Xanax vs. Xanax XR: Dosage and Timing for Anxiety Management - Psychiatry

Share to:

Medication Issues - Xanax and Xanax XR


Hello Doctor,
I am a patient with a 7-8 year history of anxiety disorder.
I have been taking Xanax (alprazolam) 0.5 mg short-acting twice daily for nearly six years.
Typically, I only increase to a third pill on days when I experience sudden anxiety.
Recently, I have noticed that I feel unable to meet my work expectations without Xanax, and I find myself calculating the duration of Xanax's effects to determine whether I have enough confidence and resilience to face work and my environment.
Given this, I have started a tapering plan for the short-acting Xanax this month.
Currently, I am using a long-acting formulation to manage the dosage of the short-acting anxiolytic.
Initially, I tried Da An Yuan (a brand of extended-release alprazolam) 2 mg, but I felt the effects were too different from Xanax, so after discussing with my doctor, I switched to Xanax XR 0.5 mg, taking one pill in the morning and one in the evening.
I would like to ask how many short-acting Xanax 0.5 mg pills are equivalent to one Xanax XR 0.5 mg pill? I usually take the first XR pill at 8 AM; when would be the best time to take the second pill in the evening? Will there be overlapping effects between the first and second doses? Additionally, my doctor has still prescribed me one short-acting pill daily.
If I take the short-acting pill during the duration of the long-acting medication, will the effects also be additive?
Thank you for taking the time to respond!

asos, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2017/03/19

Dr. Dai Wanxiang reply Psychiatry


Hello Mr.
ASOS: There is no difference in dosage between the regular and extended-release formulations of XANAX (0.5mg); the actual effects depend on individual clinical experience (which may vary from 1/2 to 4 times the dosage).
However, the extended-release formulation has a slower release and onset of action, resulting in a longer duration of effect and reduced frequency of dosing.
In the event of discontinuation, withdrawal symptoms (such as anxiety, tremors, restlessness, insomnia, etc.) may be milder, making it easier to taper off the medication gradually.
The downside of the extended-release formulation is that the increase in drug concentration is slower, and the effects may take longer to manifest.
If you take one extended-release tablet at 8 AM, the timing for the second dose in the evening may depend on the severity of your symptoms and individual response.
Generally, extended-release formulations can be taken once or twice daily.
If short-acting medications are added in between, there may indeed be an additive effect, and the dosage should be determined based on individual therapeutic response.
You can discuss the relevant details with your physician and pharmacist.
Thank you.

Reply Date: 2017/03/19

More Info


When it comes to managing anxiety with medications like Xanax (alprazolam) and Xanax XR (extended-release), understanding the differences in dosage, timing, and potential effects is crucial for effective treatment.
Xanax is a short-acting benzodiazepine that is commonly prescribed for anxiety and panic disorders. It works quickly to provide relief from anxiety symptoms, but its effects typically last for a few hours. In contrast, Xanax XR is designed to release the medication slowly over time, providing a more prolonged effect. This means that while both formulations contain the same active ingredient, the way they work in the body differs significantly.

In your case, you are transitioning from Xanax to Xanax XR as part of a tapering plan. When considering the equivalence of Xanax XR 0.5 mg to regular Xanax, it is important to note that the extended-release formulation is designed to provide a steady level of medication in your bloodstream over an extended period. Therefore, one Xanax XR 0.5 mg tablet does not equate to a specific number of Xanax 0.5 mg tablets. The effects of Xanax XR will last longer, and you may find that you need to take it less frequently than the short-acting version.

Regarding the timing of your doses, if you take your first dose of Xanax XR at 8 AM, the second dose can typically be taken around 12 hours later, which would be around 8 PM. However, the exact timing may depend on your individual response to the medication and your specific anxiety symptoms. It is essential to follow your doctor's recommendations regarding dosing schedules.

As for the concern about overlapping effects, it is possible that taking both Xanax XR and a short-acting Xanax could lead to an additive effect, especially if the short-acting dose is taken during the time when the XR is still active in your system. This could increase the risk of side effects, such as sedation or dizziness. Therefore, it is crucial to communicate with your healthcare provider about any additional doses you may need and to monitor how you feel when combining these medications.

