False Positives in Exercise ECG: Common Causes Explained

Issues with Exercise Electrocardiogram (ECG)

Hello Doctor: Last year, I had a stress electrocardiogram (ECG) done at a large hospital, which indicated signs of hypoxia.
The physician suggested that I undergo a cardiac catheterization or a self-paid cardiac scan.
However, due to concerns about the risks associated with these tests, I opted for a self-paid cardiac CT scan instead.
The results were normal, except for a minor issue with one of my coronary arteries being slightly compressed.
I would like to ask the doctor: what is the most likely cause of a "false positive" result in a stress ECG? The physician did not explain it clearly at the time, and I have been struggling to understand why the stress ECG covered by insurance indicated hypoxia, while the self-paid cardiac CT scan costing 15,000 NTD showed normal results (with only a slight compression of a coronary artery, which the doctor said was not a concern and just needed observation).
I couldn't find detailed information online regarding the causes of false positives in stress ECGs, and this uncertainty has been troubling me for a long time.
I would appreciate your clarification.
Thank you, Doctor.

Mr. Wang, 40~49 year old female. Ask Date: 2018/07/13

Dr. He Dongjin reply Cardiology

Hello, the positive result may be related to respiratory issues, body weight, breast size, or even coronary artery compression.
As long as you are safe and well, that's what matters.
Changhua Hospital cares about you.

Reply Date: 2018/07/13

More Info

Understanding false positives in exercise electrocardiograms (ECGs) is crucial for patients who undergo these tests, especially when the results seem contradictory to other diagnostic methods like coronary CT scans. A false positive occurs when a test indicates a problem (such as myocardial ischemia) when, in fact, there is none. This can lead to unnecessary anxiety and further testing, which may carry risks.

Several factors can contribute to false positives in exercise ECGs:
1. Physiological Variability: The heart's response to exercise can vary significantly among individuals. Factors such as age, fitness level, and even hydration status can influence heart rate and blood pressure responses during exercise. For example, a well-conditioned athlete may exhibit different ECG changes compared to a sedentary individual, potentially leading to misinterpretation of the results.

2. Technical Factors: The quality of the ECG recording can be affected by electrode placement, skin preparation, and patient movement during the test. Poor electrode contact or motion artifacts can create misleading ST segment changes that may be interpreted as ischemia.

3. Medications: Certain medications, especially those affecting heart rate and blood pressure, can alter the ECG response to exercise. For instance, beta-blockers can blunt the heart rate response, potentially masking ischemic changes.

4. Baseline Conditions: Pre-existing conditions such as left ventricular hypertrophy, electrolyte imbalances, or even anxiety can affect the ECG readings. These conditions may cause changes that mimic ischemia, leading to false positive results.

5. ST Segment Changes: The interpretation of ST segment changes can be subjective. Upsloping ST segment depression, for example, is often considered less indicative of ischemia compared to horizontal or downsloping changes. However, the presence of any ST segment depression during exercise can still raise concerns, even if it is not clinically significant.

6. Gender Differences: Research indicates that women may exhibit different ECG responses to exercise compared to men, which can complicate the interpretation of results. Women are more likely to experience false positives due to differences in heart size, hormonal influences, and vascular responses.

In your case, the discrepancy between the exercise ECG indicating ischemia and the coronary CT scan showing normal results could be attributed to one or more of these factors. It is essential to understand that no single test can provide a definitive diagnosis of coronary artery disease (CAD). Each test has its strengths and limitations, and results should be interpreted in the context of the overall clinical picture, including symptoms, risk factors, and other diagnostic findings.

If you have concerns about the results of your exercise ECG or the recommendations for further testing, it is advisable to discuss these with your healthcare provider. They can provide clarity on the significance of the findings and help determine the best course of action based on your individual health status and risk factors. Additionally, if you have a family history of heart disease, as you mentioned, it is crucial to remain vigilant and proactive about your cardiovascular health. Regular follow-ups and appropriate lifestyle modifications can significantly reduce your risk of developing heart-related issues.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Positive Exercise ECG Results: What You Need to Know

Previously, the resting electrocardiogram (ECG) was normal. In early April, during a health check-up, a flat T wave was observed, prompting a referral for a treadmill exercise test. Based on the report dated April 23, 2024, the findings are as follows: 1. Resting ECG: normal sin...

Dr. Wu Xueming reply Cardiology
A positive exercise electrocardiogram (ECG) may indicate the possibility of coronary artery disease. If you have risk factors for heart disease, such as diabetes, hypertension, smoking, etc., along with typical symptoms of chest discomfort, it is recommended to consult with a phy...

Understanding Exercise ECG: Insights on Heart Palpitations and Risks

Hello Doctor, I have recently experienced occasional palpitations. I underwent an echocardiogram and a 24-hour Holter monitor, both of which showed no significant abnormalities. I then arranged for a stress test, and the report is as follows. I would like to know if this situatio...

Dr. Wu Xueming reply Cardiology
The results of the exercise electrocardiogram (ECG) are positive. If you continue to experience symptoms of chest tightness or chest pain, please visit the outpatient clinic to discuss with your physician whether further testing is necessary.

Understanding Exercise ECG Abnormalities in Heart Disease Patients

Hello, Doctor. A year ago, during a cardiology examination with a resting electrocardiogram, I was diagnosed with myocardial ischemia. Occasionally, I experience sharp chest pain and a feeling of breathlessness, but it is not very uncomfortable. After undergoing a stress test, ec...

Dr. He Dongjin reply Cardiology
Hello, it doesn't seem like a condition caused by heart failure. Let's wait for further examinations. Ping An Changhua Hospital cares about you.

Understanding Exercise ECG Results: What to Expect After Testing

Hello, I have an issue with arrhythmia. Recently, I fainted suddenly, so I underwent an exercise electrocardiogram and blood tests. Aside from a cholesterol level of 190 and a fasting blood glucose level of 101, there don't seem to be any other problems. Here are the report ...

Dr. Wu Xueming reply Cardiology
The results of the exercise electrocardiogram need to be interpreted in conjunction with clinical symptoms indicative of cardiovascular disease, and the positive predictive value is approximately 60 to 70 percent. Therefore, additional tests are still required to determine if you...