Keloids: Are Your Skin Growths Melanomas or Keloids? - Dermatology

Share to:

Mole? Keloid? Melanoma?


Hello, I have a keloid tendency and have various keloids on my body.
Once, I developed a pimple on my back, and when I squeezed it, a small black stone came out.
Later, a black raised lesion formed at that spot (aside from the color being different from my keloids, the texture and itchy sensation are very similar to my other keloids).
The color is dark brown to black, measuring about 0.6 cm, and the degree of elevation resembles that of a keloid, being a symmetrical round shape.
It is not painful but can be itchy at times.
Could this also be considered a type of keloid? I am concerned because my other keloids are pink, so I am wondering if this black one is different.
Thank you.

PW, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2017/05/16

Dr. Wu Yuxin reply Dermatology


Without actually seeing the lesion, it is impossible to determine the issue.
If it is very concerning, please seek medical attention as soon as possible.
A proper examination is necessary to understand the problem and to determine the appropriate treatment.

Reply Date: 2017/05/16

More Info


Keloids, or "蟹足腫" in Mandarin, are a type of raised scar that occurs when the body produces too much collagen during the healing process. They can appear as thick, rubbery lesions that extend beyond the original wound site. Your description of having a black, raised growth on your back that resembles your existing keloids raises some important considerations.

Firstly, it’s crucial to differentiate between keloids and other types of skin growths, including benign lesions and potentially malignant ones like melanomas. Keloids typically have a smooth surface and can vary in color from pink to dark brown, depending on your skin tone. They are usually asymptomatic, although they can sometimes itch or cause discomfort. The fact that your new growth is dark brown to black and has a similar texture to your keloids suggests it may also be a keloid, especially if it developed after a skin injury, such as the pimple you mentioned.

However, the color change and the specific characteristics of the growth warrant further investigation. Melanomas, a type of skin cancer, can also present as dark, raised lesions. Key features to look for in distinguishing a melanoma from a keloid include asymmetry, irregular borders, multiple colors, and a diameter larger than 6mm. If your growth exhibits any of these characteristics, it is essential to seek medical advice promptly.

Given your history of keloids, it is possible that the new growth is indeed another keloid, especially if it developed in response to trauma or irritation. Keloids can sometimes form in areas of previous skin damage, and they may vary in color and texture. However, the fact that it is darker than your other keloids could indicate a different type of skin lesion, particularly if it was not associated with a known injury.

I recommend that you consult a dermatologist for a thorough evaluation. They may perform a physical examination and, if necessary, a biopsy to determine the exact nature of the growth. This is crucial not only for diagnosis but also for determining the appropriate treatment. Treatments for keloids can include corticosteroid injections, silicone gel sheets, laser therapy, or surgical removal, depending on the size, location, and symptoms associated with the keloid.

In summary, while your new growth may be another keloid, the differences in color and the fact that it developed after a pimple necessitate a professional evaluation to rule out other possibilities, including melanoma. Early diagnosis and treatment are key to managing skin growths effectively, so please do not hesitate to seek medical attention.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Skin Spots on Fingers and Soles: Melanoma Risks Explained

Hello Doctor, I just saw the news that spots on the fingers and soles of the feet could potentially develop into melanoma. I have noticed brown spots on my hands and feet (which have been there for several years) that are irregularly shaped and symmetrical. I would like to ask if...


Dr. Xiao Yongxun reply Family Medicine
Dear Mr. Wei: 1. Melanoma, also known as malignant melanoma, is more commonly found in Caucasians and individuals with fair skin. The primary causative factor is damage from sunlight (ultraviolet radiation). Other contributing factors for melanoma include dysplastic nevi and cer...

[Read More] Understanding Skin Spots on Fingers and Soles: Melanoma Risks Explained


Understanding Dermatofibromas: Pain, Changes, and Cancer Risks

Hello! I would like to ask the doctor a question. Three years ago, I developed two dermatofibromas—one on my back and one on the inner thigh. Recently, I have been experiencing a sharp pain in the thigh lesion if it gets accidentally rubbed. Does this indicate a change in the con...


Dr. Zhang Zhibo reply Dermatology
Hello: Most dermatofibromas are asymptomatic, but if there is a vascular component, pain may occur. If it is a malignant dermatofibrosarcoma, it typically presents as a nodular tumor resembling a keloid. To determine whether a dermatofibroma is malignant, a skin biopsy is necessa...

[Read More] Understanding Dermatofibromas: Pain, Changes, and Cancer Risks


Understanding Skin Conditions: Seborrheic Dermatitis and Wound Healing

1. Having seborrheic dermatitis, which resembles eczema, can predispose you to keloid formation at surgical sites. This may explain why the lower half of your wound appears swollen and thickened. 2. If you experience easy bruising or bleeding during bathing without vigorous scru...


Dr. Cai Changlin reply Dermatology
Hello: Regarding your question, seborrheic dermatitis and keloids are two distinct dermatological conditions that can exist independently but may also occur simultaneously. Therefore, having seborrheic dermatitis or eczema does not necessarily increase the likelihood of developin...

[Read More] Understanding Skin Conditions: Seborrheic Dermatitis and Wound Healing


Understanding Keloids on the Face: Causes, Treatments, and Concerns

Hello Doctor, I came to the UK about six months ago, and five months ago, I developed a pimple on my right cheek. After I squeezed it, it turned into a raised wound. Since I do not have a history of keloid formation, I did not pay much attention to it until it suddenly became mor...


Dr. Wu Yuxin reply Dermatology
1. The chances are slim. 2. No. 3. Without actually seeing the lesion, it cannot be determined. If it is very concerning, please seek medical attention promptly.

[Read More] Understanding Keloids on the Face: Causes, Treatments, and Concerns


Related FAQ

Keloid

(Dermatology)

Moles, Birthmarks

(Dermatology)

Sunspots

(Dermatology)

Melanin

(Dermatology)

Keratosis Pilaris

(Dermatology)

Hemangioma

(Dermatology)

Freckles

(Dermatology)

Nodular Erythema

(Dermatology)

Stretch Marks

(Dermatology)

Areola

(Dermatology)