Should You Treat Periodontal Disease or Extract Your Tooth? - Dentistry

More Info

---

When faced with the dilemma of whether to treat periodontal disease or extract a tooth, especially in the context of your right lower first molar, it is essential to consider several factors, including the current state of your dental health, the recommendations from various dental professionals, and the potential consequences of each option.

From your description, it appears that your first molar has a history of root canal treatment but has not been crowned, which can lead to structural weakness. The presence of a small fracture and recurrent swelling with pus indicates ongoing periodontal issues, likely exacerbated by the incomplete filling at the root canal's base. This situation can lead to further complications, including infection and potential loss of surrounding teeth.


Evaluating Treatment Options
1. Periodontal Treatment: If you choose to pursue periodontal treatment, it is crucial to address the underlying infection and inflammation. This may involve scaling and root planing, which can help remove plaque and tartar from below the gum line. Additionally, if the root canal filling is inadequate, a retreatment may be necessary to ensure that the tooth is free of infection. However, this option may require a significant investment of time and money, especially if it is not covered by insurance.

2. Extraction: Extracting the tooth may seem like a straightforward solution, especially if the tooth is deemed non-restorable due to the extent of the damage and infection. However, removing the first molar can lead to complications such as shifting of adjacent teeth, loss of chewing function, and potential bone loss in the area. If you opt for extraction, you will need to consider subsequent restorative options, such as dental implants or removable partial dentures.

3. Restorative Options: If the tooth is extracted, you will need to decide on the best way to restore function and aesthetics. Dental implants are often considered the gold standard for replacing missing teeth, as they provide a stable and permanent solution. However, they require sufficient bone density and may involve additional procedures, such as bone grafting, if there has been significant bone loss. Alternatively, a removable partial denture can be a less invasive and more cost-effective solution, but it may not provide the same level of comfort or function as an implant.


Recommendations
Given the conflicting opinions from different dental professionals, it may be beneficial to seek a comprehensive evaluation from a specialist, such as a periodontist or an oral surgeon. They can provide a detailed assessment of your periodontal health and the condition of the tooth in question. Here are some steps you can take:
- Get a Second Opinion: Consult with a periodontist who can evaluate the extent of the periodontal disease and the condition of the root canal treatment. They can help determine if the tooth can be saved with further treatment or if extraction is the best option.


- Consider Comprehensive Treatment: If you opt for periodontal treatment, ensure that it includes addressing the root canal issue. This may involve retreatment or extraction, depending on the tooth's prognosis.

- Evaluate Restorative Options: If extraction is necessary, discuss the timeline and options for replacement with your dentist. Consider factors such as your age, overall health, and financial situation when deciding between implants and dentures.

- Maintain Oral Hygiene: Regardless of the decision, maintaining excellent oral hygiene is crucial to prevent further complications. Regular dental check-ups and cleanings will help manage any existing periodontal issues and monitor your overall dental health.

In conclusion, the decision to treat periodontal disease or extract your tooth should be made based on a thorough evaluation of your specific situation, the potential for saving the tooth, and your long-term dental health goals. Consulting with specialists and considering all available options will help you make an informed decision that aligns with your needs.