Vocal cord paralysis leading to respiratory failure?
Hello, doctor.
My mother is currently in the respiratory care unit due to respiratory failure caused by vocal cord paralysis.
According to her attending physician, the respiratory failure is a result of the vocal cord paralysis, and she is on a ventilator that cannot be removed.
She frequently develops respiratory infections, for which she has been treated with antibiotics.
My mother is unwilling to undergo a tracheostomy and is interested in vocal cord surgery to improve her condition.
I am unsure if this is appropriate and if there are any comprehensive recommendations available.
Additionally, I found information online about a procedure developed by Dr.
Su Wan-Fu at Tzu Chi Hospital called vocal cord lateralization surgery, which has shown effectiveness in alleviating respiratory difficulties caused by vocal cord paralysis.
However, it seems that there is little interest in this procedure within the medical community.
Is this due to health insurance factors, or does the procedure carry significant risks? Thank you for your response.
Dai Zi, 40~49 year old female. Ask Date: 2017/08/02
Dr. Li Jiaxuan reply Otolaryngology
It is important to first determine whether your mother's vocal cord paralysis is adductor type or abductor type (based on your description, it seems to be the former).
Indeed, after evaluation, vocal cord lateralization surgery could be considered.
However, the surgery itself requires anesthesia, and I am unsure if your mother's health condition allows for that.
Additionally, this type of voice surgery is complex, requires extensive equipment, and the results may not be satisfactory for everyone (as voice and breathing cannot be balanced after fixation).
This procedure is not commonly performed in the country.
I recommend that you consult with Professor Su for an evaluation before making a decision.
Wishing you peace and safety.
Reply Date: 2017/08/02
More Info
Vocal cord paralysis (VCP) is a condition that can significantly impact a person's ability to breathe, speak, and swallow. It occurs when the nerves that control the vocal cords become damaged, leading to partial or complete loss of movement in one or both vocal cords. This can result in respiratory failure, especially if the paralysis affects the ability to protect the airway or if it leads to aspiration of food or liquids into the lungs.
In your mother's case, it seems that her vocal cord paralysis has led to respiratory failure, necessitating the use of a ventilator. This is a serious condition, as respiratory failure can lead to inadequate oxygenation of the body and can increase the risk of respiratory infections, which may explain the need for antibiotics. The connection between vocal cord paralysis and respiratory issues is well-documented; when the vocal cords cannot close properly, it can lead to airway obstruction or aspiration, both of which can compromise respiratory function.
Regarding the surgical options, vocal cord surgery may be appropriate depending on the underlying cause of the paralysis and the specific characteristics of your mother's condition. Surgical interventions can include procedures to reposition the vocal cords to improve airway patency or to enhance vocal function. The procedure you mentioned, developed by Dr. Su Wan-Fu, known as vocal cord lateralization or fixation, is designed to help patients with vocal cord paralysis breathe more easily by keeping the vocal cords in a position that allows for better airflow.
However, the decision to proceed with surgery should be made after careful consideration of the risks and benefits. Surgical interventions can carry risks, including infection, bleeding, and the potential for further complications related to the airway. Additionally, the success of the surgery can vary based on individual circumstances, including the duration of the paralysis and the overall health of the patient.
It is also worth noting that the interest in certain surgical techniques can be influenced by various factors, including healthcare policies, reimbursement issues, and the availability of specialized training among surgeons. If there is a lack of interest in a particular procedure, it may be due to concerns about its efficacy, safety, or the complexity of the technique.
In terms of next steps, it would be advisable to have a thorough discussion with your mother's healthcare team, including her pulmonologist and an otolaryngologist (ENT specialist). They can provide insights into the potential benefits of surgery, the risks involved, and whether your mother is a suitable candidate for the procedure. Additionally, they can explore other supportive measures that may improve her quality of life while managing her respiratory needs.
In conclusion, vocal cord paralysis can lead to significant respiratory challenges, and surgical options may provide relief. However, careful evaluation and discussion with medical professionals are essential to determine the best course of action for your mother's specific situation.
Similar Q&A
Understanding Vocal Cord Paralysis: Causes and Diagnosis Explained
Vocal cord paralysis has resulted in the absence of voice for over 10 days. An endoscopy revealed right vocal cord paralysis. The clinic referred me to a medical center, which has requested a neck CT scan. I will review the report tomorrow. What are the possible causes of vocal c...
Dr. Ye Dawei reply Otolaryngology
Sir, your issue should first be evaluated with a chest X-ray to rule out any visibly apparent lung tumors. Following that, a neck CT scan should be performed.[Read More] Understanding Vocal Cord Paralysis: Causes and Diagnosis Explained
Addressing Vocal Cord Closure Issues in Children: Solutions and Support
I would like to ask about a child who has been experiencing weakness in their voice and hoarseness since they were young, leading to feelings of inferiority and reluctance to speak in public. An ENT specialist diagnosed the child with abnormally thin vocal cords that do not close...
Dr. Zheng Jueyi reply Otolaryngology
If the vocal cords cannot close completely and speech therapy is not effective, it is recommended to consult an otolaryngologist at a medical center to determine if vocal cord injection is appropriate to improve voice quality. As for the hoarseness in this regard, it should not b...[Read More] Addressing Vocal Cord Closure Issues in Children: Solutions and Support
Post-Surgery Vocal Cord Paralysis: Treatment Options and Insights
Hello, Doctor: I underwent a thoracic aortic aneurysm resection and artificial graft repair in 2004. After the surgery, my left vocal cord became immobile, resulting in hoarseness and vocal fatigue. I participated in voice rehabilitation for about a year, which led to some improv...
Dr. Ye Dawei reply Otolaryngology
Hello. 1. In the case of complete paralysis, theoretically, there should be no improvement; however, the other side may compensate. 2. This is a procedure that requires a medical center-level facility, which our hospital is unable to perform. 3. Dr. Hsiao Tzu-Yu from National Tai...[Read More] Post-Surgery Vocal Cord Paralysis: Treatment Options and Insights
Post-Surgery Hoarseness: Understanding Vocal Cord Issues After Lung Surgery
Due to general anesthesia and intubation during lung surgery, the patient is experiencing hoarseness and can only produce a breathy voice, making it difficult to drink water without choking. The surgeon advised monitoring for two months. Is this related to vocal cord paralysis? I...
Dr. Zheng Jueyi reply Otolaryngology
Hello, if you are experiencing persistent hoarseness and are easily prone to coughing, it is advisable to visit an otolaryngologist for a thorough examination. Wishing you safety and good health. Sincerely, Dr. Cheng Jue-Yi, Director of the Department of Otolaryngology, Taoyuan H...[Read More] Post-Surgery Hoarseness: Understanding Vocal Cord Issues After Lung Surgery
Related FAQ
(Otolaryngology)
Hoarseness(Otolaryngology)
Throat Disease(Otolaryngology)
Breathing(Otolaryngology)
Choking(Otolaryngology)
Cough(Otolaryngology)
Deafness(Otolaryngology)
Difficulty Swallowing(Otolaryngology)
Choking(Pulmonology)
Chronic Pharyngitis(Otolaryngology)