly regarding the removal of hardware, are crucial for both patient recovery and long-term health. In your case, where you have experienced a lumbar spine fracture due to a car accident, it is understandable that you have many questions about the implications of hardware removal and the recovery process.
When to Consider Hardware Removal
The decision to remove hardware, such as screws and rods used in spinal fusion or stabilization procedures, typically depends on several factors:
1. Bone Healing: If the bone has healed adequately, as confirmed by imaging studies (like X-rays or CT scans), and there are no signs of instability, the hardware may be considered for removal. Generally, this is evaluated around 6 months to a year post-surgery.
2. Symptoms: If you continue to experience significant discomfort, pain, or neurological symptoms (like numbness or weakness), it may indicate that the hardware is causing issues, such as irritation to surrounding tissues or nerves. In such cases, removal might be warranted.
3. Infection or Complications: If there is an infection or other complications related to the hardware, removal may be necessary to prevent further issues.
4. Patient Preference: Some patients may prefer to have the hardware removed for peace of mind, especially if they feel it is causing discomfort.
Specific Situations for Hardware Removal
Specific situations that might necessitate hardware removal include:
- Persistent Pain: If pain persists despite adequate healing, it may be due to hardware irritation.
- Hardware Failure: If the screws or rods become loose or break, they may need to be removed or replaced.
- Neurological Symptoms: If there are new or worsening neurological symptoms, such as weakness or bowel/bladder dysfunction, this could indicate that the hardware is affecting the spinal cord or nerves.
Post-Removal Considerations
After hardware removal, rehabilitation is often necessary. This may include:
- Physical Therapy: To strengthen the muscles around the spine and improve flexibility.
- Activity Modification: You may need to avoid certain activities that could stress the spine during the healing process.
Protective Measures
Regarding protective measures post-surgery, wearing a brace (often referred to as a "back brace" or "spinal orthosis") may be recommended, especially in the early stages of recovery. This can help stabilize the spine and prevent excessive movement that could jeopardize healing.
Long-Term Considerations
It's also important to understand that some patients may have hardware left in place indefinitely without issues. The decision to remove hardware should be made collaboratively with your healthcare provider, considering your specific situation, overall health, and recovery progress.
Conclusion
In summary, the decision to remove spinal hardware should be based on thorough evaluation of bone healing, symptomatology, and potential complications. If you are experiencing ongoing issues, it is essential to communicate these with your healthcare provider, who can guide you through the decision-making process and recommend appropriate follow-up care, including rehabilitation and protective measures. Always feel free to ask questions and express your concerns, as understanding your treatment plan is vital for your recovery.
Similar Q&A
Post-Discectomy: Should My Boyfriend Have His Hardware Removed?
My boyfriend underwent minimally invasive surgery for a herniated disc on July 11 of last year due to lower back pain and leg numbness. After the surgery, he still experiences lower back discomfort. He is now hesitant about whether to have the screws removed, as even the doctors ...
Dr. Zhang Junwei reply Neurosurgery
Why is it necessary to perform spinal fusion? Is it due to lumbar spondylolisthesis? If the purpose of the procedure is not clear, it is not advisable to remove the hardware casually![Read More] Post-Discectomy: Should My Boyfriend Have His Hardware Removed?
Should You Remove Titanium Screws After Spinal Surgery?
Hello Dr. Shi: I underwent L3 vertebral fracture fixation and L3-L4 discectomy on November 16 last year, and I have titanium fixation screws. Should I have surgery to remove them? Additionally, there is a disc at L5-S1; should that be addressed as well? Thank you.
Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
Typically, the screws used after a discectomy do not need to be removed. If there are no specific issues or symptoms related to the L5-S1 disc, there is no need to intervene with them.[Read More] Should You Remove Titanium Screws After Spinal Surgery?
Post-Surgery Concerns: Can I Remove Screws After Lumbar Fusion?
Hello Doctor: I underwent fusion surgery on my lumbar spine at L4, L5, and S1 in 2015, where 6 screws were implanted. The protruding parts at L4 and L5 were removed, and a spacer was placed at L5-S1. I still feel discomfort post-surgery. I have a sensation that the screws are pre...
Dr. Lai Zhaokang reply Neurosurgery
Hello, 1. If the implanted spacer has fused, the fixation screws may be considered for removal. 2. What you are feeling as a protrusion needs to be evaluated in person. It is advisable to consult an experienced spine neurosurgeon for an examination. 3. Can the spacer displace...[Read More] Post-Surgery Concerns: Can I Remove Screws After Lumbar Fusion?
Post-Spinal Surgery Pain: Could Screws Be the Culprit?
Hello, my mother underwent minimally invasive spinal surgery last year, during which a brace and six screws were implanted. However, nearly six months post-surgery, she still experiences persistent lower back pain and a sensation of foreign objects. Could the screws be causing th...
Dr. Chen Bochen reply Orthopedics
Hello, there are several possible causes for discomfort after spinal surgery: 1. Postoperative muscle weakness, which generally requires rehabilitation, nutritional supplementation, and personal exercise. 2. The area that was not operated on may still have issues, such as pre-exi...[Read More] Post-Spinal Surgery Pain: Could Screws Be the Culprit?
Related FAQ
(Neurosurgery)
Post-Discectomy(Neurosurgery)
Lumbar Spondylolisthesis(Neurosurgery)
Sciatica(Neurosurgery)
Coccyx(Neurosurgery)
Post-Spinal Surgery(Orthopedics)
Back(Neurosurgery)
Post-Spinal Surgery(Rehabilitation)
Posterior Head(Neurosurgery)
Lumbar Fracture(Orthopedics)