Post-Mole Removal Scar Care: Choosing Between Silicone Gel and Beauty Tape

Q: Post-Mole Removal Scar Care: Choosing Between Silicone Gel and Beauty Tape

1. Post-operative scar care should include： moisturizing, compression, immobilization, and sun protection for at least 3 months. 2. You can also apply a silicone gel sheet for 12 hours and use an ointment for another 12 hours. 3. Do not pick or scratch the sca

Post-Mole Removal Scar Care

About two weeks after the mole removal surgery, I am still using a silicone adhesive strip, but the hospital provided a tube of dermatic silicone gel.
I’m not sure if it’s because my face tends to be oily, but the adhesive strip doesn’t stay on for more than two days.
The scar is about one centimeter long and feels slightly firm to the touch.
The pharmacist suggested that I could just apply the gel directly.
I would like to know how to choose between the gel and the adhesive strip.
Can I apply the gel, wait for it to dry, and then put on the adhesive strip? I’m worried that if I don’t use the strip, the scar might become raised, and if I don’t use the gel, the scar might be more noticeable.
I’m in a bit of a dilemma.

s, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2018/01/06

Dr. Zhou Hongzhang reply Plastic Surgery

1.
Post-operative scar care should include: moisturizing, compression, immobilization, and sun protection for at least 3 months.
2.
You can also apply a silicone gel sheet for 12 hours and use an ointment for another 12 hours.
3.
Do not pick or scratch the scar to ensure it heals beautifully.

Reply Date: 2018/01/06

More Info

When it comes to post-mole removal scar care, choosing between silicone gel and beauty tape can indeed be a challenging decision, especially given the unique characteristics of your skin and the nature of your scar. After mole removal, proper scar management is crucial to minimize the appearance of scars and promote healing. Here’s a comprehensive overview of your options and recommendations based on current medical practices.

Understanding Silicone Gel and Beauty Tape
Silicone Gel: Silicone gel is widely recognized in dermatology for its effectiveness in scar management. It works by creating a protective barrier over the scar, which helps to retain moisture and regulate collagen production. This can lead to softer, flatter scars over time. Silicone gel is particularly beneficial for scars that are still in the healing phase, as it can help reduce redness and itching. It is generally recommended to apply silicone gel twice daily, allowing it to dry completely before covering it with any other products.

Beauty Tape: Beauty tape, often referred to as silicone sheets or adhesive strips, is designed to provide pressure to the scar area. This pressure can help flatten the scar and reduce its visibility. However, the effectiveness of beauty tape relies heavily on consistent application and adequate pressure. Many patients find that beauty tape can be challenging to keep in place, especially on oily skin or in areas prone to movement.

Recommendations for Your Situation
Given that you are currently using beauty tape but experiencing issues with it adhering to your skin due to oiliness, it may be beneficial to consider the following approach:
1. Use Silicone Gel First: Since your pharmacist suggested using the silicone gel, it may be wise to start with that. Apply the silicone gel directly to the scar, ensuring that the area is clean and dry. Allow the gel to dry completely before applying any other products. This will help create a good base for scar management.

2. Incorporate Beauty Tape: After the silicone gel has dried, you can apply the beauty tape. If you find that the tape does not adhere well due to oiliness, consider using a gentle cleanser to remove excess oil from your skin before application. Additionally, you might want to try using the beauty tape for shorter periods, such as 12 hours on and 12 hours off, as suggested in some practices. This can help reduce irritation while still providing some pressure to the scar.

3. Monitor the Scar: Keep an eye on the scar’s appearance and texture. If it feels hard or raised, this could indicate that the scar is still in an active healing phase. Consistent use of silicone gel can help soften the scar tissue over time.

4. Avoid Picking or Scratching: It’s crucial to avoid picking at or scratching the scar, as this can lead to further irritation and potentially worsen the scar’s appearance.

5. Consult Your Dermatologist: Since every individual’s skin reacts differently, it’s always a good idea to consult with your dermatologist or surgeon regarding your specific situation. They can provide personalized advice based on your skin type and the characteristics of your scar.

Additional Considerations
- Sun Protection: Protecting your scar from sun exposure is vital. UV rays can darken scars, making them more noticeable. Use a broad-spectrum sunscreen with an SPF of at least 30 on the scar when exposed to sunlight.

- Hydration and Nutrition: Keeping your skin hydrated and maintaining a balanced diet can also support the healing process. Consider drinking plenty of water and consuming foods rich in vitamins C and E, which are known to promote skin health.

In conclusion, while both silicone gel and beauty tape have their benefits, starting with silicone gel may provide a more effective foundation for scar management. You can then incorporate beauty tape as needed, ensuring that you monitor the scar’s progress and consult with your healthcare provider for tailored advice. Remember, patience is key in scar healing, and consistent care will yield the best results over time.

Similar Q&A

Beauty Gels vs. Silicone Strips: Which is Better for Scar Healing?

Hello Dr. Lu: I would like to ask which is better for surgical scars, beauty gel or silicone tape, in order to make them less noticeable. Thank you.

Dr. Lu Daokuan reply Plastic Surgery
Beauty gels provide tension to the wound, making it less likely for scars to widen, while silicone adds compressive force. Silicone is more effective but is less convenient to use and tends to be more expensive.

Scar Gel vs. Beauty Tape: Can They Be Used Together for Optimal Healing?

Doctor, I bought a tube of (Mederma Scar Gel) at the hospital. It has been 20 days since my facial stitches were removed, and I have also been using 3M silicone tape. Should I use the scar gel first or the silicone tape? Or can I use both together? The plastic surgeon advised me ...

Dr. Luo Qihua reply Plastic Surgery
Question: Inquirer: Li Ya-Hui / Female / 5 / 2001/11/26 I have a 5-year-old daughter who sustained an injury to her face, with four stitches placed between her eyebrows, above her nose. I am very worried and wonder if she will be able to undergo cosmetic procedures in the future ...

Is Beauty Tape Effective for Scar Management After Surgery?

I just had a sebaceous cyst surgery on my cheek last week, and while searching for information about cosmetic tape online, I came across this article. I would like to ask the doctor about the accuracy of this information and whether silicone gel is recommended instead. Thank you....

Dr. Wu Yuxin reply Dermatology
Each physician has different practices, and there is no truly absolute correct method. For example, I typically apply cosmetic adhesive for two weeks after suture removal, and then switch to silicone gel, continuing for at least six months.

Post-Stitch Scar Care: Silicone Sheets vs. Beauty Tape

Two weeks ago, I had a car accident and during the stitch removal, the doctor advised me to use cosmetic tape for three months, but only after one week of removing the stitches. The wound is raised; should I use silicone sheets or continue using the cosmetic tape?

Dr. Lu Daokuan reply Plastic Surgery
Silicone sheets and artificial skin are both effective; however, beauty tape is less effective. Use them for up to 6 months, and if you are not satisfied, consult a plastic surgeon.