Is Acid Etching Enough? Concerns About Incomplete Cavity Treatment

The dental filling was not properly performed, and the decay was not thoroughly removed?

Hello doctor, I have a cavity on the surface of my tooth.
During the filling process, the dentist did not remove the decayed part but directly applied a bonding agent using an etching method for about 30 seconds, then asked me to rinse my mouth without rinsing with water or drying the area properly.
The filling is now done, and I would like to ask if it is acceptable to use the etching method without removing the decayed part.
Will the agent continue to erode the tooth since it wasn't properly rinsed? Also, since the decayed part was not thoroughly removed, will it continue to decay in the future? I hope you can clarify my concerns.

Nǐ hǎ, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2017/01/04

Dr. Zeng Guanghui reply Dentistry

After a dental filling for surface caries, I feel that the process did not adequately remove the decayed portion of the tooth and only applied a medicament (acid etching method).
If the main part of the tooth was not thoroughly cleaned, there is a possibility of recurrent decay in the future.
It is advisable to return for a follow-up appointment for further examination by a dentist.

Reply Date: 2017/01/04

More Info

When it comes to dental treatments, particularly for cavities, it is crucial to ensure that the procedure is thorough and effective. Acid etching is a common technique used in dentistry, especially in the context of preparing a tooth surface for bonding materials, such as sealants or composite fillings. However, it is important to understand that acid etching alone is not sufficient for treating cavities, especially if there is active decay present.

In your case, it seems that the dentist opted for a less invasive approach by applying a membrane agent directly over the cavity without removing the decayed tooth structure. While this method may be appropriate in certain situations, such as for very early-stage caries (decay), it raises several concerns:
1. Incomplete Removal of Decay: If the decayed portion of the tooth was not adequately removed, there is a significant risk that the cavity will continue to progress. Bacteria can thrive in the decayed area, leading to further deterioration of the tooth structure. This could result in the need for more extensive treatment in the future, such as a root canal or extraction.

2. Acid Etching Process: Acid etching is typically used to create a rough surface on the enamel, allowing for better adhesion of restorative materials. However, if the tooth surface is not properly cleaned and dried after etching, residual acid or moisture can interfere with the bonding process. This could compromise the effectiveness of the treatment and potentially lead to future complications.

3. Potential for Continued Decay: Without proper cleaning and removal of the decayed tissue, the cavity may continue to progress. This could lead to further pain, sensitivity, or even infection. It is essential to monitor the tooth for any signs of worsening decay, such as increased sensitivity or visible changes in the tooth structure.

4. Follow-Up Care: It is advisable to schedule a follow-up appointment with your dentist to discuss your concerns. They may recommend further evaluation, including X-rays, to assess the extent of the decay and determine if additional treatment is necessary. If the cavity is still present, the dentist may need to remove the decayed tissue and restore the tooth properly.

In summary, while acid etching is a valuable tool in dental procedures, it should not be the sole method for treating cavities. Proper diagnosis and treatment planning are essential to ensure the long-term health of your teeth. If you have concerns about the adequacy of your treatment, do not hesitate to seek a second opinion or further evaluation from your dentist. Your oral health is paramount, and addressing any issues early on can prevent more significant problems down the line.

Similar Q&A

Revolutionary Dental Treatment: Cavities Fixed with a Simple Injection

I'm sorry, but I can't access external websites or verify specific articles. However, if you have any questions about dental treatments or technologies related to cavity treatment, feel free to ask!

Dr. Yang Zhiren reply Dentistry
Hello, according to reports, this technology is feasible. It is currently unknown when Taiwan will introduce this acidic gel. Generally, dental fillings for cavities are covered by health insurance, but if this material is very expensive, it may require out-of-pocket expenses. Dr...

Understanding Follow-Up Dental Treatments for Cavities and Misalignment

I have cavities between my two front teeth, with the one on the right being more decayed. The right tooth is also slightly misaligned, overlapping the left tooth. Can this be fixed without orthodontics? If I remove the overlapping part and fill it, will the tooth still be non-vit...

Dr. Zeng Guanghui reply Dentistry
Hello Sir: Thank you for your inquiry. I would like to address your question and provide the following recommendations: The overlapping of your two front teeth may indicate misalignment in your dental arch, making oral hygiene difficult and potentially leading to cavities between...

Addressing Uneven Dental Fillings in Upper Molars: Concerns and Solutions

Hello Doctor, I have a cavity on the side of my upper left premolar, specifically in the interproximal area, which extends into the gum tissue above. The size of the cavity is classified as medium to large. After receiving a composite resin filling at the clinic, I have not exper...

Dr. Lin Jiayong reply Dentistry
Hello, I will answer your three questions as follows. Cavities below the gums are indeed quite challenging to fill with composite resin, as controlling the shape of the margins is particularly difficult (because resin is very moisture-sensitive before it hardens). Therefore, if...

How to Treat Cavities Between Teeth Without Compromising Structure?

If there is a cavity between the teeth, how should it be treated? I noticed that the dentist drills a large hole from the occlusal surface, which seems to waste a lot of tooth structure. Could this lead to the tooth being hollow or incomplete? Thank you.

Dr. Zeng Guanghui reply Dentistry
Cavities in the interproximal areas should be assessed based on their size and whether they have invaded the pulp chamber. For small interproximal cavities, they can be treated with a filling. Typically, the procedure involves accessing the cavity from the occlusal surface to tho...