Exploring Alternative Methods for Diagnosing Anal Fistulas - Surgery

Share to:

Anal fistula


Doctor, I saw someone on the forum asking, "Is there a high probability of an anal fistula being misdiagnosed as not having one?" and your response was that it is possible.
I have the same concern as her, and my issue has been ongoing for a long time.
It used to flare up frequently, but now it has become bearable.
Previously, I consulted doctors who all diagnosed me as not having a fistula, and I eventually gave up and stopped seeing a doctor.
I would like to ask again, besides digital examination and endoscopy, are there other methods to test for the presence of an anal fistula?

A-Rui, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2017/05/30

Dr. Ke Fangxu reply Surgery


Textbooks mention that magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) can be used to diagnose complex anal fistulas, and fistulography is also one of the diagnostic methods.
However, both of these diagnostic techniques are utilized for confirming the presence of anal fistulas when the exact tract is uncertain, and they are not commonly used diagnostic methods.
It is recommended that you consult an experienced colorectal surgeon for a more definitive diagnosis.

Reply Date: 2017/05/30

More Info


When it comes to diagnosing anal fistulas, traditional methods such as digital examination and endoscopy (including colonoscopy) are commonly employed. However, there are alternative diagnostic methods that can be utilized, especially if previous examinations have yielded inconclusive results.
One of the most effective non-invasive methods is the use of Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI). MRI is particularly useful for visualizing soft tissues and can provide detailed images of the anal region, allowing for the identification of fistulas, abscesses, and other related complications. This imaging technique is beneficial because it does not involve radiation exposure, making it a safer option for patients who may have concerns about cumulative radiation from multiple imaging studies.

Another alternative is the Endoanal Ultrasound (EAUS). This procedure uses high-frequency sound waves to create images of the anal canal and surrounding tissues. It is especially useful for detecting anal fistulas and can help in assessing the complexity of the fistula, which is crucial for planning surgical intervention if needed. EAUS is a relatively quick procedure and can be performed in an outpatient setting.

In some cases, CT scans can also be utilized, particularly if there is a suspicion of associated abscess formation. However, as you mentioned concerns about radiation exposure, it is important to weigh the benefits against the risks. CT scans are more commonly used in acute settings or when complications are suspected.

Additionally, fistulography is a specialized procedure where a contrast dye is injected into the fistula tract, and X-rays are taken to visualize the anatomy of the fistula. This method can provide valuable information about the fistula's path and its relationship to surrounding structures.

It’s also worth mentioning that clinical history and symptomatology play a significant role in the diagnosis of anal fistulas. Symptoms such as persistent pain, swelling, or discharge from the anal area can guide the clinician in making a more accurate diagnosis.
If you have previously been diagnosed as having no fistula but continue to experience symptoms, it may be beneficial to seek a second opinion or consult a specialist in colorectal surgery. They may recommend one or more of the aforementioned diagnostic methods to ensure a comprehensive evaluation.

In summary, while digital examination and endoscopy are standard practices for diagnosing anal fistulas, alternative methods such as MRI, endoanal ultrasound, and fistulography can provide additional insights, especially in cases of misdiagnosis. If you are experiencing ongoing symptoms, it is crucial to pursue further evaluation to determine the underlying cause and appropriate treatment.

Similar Q&A

Can Digital Rectal Examination Accurately Diagnose Anal Fistulas?

Dear Doctor, can a digital rectal examination be sufficient for diagnosing anal conditions? Is the result from a digital examination always accurate, or is it safer to get checked at a larger hospital?


Dr. Zhang Shuhao reply Surgery
Experienced colorectal surgeons can diagnose anal fistulas in the clinic based on the location of the external opening, palpation, and anoscopy, achieving a high degree of accuracy that can serve as a basis for surgical intervention. Highly complex or recurrent fistulas may requi...

[Read More] Can Digital Rectal Examination Accurately Diagnose Anal Fistulas?


Diagnosis and Treatment of Anal Fistulas: Insights from Tzu Chi Hospital

The diagnostic methods and tools for anal fistulas include physical examination, digital rectal examination, and imaging studies such as ultrasound or MRI. The level of colorectal surgery at Tzu Chi Hospital is considered to be high, with a focus on advanced techniques and patien...


Dr. Wang Qichao reply Surgery
The diagnosis of anal fistula primarily relies on the patient's medical history and physical examination, as there are no particularly effective tools for testing. In the medical history, patients often initially present with an abscess, which gradually forms a fistula after...

[Read More] Diagnosis and Treatment of Anal Fistulas: Insights from Tzu Chi Hospital


Determining Anal Fistula: Key Signs and Diagnostic Criteria

Doctor, six months ago I had an abscess on the right side of my anus, which was drained in a proctology clinic. Recently, during a follow-up visit, the doctor said that an anal fistula has formed. I have seen three doctors: one said it is a fistula and noted the presence of disch...


Dr. Lin Zhiguang reply Surgery
If there has been a history of abscess formation, the likelihood of developing an anal fistula is high. Typically, outpatient drainage is not sufficient for a complete cure of the fistula. Surgical intervention is usually required to effectively address the fistula tract. It is r...

[Read More] Determining Anal Fistula: Key Signs and Diagnostic Criteria


Misdiagnosis of Anal Fistulas: Understanding the Risks and Challenges

Is there a high chance of misdiagnosing an anal fistula as not having one?


Dr. Ke Fangxu reply Surgery
It is possible that no diagnostic method has a 100% accuracy rate. Sometimes, the fistula may be too deep to palpate, or it may be very superficial and overlooked. If there are concerns, it is advisable to consult multiple physicians to reduce the likelihood of being missed.

[Read More] Misdiagnosis of Anal Fistulas: Understanding the Risks and Challenges


Related FAQ