the Accuracy of RT-PCR Testing: Myths and Facts

What is the reliability of RT-PCR?

According to Dr.
Luo from National Taiwan University, the accuracy of RT-PCR testing is very good but not 100%, with less than 1% of cases being extraordinary controllers.
Some laboratories and physicians have stated that this is currently the highest technology in testing methods and is generally reliable, but it is not commonly used due to its high cost and the time required for results.
From a medical perspective, how accurate is RT-PCR? Have you heard of cases of false negatives with RT-PCR? How many days after exposure is it advisable to get tested for more reliable results? Currently, I've heard that testing after ten days is recommended, and is it possible for extraordinary controllers to exhibit acute symptoms?

Zhang, 40~49 year old female. Ask Date: 2017/06/15

Dr. Hong Yuanbin reply Internal Medicine

Hello, Dr.
Luo's statement is more accurate.
Although RT-PCR is very precise, there is still a small margin of error, and it is not 100% accurate.
Clinically, there are indeed a few cases of false negatives.
If a test is done a few days later, while it is generally said that retesting should occur after 10 days, it is not absolute and there may still be missed cases.
Therefore, if there is a high suspicion, it is recommended to retest after several months or even half a year to make a judgment, or to use other testing methods for confirmation.
Regardless of whether one is an extraordinary controller or not, there should be acute symptoms; however, some individuals may have very mild acute symptoms that can easily be overlooked, resembling a mild cold.
Ultimately, safe practices are still recommended, especially the use of condoms, which remains a more reliable method of protection.
Thank you for your question.

Reply Date: 2017/06/15

More Info

RT-PCR, or Reverse Transcription Polymerase Chain Reaction, is a highly sensitive and specific method used for detecting RNA viruses, including HIV. Its accuracy is generally considered to be very high, but it is not infallible. The claims regarding its accuracy can vary based on the context in which it is used, the timing of the test, and the specific population being tested.

Accuracy of RT-PCR Testing
1. High Sensitivity and Specificity: RT-PCR is known for its high sensitivity, meaning it can detect very low levels of viral RNA. This makes it an excellent tool for diagnosing infections like HIV, especially in acute cases where the viral load may be low. However, while sensitivity is high, it does not guarantee a 100% accuracy rate. There can be false negatives, particularly in the early stages of infection or due to technical errors in the testing process.

2. False Negatives: The phenomenon of false negatives in RT-PCR testing can occur. This is particularly relevant in the context of HIV testing. If a person is tested too early after exposure, the viral load may not be high enough to be detected, leading to a negative result despite an actual infection. This is often referred to as the "window period," which can last several days to weeks. For HIV, it is generally recommended to wait at least 10 days to two weeks after potential exposure before testing, but even then, a follow-up test after three months is often advised for conclusive results.

3. Timing of Testing: The timing of the RT-PCR test is crucial. Testing too early can result in a false negative. For HIV, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) recommends testing at least 2-4 weeks after potential exposure, with a follow-up test at three months for definitive results. This is because the body takes time to produce enough viral RNA for detection.

4. Acute Symptoms and Testing: Individuals who are classified as "elite controllers" may have a unique immune response that keeps their viral load undetectable. However, even these individuals can experience acute symptoms similar to those of an HIV infection. Therefore, if someone presents with acute symptoms and tests negative via RT-PCR, it does not completely rule out the possibility of HIV infection, especially if the test was conducted during the window period.

Recommendations for Testing
- Initial Testing: If there is a suspicion of HIV infection due to potential exposure or symptoms, an initial RT-PCR test can be performed. However, it is essential to understand that a negative result does not definitively rule out infection.

- Follow-Up Testing: For individuals with high-risk exposure or symptoms, follow-up testing is crucial. A combination of tests, including antibody tests (like the HIV Ag/Ab Combo Test), can provide a more comprehensive assessment of HIV status.

- Consultation with Healthcare Providers: It is advisable to consult with healthcare professionals for personalized advice and to determine the most appropriate testing strategy based on individual risk factors and symptoms.

Conclusion
In summary, while RT-PCR is a powerful tool for detecting HIV and other RNA viruses, it is not without limitations. False negatives can occur, particularly if testing is done too early. Therefore, understanding the timing of the test and the nature of the symptoms is critical. For anyone concerned about potential HIV infection, it is best to seek medical advice and consider follow-up testing to ensure accurate diagnosis and peace of mind.

Similar Q&A

Understanding RT-PCR Accuracy and HIV Treatment Timelines in Urology

The RT-PCR test, which stands for Reverse Transcription Polymerase Chain Reaction, is primarily used to reduce the window period to two weeks. Its accuracy can vary, but it is generally considered to be highly sensitive and specific for detecting HIV. If you test negative on day ...

Dr. Xu Weikai reply Urology
Anonymous: Hello, RT-PCR testing is primarily used for diseases that require rapid diagnosis to prevent the spread of infection, such as the recent H1N1. For HIV, traditional testing methods are generally used, as there is not much difference in the timing of the test and treatme...

Understanding RT-PCR: Key Insights on Flu and SARS Testing

I saw in newspapers and magazines about the method for testing SARS, RT-PCR. What is that? What is the principle behind it?

Dr. Ke Zhengqin reply Influenza
RT-PCR is an abbreviation for Reverse Transcriptase Polymerase Chain Reaction, a technique developed by foreign researchers, hence its English name. This technology was created to address the following challenge: how can we determine whether a specific virus is present in the blo...

Will Delayed Blood Storage Affect RT-PCR Test Accuracy?

Doctor, I found a medical laboratory on a website in Aichi and had my blood drawn for RT-PCR testing on the 19th. Today, I called them, and they said they are closed for spring break. The molecular testing lab in Taipei will not resume operations until the 31st. Given that my blo...

Dr. Lin Wenxu reply Urology
Hello, sir: Thank you for your inquiry. I would like to respond to your question and provide the following suggestions: If the specimens are properly preserved, it is still possible to conduct tests. If you have concerns, you can consider follow-up testing after three months. The...

Understanding Rt-PCR and Combo Tests: Your Concerns Addressed

Hello, doctor. I am the one who mentioned in previous posts that I had oral sex for ten seconds and tested negative on the RT-PCR after ten days. I went for a combo test on day 27, and it was also negative. I heard that the combo test at National Cheng Kung University Hospital us...

Dr. Hong Yuanbin reply Internal Medicine
Hello, if the combo test is negative on day 27, while it is not 100% conclusive, it is close to a very high level of certainty that you are not infected. Therefore, you should not be overly concerned at this time. Of course, it is advisable to retest at 84 days for confirmation. ...