Can Pregnancy Tests Be Inaccurate? Rare Cases

Can pregnancy tests be inaccurate?

In the United States and the United Kingdom, there have been cases where doctors were unable to detect pregnancy despite clear signs such as fetal movement or pregnancy symptoms.
Even with ultrasound and blood tests, the results were completely negative, and some women continued to have their menstrual periods.
One individual from a non-profit organization mentioned that she is experiencing such a situation; no matter how many pregnancy tests she takes, they all come back negative, even though she feels fetal movement and has abdominal swelling.
She has been pregnant for over two years, approaching three years, and is still continuing her pregnancy.
When I asked her why it cannot be detected, she said it is because her intestines are obstructing the view.
I inquired about blood tests and urine tests, and she explained that because her endometrium is continuously shedding, her hCG levels cannot rise, making it undetectable.

Is it really possible for such a situation to occur? She stated that many people in the world are facing this issue, yet there seems to be no news coverage or articles from doctors addressing this problem.
If what she claims is true, is it really possible for individuals in this situation to carry a pregnancy for 3 to 5 years? She sent me some videos that appear to show fetal movement, which has left me very confused.

I am concerned about this topic because I have been experiencing irregular menstrual cycles, with three consecutive instances of abnormal bleeding that do not resemble a typical menstrual period.
However, blood tests, urine tests, and vaginal ultrasounds have all returned negative results, and doctors have not identified any abnormalities.
I am worried that I might be in a similar situation, but I cannot find any discussions in Chinese about this topic online, and the English resources are limited to a few parenting websites and the organization she is affiliated with.
This has left me feeling quite troubled and anxious, and I hope a doctor can provide some answers.
Thank you.

Niming, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2017/03/14

Dr. Zhang Kunmin reply Obstetrics and Gynecology

A physician must not administer treatment, prescribe medication, or provide a diagnosis without a personal examination.
Hello, based on your description, it is advisable to consult with a physician for an examination before discussing and seeking further advice.
Thank you! Wishing you peace and health.
Dr.
Chang

Reply Date: 2017/03/14

More Info

Pregnancy tests, both urine and blood tests, are generally reliable methods for detecting pregnancy. However, there are rare cases where these tests can yield false negatives, leading to a phenomenon known as "cryptic pregnancy." This term refers to a situation where a woman is unaware of her pregnancy until late in the gestation period, sometimes even until labor.
In the scenarios you described, it is indeed possible for a woman to experience symptoms of pregnancy—such as fetal movement and abdominal changes—while still receiving negative results on pregnancy tests. This can occur for several reasons:
1. Low hCG Levels: Human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG) is the hormone produced during pregnancy, and its levels can vary significantly among individuals. In some cases, a woman may have a very low level of hCG that is not detectable by standard tests, especially in the early stages of pregnancy. If the hormone levels are insufficient, it may not trigger a positive result on urine or blood tests.

2. Irregular Menstrual Cycles: Women with irregular menstrual cycles may misinterpret their symptoms or the timing of their periods. If a woman experiences light bleeding or spotting, she might mistake it for a regular menstrual period, which can further complicate the situation.

3. Medical Conditions: Certain medical conditions, such as ectopic pregnancies or hormonal imbalances, can also lead to atypical pregnancy symptoms and negative test results. In some cases, conditions like polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS) can affect hormone levels and menstrual cycles, leading to confusion about pregnancy status.

4. Obscured Ultrasound Results: As mentioned in your query, anatomical factors such as bowel obstruction could potentially obscure ultrasound imaging, making it difficult for healthcare providers to detect a pregnancy. However, this is quite rare.

5. Psychological Factors: In some instances, psychological factors may lead women to believe they are experiencing pregnancy symptoms without a physiological basis. This can create a complex interplay between perception and reality.

While the stories of women experiencing cryptic pregnancies are compelling, they remain rare. The medical community generally recognizes that while pregnancy tests can occasionally fail, the combination of negative tests, ultrasound findings, and blood tests typically provides a reliable indication of whether a woman is pregnant.
If you are experiencing irregular bleeding and have received negative results from multiple pregnancy tests, it is essential to consult with a healthcare provider. They can perform a thorough evaluation, including additional blood tests and imaging studies, to determine the underlying cause of your symptoms.
In conclusion, while cryptic pregnancies can occur, they are not common, and the vast majority of pregnancies can be detected through standard testing methods. If you have concerns about your menstrual irregularities or potential pregnancy, seeking medical advice is crucial for your health and peace of mind.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Pregnancy Test Accuracy: Common Errors and Misconceptions

Hello Dr. Lu, I bought two different brands of pregnancy tests and had my girlfriend take them on the 16th and 22nd days, both showing negative results. Is it possible that the results are due to incorrect usage or that the pregnancy tests are not accurate? Thank you for your res...

Dr. Lü Lizheng reply Obstetrics and Gynecology
Under normal circumstances, if used correctly, the probability of a pregnancy test being inaccurate is only 1%. The likelihood of it being inaccurate twice in a row is just 0.01%. Therefore, you should trust the results of the pregnancy test, which indicates that you are not preg...

Are Home Pregnancy Tests Accurate? Understanding Your Symptoms

Since my period is more than 3 days late, I bought a pregnancy test but it came back negative. However, my breasts are swollen and painful, I feel very tired and want to sleep, and my lower back hurts. I'm not sure what's going on. How accurate are pregnancy tests?

Dr. Wang Jionglang reply Obstetrics and Gynecology
Hello Ms. Chi Wei-Chun: The accuracy of pregnancy tests can be as high as 99.9%. When a woman becomes pregnant, her body produces a special hormone called human chorionic gonadotropin, abbreviated as HCG. This hormone appears in the urine of pregnant women, and testing for the pr...

Understanding Pregnancy Test Accuracy: Your Questions Answered

Hello doctor, I have a question. I had sexual intercourse on the night of August 26, and yesterday, August 31, around 6 PM, I bought a pregnancy test kit and tested it. After about six minutes, there was only one very clear red line. I read online that a pregnancy test can be acc...

Dr. Huang Jianzhong reply Obstetrics and Gynecology
On the evening of August 26, there was sexual intercourse. Yesterday, on August 31, around six o'clock, a pregnancy test was purchased and used. After about six minutes, there was only one very clear red line. I read online that a pregnancy test can be accurate as early as s...

Pregnancy Testing: Accuracy and Related Concerns During Early Stages

Hello, can a pregnancy test still show a positive result after three months of pregnancy? What is the accuracy? Can pregnancy tests detect pregnancy throughout the entire pregnancy period? What is the accuracy during that time? If I experience pain and bloating in my abdomen afte...

Dr. Zhang Kunmin reply Obstetrics and Gynecology
Hello, the accuracy is generally over 95%. Pregnancy cannot be determined solely by subjective symptoms, and a cyst may not necessarily have an impact. Thank you! Wishing you peace and health. Dr. Chang