HIV Testing: Combo Test vs. 4th Generation ELISA Explained

HIV testing methods?

Hello doctor, I have been searching for a long time and I am unclear about the differences in testing types.
Is the combo test the same as the 4th generation ELISA test? Where can I find the DUO test in Taichung? What is the window period for these tests? I went to China Medical University Hospital for screening at 6 weeks and tested negative; is that reliable?

Kevin, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2017/07/23

Dr. Liao Zhongxin reply Internal Medicine

Dear readers,
Regarding the different types of testing, here is the response:
A: According to the reference webpage https://tw.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20140413000016KK03122, regardless of the reagent used for testing, the results after 13 weeks are considered final and do not require retesting.

1.
The third-generation ELISA test is already very reliable at 6 weeks, and retesting at 10 weeks can completely rule out infection.

2.
The fourth-generation ELISA test (combo test) combines the detection of the P24 antigen with antibody testing.
If antibodies are not detected, the P24 antigen should be able to detect the viral antigen (qualitative test).
Therefore, using the fourth-generation reagent, testing at 6 weeks can rule out infection.
Generally, the time frame for HIV exclusion should be 13 weeks.
However, there are certain groups we recommend to follow up with retesting after 13 weeks:
(1) Drug users - it is recommended to test after 6 months (with a history of drug use for over 1 year).

(2) Healthcare workers who accidentally come into contact with HIV - baseline testing should be done at 6 weeks, 12 weeks, 6 months, and 1 year.

(3) Individuals who have engaged in high-risk sexual behavior with known HIV-positive individuals, such as unprotected anal intercourse, should be tested after 6 months.
However, for most individuals engaging in such behaviors, a negative test result at 13 weeks should be trusted.

(4) If you are sexually active, even with protected sex, you should get tested annually.
Thank you!

Reply Date: 2017/07/23

More Info

Understanding HIV testing can be quite complex, especially with the various types of tests available. Let's clarify the differences between the Combo Test, 4th Generation ELISA, and the DUO Test, as well as address your concerns regarding the window period and the reliability of your recent negative test result.

Combo Test vs. 4th Generation ELISA
The terms "Combo Test" and "4th Generation ELISA" are often used interchangeably, and for practical purposes, they refer to the same type of test. Both are designed to detect HIV by identifying both the antibodies produced in response to the virus and the p24 antigen, which is a protein that appears in the blood shortly after infection.
1. 4th Generation ELISA (Combo Test): This test can detect HIV-1 and HIV-2, including various subtypes of HIV-1 (such as groups M, N, and O). It is more sensitive than earlier generations of tests, which only detected antibodies. The inclusion of the p24 antigen allows for earlier detection of HIV, typically within 2 to 4 weeks after exposure.

2. DUO Test: The DUO Test is essentially another name for the 4th Generation Combo Test. It emphasizes the dual detection capability of both antibodies and the p24 antigen. Therefore, if you come across the term DUO Test, you can consider it synonymous with the Combo Test or 4th Generation ELISA.

Window Period
The window period is the time after exposure to HIV during which the virus may not be detectable by tests. For the 4th Generation ELISA, the window period is generally around 4 to 6 weeks, but it is recommended to wait until 13 weeks for a conclusive result.
- 6 Weeks Testing: Since you tested negative at 6 weeks, this result is quite promising, especially with the 4th Generation test. However, while a negative result at this stage is encouraging, it is not definitive. The CDC and other health organizations recommend retesting at 3 months (13 weeks) for a conclusive result.

Reliability of Your Test Result
You mentioned that you had a negative result at China Medical University Hospital after 6 weeks. Given that you underwent a 4th Generation ELISA (Combo Test), this result is reliable, but keep in mind that the final confirmation should ideally be done at the 13-week mark.

Recommendations
1. Follow-Up Testing: It is advisable to return for a follow-up test at 13 weeks to confirm your negative result. This is particularly important if you have had any high-risk exposures, even if they were infrequent.

2. Testing Locations: In Taichung, you can find HIV testing services at hospitals, clinics, and specialized health centers. It is best to contact local health services or hospitals to inquire about the availability of the 4th Generation ELISA or DUO Test.

3. Ongoing Monitoring: If you continue to engage in high-risk behaviors, regular testing (at least annually) is recommended, even if you consistently use protection.

In conclusion, the Combo Test and 4th Generation ELISA are essentially the same, both capable of detecting HIV earlier than previous tests. Your negative result at 6 weeks is a good sign, but for peace of mind and medical accuracy, follow up with another test at 13 weeks. Always consult with healthcare professionals for personalized advice and testing options.

Similar Q&A

Understanding HIV Testing: ELISA vs. EIA and the Fourth Generation Combo Test

Hello Dr. Hong, I am seeking clarification regarding HIV screening. I consulted Testing Unit A, which indicated that they use the fourth-generation ELISA (Combo), while Testing Unit B mentioned they use traditional EIA. From my understanding and research, ELISA is equivalent to E...

Dr. Hong Yuanbin reply Internal Medicine
Enzyme immunoassay (EIA) is a general term that refers to any method that utilizes enzymes and immunological techniques. EIA encompasses various approaches, with the most commonly used being the enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA). However, currently, the terms EIA and ELIS...

Is HIV Ag/Ab Combo Test Considered Fourth-Generation ELISA?

Hello Dr. Hong, thank you for your response during the holiday. Currently, many testing facilities are using the HIV Ag/Ab Combo, which includes both antibody and antigen (p24) testing. I would like to ask you, Dr. Hong, is the HIV Ag/Ab Combo test considered the so-called fourth...

Dr. Hong Yuanbin reply Internal Medicine
Hello, the HIV Ag/Ab Combo test is indeed what is commonly referred to as the fourth-generation ELISA, which can simultaneously detect both antibodies and the p24 antigen. Thank you for your inquiry.

Understanding HIV Testing: Interpreting ELISA Results and Detection Capabilities

Hello Dr. Hong, I have undergone the fourth-generation ELISA HIV Ag/Ab combo test twice within a week. The first result was 0.09 and the second was 0.12. I would like to ask if this increase in values is normal, or if values below 1 are considered acceptable. Additionally, does t...

Dr. Hong Yuanbin reply Internal Medicine
Hello, 1. Yes, anything less than 1 is considered normal. 2. Both HIV-1 and HIV-2 can be detected. 3. Yes, these subtypes can be detected as well. Thank you for your question.

Understanding HIV Testing: Key Insights on Antibody and Combo Tests

Hello Dr. Hong, thank you for your previous response. There are many different types of HIV tests available on the market. I would like to ask you, is it sufficient to perform an HIV antibody test (HIV Ag+Ab Combo (AIDS), Anti-HIV, etc.) to determine if a person is infected with ...

Dr. Hong Yuanbin reply Internal Medicine
Hello, it is currently recommended to use the HIV Ag+Ab Combo test to check for HIV. If there are any special circumstances, it is advisable to discuss with an infectious disease specialist whether any additional interventions are necessary. Thank you for your inquiry.