In summary, transitioning from Xanax to Xanax XR can be a beneficial strategy for managing anxiety, particularly if you are experiencing difficulties with dependence on the short-acting formulation. The key points to remember are:
1. Dosage Equivalence: Xanax XR 0.5 mg does not directly equate to a specific number of Xanax 0.5 mg tablets due to the differences in release mechanisms.


2. Timing: Taking Xanax XR in the morning and evening is generally acceptable, but the timing should be tailored to your individual needs and symptoms.

3. Additive Effects: Be cautious about taking short-acting Xanax while on Xanax XR, as this can lead to increased sedation and other side effects.

4. Consult Your Doctor: Always discuss any changes in your medication regimen with your healthcare provider to ensure safe and effective management of your anxiety symptoms.

Managing anxiety is a complex process, and it often requires a combination of medication, therapy, and lifestyle changes. It is essential to work closely with your healthcare provider to find the best approach for your specific situation.

Similar Q&A

Managing Anxiety: Expert Advice on Xanax Use and Alternative Treatments

Hello, Doctor. I am currently diagnosed with generalized anxiety disorder, panic disorder with agoraphobia, nausea with vomiting, and an unspecified mental disorder. I have been on medication for about two years. The medications I am currently taking include: one Sulmatyl tab 50m...


Dr. Wu Enliang reply Psychiatry
Q1: I would like to ask the doctor what a reasonable way to take medication is. If one pill is not effective enough, how long should I wait before taking a second pill? A: If possible, prioritize non-pharmacological methods such as relaxation techniques and breathing exercises....

[Read More] Managing Anxiety: Expert Advice on Xanax Use and Alternative Treatments


Managing Anxiety and Medication: Understanding the Risks of Xanax Use

I visited a cardiologist due to discomfort in my heart and was diagnosed with mitral valve prolapse and autonomic nervous system dysfunction. I often experience rapid heart rates, and the doctor mentioned that my stress levels are too high. Subsequently, the doctor prescribed Ent...


Dr. Wu Enliang reply Psychiatry
Hello, netizen: Indeed, Xanax is a short-term solution and not a cure, and it is not advisable to take it daily for an extended period. Academic pressure can be quite distressing, but it is something we must face. I wonder if the counseling teacher has taught any relaxation techn...

[Read More] Managing Anxiety and Medication: Understanding the Risks of Xanax Use


Managing Anxiety Medication Timing for Driving Test Success

I get so nervous during my motorcycle road test that my hands and feet shake, and my hands feel weak. I have Xanax 10mg, but my next test is a backup, and I don't know what time it will be. If I take the medication and still haven't tested after 2 hours, should I take a...


Dr. Wu Enliang reply Psychiatry
Hello, online user: These medications do have some anxiolytic effects, but their use requires a detailed assessment of the individual's condition, considering both the benefits and risks, as well as potential side effects. For example, medications like Sertraline may trigger...

[Read More] Managing Anxiety Medication Timing for Driving Test Success


Managing Medication Timing for Anxiety: Can I Take Extra Doses?

Hello, doctor: I have a question. I regularly take 0.25 mg of Xanax before bed, but I had an episode at 6 PM during dinner and took one 0.25 mg Xanax. Can I take another one before bed, or should I skip it?


Dr. Wu Enliang reply Psychiatry
It is better for netizens to skip it if possible, and ideally, not to take it at all. Sedatives can lead to dependence if used daily, so it is recommended to use them only for a short term or when necessary. Dr. Wu En-Liang.

[Read More] Managing Medication Timing for Anxiety: Can I Take Extra Doses?


Related FAQ

Anti-Anxiety Medication

(Psychiatry)

Anxiety Disorder

(Psychiatry)

Drug Interactions

(Psychiatry)

Sleeping Pills

(Psychiatry)

Drowsiness

(Psychiatry)

Autonomic Nervous System

(Psychiatry)

Emotional Distress

(Psychiatry)

Anxiety

(Cardiology)

Cbt

(Psychiatry)

Fear

(Psychiatry)