Post-Surgery Complications: Unremoved Fragments in Femoral Osteochondral Fracture - Orthopedics

Share to:

After the surgery for a right femoral condyle fracture, it was found that some fragments of bone were not completely removed. Is this considered a malpractice?


Dear Doctor,
My mother underwent surgery for a right femoral condyle fracture, but she has been experiencing persistent pain at the surgical site.
The attending physician stated that this is normal.
We then took her to a larger hospital where an orthopedic surgeon performed another procedure at the same site.
During this surgery, fragments of cartilage from the right femur were removed.
It appears that the initial surgeon did not completely remove all the cartilage fragments from the fracture site.

I would like to ask if the initial surgeon's actions can be considered free of negligence and within the bounds of normal medical practice.

Additionally, the right femur has significant cartilage damage, and the surrounding soft tissues, such as tendons and ligaments, may have sustained both internal and external injuries.
While external trauma may not always be evident, there will inevitably be varying degrees of internal injury.
Given that the initial surgeon left cartilage fragments in the right femur, could this lead to issues such as bacterial infection? My mother continues to experience pain at the surgical site.
Is it possible that an infection was present at the time of the initial surgery? I would appreciate any advice on how to address her current pain issue.

Thank you.

Wen Sheng, 40~49 year old female. Ask Date: 2018/01/26

Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics


The cartilage on the femur is located at the knee joint or hip joint, but it is not clearly stated in the document.
It does not specify how long after the surgery the patient may experience pain.
Typically, there will be a varying period of time post-surgery during which pain may still be present.
The removal of cartilage does not necessarily correlate with the pain experienced, nor is there a direct association with bacterial infection.
Since a second surgery has already been performed, the surgeon who conducted the procedure would have the most detailed understanding of the situation.

Reply Date: 2018/01/26

More Info


In the context of your mother's recent surgery for a femoral osteochondral fracture, it is understandable to have concerns regarding the surgical outcomes and potential complications. The situation you described raises several important points regarding surgical practices, postoperative complications, and the management of residual fragments.

Firstly, it is not uncommon for patients to experience pain following surgery, especially in cases involving complex structures like the femur and its surrounding soft tissues. Postoperative pain can be attributed to various factors, including inflammation, surgical trauma, and the healing process. However, persistent pain that does not improve over time may warrant further investigation, as it could indicate complications such as the presence of unremoved fragments, infection, or other issues.

Regarding the surgical technique employed by the initial surgeon, it is essential to understand that while surgeons strive for complete removal of all fragments during surgery, there are instances where small fragments may be inadvertently left behind. This can occur due to the complexity of the fracture, the surgeon's assessment during the procedure, or the visibility of the fragments. In many cases, the presence of small, non-symptomatic fragments may not lead to significant complications. However, if these fragments are large enough or positioned in a way that they cause irritation or inflammation, they can lead to ongoing pain and discomfort.

As for the question of whether the initial surgeon's actions constitute negligence, this is a nuanced issue. Medical malpractice typically requires proof that the surgeon deviated from the standard of care expected in similar circumstances. If the surgeon acted within the bounds of accepted medical practice and made a reasonable judgment based on the situation, it may not be considered negligence. However, if it can be demonstrated that the surgeon failed to meet the standard of care—such as not adequately assessing the fracture or not taking appropriate measures to remove all fragments—then there may be grounds for concern.

In terms of the risk of infection, the presence of retained fragments can potentially increase the risk of complications, including infection. If fragments are left behind, they can serve as a nidus for bacterial growth, leading to postoperative infections. Symptoms of infection may include increased pain, swelling, redness, warmth at the surgical site, and systemic symptoms such as fever. If your mother is experiencing ongoing pain, it is crucial to consult with her healthcare provider to rule out any signs of infection or other complications.

To address the current pain your mother is experiencing, it is advisable to follow up with her orthopedic surgeon or a specialist who can evaluate her condition. They may recommend imaging studies, such as X-rays or MRI, to assess the surgical site for any retained fragments or other issues. Depending on the findings, further interventions may be necessary, which could include additional surgery to remove any problematic fragments or other treatments to manage pain and inflammation.

In conclusion, while postoperative pain can be a normal part of the healing process, persistent pain should be thoroughly evaluated to rule out complications. The presence of unremoved fragments can potentially lead to further issues, including infection. It is essential to maintain open communication with healthcare providers to ensure appropriate management of your mother's condition and to address any concerns regarding the initial surgical procedure.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Complications and Recovery After Femur Fracture Surgery

I apologize for the inconvenience. I suffered an open fracture of the left femur due to a car accident and currently have a steel plate implanted for treatment. I would like to ask if there are any potential complications associated with the implanted plate. Additionally, I just ...


Dr. Yang Zhengfan reply Orthopedics
I'm sorry

[Read More] Understanding Complications and Recovery After Femur Fracture Surgery


Unexpected Complications After Plate Removal: Unhealed Fracture and New Surgery

Hello, doctor. I had a regrettable incident while having a plate removed in a rural area: 1. I fractured my metatarsal in early August last year and had a plate installed. A year later, during a follow-up visit, an X-ray was taken, and the doctor assessed whether the plate could ...


Dr. Wang Jiacheng reply Orthopedics
1. It is usually necessary to confirm that the fracture has healed before removing the metal plate. 2. It is possible that it has not fully healed yet.

[Read More] Unexpected Complications After Plate Removal: Unhealed Fracture and New Surgery


Post-Removal Care Tips for External Fixators in Orthopedics

Dear Dr. Shi, I hope this message finds you well. I have a question regarding external fixators. I have heard that in a few cases, after the removal of a thigh external fixator, the bone fractured for unknown reasons. Therefore, I would like to ask you what measures are recommen...


Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
First, it is important to ensure that the healing of the bone extension site is complete before removing the device. After removal, avoid any jarring movements. Additionally, when walking, it is advisable to initially use crutches for support until the thigh can bear weight witho...

[Read More] Post-Removal Care Tips for External Fixators in Orthopedics


Understanding Complications After Hip Surgery: Pins, Plates, and Recovery

Dear Doctor, I underwent surgery on May 7th for a "right pelvic fracture with associated right hip dislocation." However, the doctor informed me that my pelvis is fragmented, and instead of a hip replacement, I opted for the implantation of screws and plates. I have a f...


Dr. Ye Qingnian reply Orthopedics
In the case of a comminuted right hip fracture, it is crucial to strictly follow the attending physician's instructions and avoid putting weight on the affected leg; otherwise, displacement may occur, leading to lifelong regrets. If there is significant pain, an X-ray should...

[Read More] Understanding Complications After Hip Surgery: Pins, Plates, and Recovery


Related FAQ

Post-Femoral Fracture Surgery

(Orthopedics)

Femoral Fracture

(Orthopedics)

Tibial Fracture

(Orthopedics)

Fibula Fracture

(Orthopedics)

Coccygeal Fracture

(Orthopedics)

Clavicle Fracture

(Orthopedics)

Ankle Fracture Recovery

(Orthopedics)

Talus Fracture

(Orthopedics)

Dislocation

(Orthopedics)

Pelvic Fracture

(Orthopedics)