Why Lipsticks and Balms Cause Swelling: Allergies and Sensitivities

Applying lipstick or lip balm causes redness, swelling, and peeling of the lips?

Hello doctor, I applied a drugstore lipstick for the first time and about three hours later, I developed a condition known as "sausage lips." Since then, whenever I apply lipstick or lip balm, I almost always experience redness, swelling, and itching.
After trying three or four different drugstore brands, I became hesitant to try any more.
It wasn't until I used an organic certified natural lipstick and a lip balm made with pure shea butter or nut oils (with added fragrance) that I did not experience any allergic reactions.
I later compared the ingredients of the lipsticks and lip balms I had used before and found a commonality: they all contained petrolatum.
Could it be possible that petroleum jelly could cause an allergic reaction? Many people suggest testing it on the back of my hand first to see the reaction, but every time I apply it on my hand, it seems fine, yet it causes redness and swelling on my lips.
Are there other testing methods? Or is there a specific area of skin that is more suitable for testing (perhaps the skin on my hand is thicker than that on my face)?

Flavia, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2017/05/07

Dr. Wu Yuxin reply Dermatology

The chances of success with Vaseline are low.
You might try applying it to the neck or the inner elbow.

Reply Date: 2017/05/07

More Info

Lipsticks and balms can cause swelling and allergic reactions for various reasons, primarily due to the ingredients they contain. In your case, it seems that you have experienced a consistent reaction to several over-the-counter lip products, which suggests a sensitivity or allergy to one or more components in those formulations.

Understanding Allergies and Sensitivities
1. Common Allergens in Lip Products: Many lipsticks and balms contain a variety of ingredients that can trigger allergic reactions. These include fragrances, preservatives, colorants, and emollients. Petrolatum, which you mentioned, is a common ingredient in many lip products and is generally considered safe. However, some individuals may develop sensitivities to it, especially if they have a history of skin allergies or conditions like eczema.

2. Fragrance and Flavoring Agents: Often, lip products contain added fragrances or flavoring agents to enhance the user experience. These ingredients can be irritants or allergens for some people, leading to symptoms like swelling, redness, and itching. Since you mentioned that organic products without synthetic fragrances worked for you, it’s possible that the fragrances in the previous products were the culprits.

3. Testing for Allergies: The suggestion to test on your forearm or hand is a common practice, but it may not always be effective for lip products due to the unique sensitivity of the lip area. The skin on your lips is thinner and more sensitive than that on your forearm, which can lead to different reactions.

Alternative Testing Methods
1. Patch Testing: A more reliable method for identifying specific allergens is patch testing, which is typically conducted by a dermatologist. In this test, small amounts of potential allergens are applied to your skin (usually on your back) and left for 48 hours. This can help identify specific sensitivities.

2. Elimination Method: Since you found that organic lip products worked for you, consider continuing to use those while gradually reintroducing other products one at a time. This way, you can monitor your reactions more closely and identify which specific ingredient may be causing the issue.

3. Consultation with a Dermatologist: If you continue to experience reactions, it would be wise to consult a dermatologist. They can provide a comprehensive evaluation and may recommend allergy testing to pinpoint the exact cause of your reactions.

Other Considerations
- Ingredient Labels: Always read ingredient labels carefully. If you notice a common ingredient in products that cause reactions, avoid it in the future.

- Natural Products: While natural products can be gentler, they can also contain allergens. Always check for potential allergens even in natural formulations.

- Hydration and Care: Sometimes, dry or chapped lips can exacerbate reactions. Ensure you are keeping your lips well-hydrated with products that you know are safe for you.

Conclusion
In conclusion, the swelling and irritation you experience from lipsticks and balms are likely due to an allergic reaction or sensitivity to specific ingredients. While petrolatum is generally safe, individual reactions can vary. Testing methods like patch testing and careful ingredient monitoring can help you identify the specific cause of your reactions. Consulting with a dermatologist will provide you with tailored advice and potential solutions to manage your sensitivities effectively.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Lip Swelling and Redness: Possible Causes and Solutions

Hello Dr. Zheng, this morning when I woke up, I noticed that my lips were slightly swollen and appeared redder than usual. Upon inspecting the inside, I found numerous small petechiae, and there is a mild burning and itching sensation at the lower edge. This has persisted for ove...

Dr. Zheng Jueyi reply Otolaryngology
Hello: The common phenomenon of lip inflammation, if there is no history of drug allergies and no other symptoms such as swelling around the eyes or generalized itching, is likely not related to drug allergies. It is advisable to monitor the condition and increase fluid intake. I...

Why Does My Lip Balm with SPF 30+ Cause Itching and Peeling?

The itching, swelling, and peeling of the lips after using a lip balm with SPF 30+ could be due to the presence of fragrances or other irritants in the formulation. It's also possible that the SPF ingredients themselves may be causing a reaction. If you have been using a sta...

Dr. Wu Yuxin reply Dermatology
Fragrances, preservatives, and sunscreen ingredients can all potentially cause allergic reactions. It is recommended to use petroleum jelly or a regular lip balm instead.

Persistent Lip Discomfort: Understanding Fluid Leakage and Itching

Sometimes when I wake up in the morning, my lips feel moist and itchy. Sometimes it resolves quickly, but other times it lasts for many days. My lips can become cracked and ooze, feeling sore and unhealthy, making it impossible to apply lipstick. Even touching a balloon can cause...

Dr. Wu Yuxin reply Dermatology
You should seek medical attention as soon as possible to assess your condition. It may be necessary to have blood tests to check for any issues with your immune system.

Understanding Lip Area Rash: Causes, Symptoms, and Treatment Options

Hello, doctor. I would like to ask a dermatological question. I have developed some small papules around the edges of my lips (just outside the vermilion border). They are not painful but can be a bit itchy, and they swell slightly when touched. When I brush my teeth, there is so...

Dr. Jiang Yujiao reply Dermatology
Hello: In response to your question, the lesions on the outer edge of the lip line appear to be papules or small vesicles. How long have they been present, and do both the upper and lower lip margins have these types of lesions? Based on your symptoms, it seems there may be swell...