Ear Piercing Healing: Why One Hole Closes and the Other Doesn't - Dermatology

Share to:

Healing of Ear Piercings


When I was in kindergarten, my grandmother took me to get my ears pierced.
I remember that because I was a student, I either didn't wear earrings or used a toothpick to keep the holes open.
After a long time without wearing earrings, one of the holes almost closed up.
When I tried to put an earring in, there was resistance, and I had to push it through with some force.
It hurt for a few days, but I was still able to wear earrings.
As I entered my teenage years, I hadn't worn earrings for a while, but wearing them once every few months didn't cause the holes to close up.
Now that I'm almost 40, I have ear holes but no habit of wearing earrings; it's been over six months since I last wore them.
A few days ago, I thought about trying to wear them again, but one hole has almost closed up, and I can faintly see a round shape.
This time, I was determined to push through.
I'm curious why one ear hole has remained open all these years while the other one is still prone to closing up.
Thank you.

Nìmíng, 40~49 year old female. Ask Date: 2017/04/22

Dr. Wu Yuxin reply Dermatology


During the healing process, it is possible to achieve complete healing or to form a scar; it is a matter of probability.

Reply Date: 2017/04/22

More Info


Understanding the healing process of ear piercings can be quite fascinating, especially when considering why one ear hole may close while the other remains open. Several factors contribute to this phenomenon, including biological differences, the healing process, and individual habits.

When you first get your ears pierced, the body treats the piercing as a wound. The healing process involves several stages, including inflammation, tissue formation, and maturation. Typically, a new piercing takes about 6 to 8 weeks to heal, but this can vary based on individual circumstances, such as skin type, aftercare, and whether the piercing is in a location that experiences friction or irritation.

One of the primary reasons one ear hole may close while the other does not is due to the difference in how each piercing was cared for after it was made. If one ear was consistently adorned with earrings, it would have remained open due to the continuous presence of jewelry, which helps to keep the hole from closing. Conversely, if the other ear was left without earrings for an extended period, the body may have recognized it as a wound that needed to heal, leading to closure.

Additionally, the healing process can be influenced by the body's natural tendency to heal itself. Some individuals may have a more robust healing response, leading to faster closure of piercings that are not regularly used. Factors such as age, hormonal changes, and overall health can also play a role in how quickly or slowly a piercing heals or closes.

Another aspect to consider is the anatomy of the ear and the specific location of the piercings. The tissue in different areas of the ear may have varying healing properties. For instance, the lobe of the ear is generally softer and more pliable than the cartilage, which may influence how quickly a hole can close. If the piercing is in a more fibrous area, it may remain open longer than one in a softer area that is more prone to healing.

Moreover, the technique used during the initial piercing can also affect healing. If the piercing was done with a needle, it typically creates a cleaner hole than a gun, which can lead to better healing outcomes. A clean hole is less likely to become infected or irritated, which can contribute to a longer-lasting piercing.

In your case, it seems that the ear that has closed up may not have been used as frequently or may have experienced more irritation or trauma during the healing process. The ear that remains open likely benefited from consistent use of earrings, which kept the hole from closing.

If you are considering wearing earrings again, it’s essential to ensure that the holes are clean and free from infection. If you encounter resistance when trying to insert an earring, it may be wise to use a sterile needle or seek professional help to avoid injury or infection.
In summary, the differences in healing between your two ear piercings can be attributed to a combination of care, biological factors, and the unique healing processes of your body. Understanding these elements can help you make informed decisions about your ear piercings in the future. If you have concerns about your ear health or the condition of your piercings, consulting with a healthcare professional or a licensed piercer can provide you with tailored advice and care options.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Ear Piercing Complications: When to Seek Medical Advice

Hello, doctor^^ I accidentally pierced an additional hole behind my earlobe next to my original earring hole, and it has been about six months. The wound has healed, but there is still a bit of pus inside, and there is a small bump. I’m not sure if you have encountered a similar ...


Dr. Hong Zhengsheng reply Dermatology
Hello, based on your written description, it is currently difficult to determine your specific condition. The main characteristic of skin diseases is that "seeing is believing and touching reveals texture." It is indeed challenging to convey a complete picture through t...

[Read More] Understanding Ear Piercing Complications: When to Seek Medical Advice


Understanding Ear Piercing Complications: What to Do About Growths

I have a piercing close to my ear cartilage, and because I often tug on it, it frequently becomes inflamed, so I stopped wearing earrings. However, not long after, my piercing closed up but a bump formed, making my ear protrude like an elf's. When I press on it, a white subs...


Dr. Huang Ruiyun reply Dermatology
I'm sorry, but online diagnosis is not possible. I recommend visiting an otolaryngologist or a plastic surgeon for a minor surgical procedure to remove it.

[Read More] Understanding Ear Piercing Complications: What to Do About Growths


Managing Ear Piercing Issues: Swelling and Itching Solutions

Hello, doctor. A few days ago, I got my ears pierced. The piercer advised me not to touch them for a week. However, the day after the piercing, one of my ears started to swell a bit and it was itchy. I went back to have her adjust it, and it felt much better. But after another ni...


Dr. Huang Ruiyun reply Dermatology
The best course of action is to remove the ear stud, but the ear hole may heal and close up. If there is no improvement after removal, consult a dermatologist or an otolaryngologist.

[Read More] Managing Ear Piercing Issues: Swelling and Itching Solutions


Why Won't My Ear Piercing Heal After Years of Inflammation?

The ear piercing has been done for seven or eight years, but it keeps getting inflamed repeatedly, even when I don't wear earrings. What's worse is that the ear hole seems to have formed and cannot heal. I've applied many medications, but nothing seems to work.


Dr. Cai Zhenggu reply Otolaryngology
Due to bacterial infection of the wound, repeated inflammation may occur. Topical application of anti-inflammatory ointment can help control the inflammation.

[Read More] Why Won't My Ear Piercing Heal After Years of Inflammation?


Related FAQ

Ear

(Otolaryngology)

Subcutaneous Cyst

(Otolaryngology)

Preauricular Fistula

(Otolaryngology)

Ears

(Family Medicine)

Eardrum Rupture

(Otolaryngology)

Middle Ear Effusion

(Otolaryngology)

Inner Ear Imbalance

(Otolaryngology)

Ears

(Traditional Chinese Medicine)

Lump Behind The Ear

(Otolaryngology)

Ear

(Pediatrics)