Can a patient with a comminuted tibial fracture bear weight after 12 weeks?
Hello Dr.
Lee, I sustained a spiral comminuted fracture of the distal third of my tibia on August 31, and it has been over 12 weeks since then.
During my follow-up appointment last week, the X-ray showed no signs of callus formation.
However, my attending physician mentioned that he thinks I can start using a single crutch to walk as long as I don't experience pain.
I believe this could help stimulate the bone healing process, but I'm concerned that without callus formation, the plate might not have enough support and could deform.
Currently, I can walk with one crutch without significant pain.
I would like to hear your opinion on this matter.
Additionally, I was not placed in a cast upon discharge but instead purchased a pneumatic ankle-foot orthosis.
While recovering at home, I rarely wore the brace since I wasn't going out.
Could this lack of compression have affected the callus formation? Now, I can walk with one crutch without pain when I'm not wearing the brace, and I've tried walking without a crutch while wearing the brace, which also doesn't cause pain.
Given this situation, what would you recommend I do? Thank you for taking the time to respond!
HY, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2018/11/27
Dr. Li Yongheng reply Orthopedics
Hello: 1.
The patient has a spiral comminuted fracture of the distal third of the tibia that has exceeded 12 weeks, and no callus formation is observed on the X-ray.
Currently, even with the use of a pneumatic ankle brace, it is not advisable to completely avoid using crutches.
However, the patient may use a single crutch for ambulation as long as there is no pain.
2.
Since the fracture has exceeded 12 weeks and there are concerns regarding the range of motion in the ankle joint, the use of the pneumatic ankle brace is no longer necessary.
Reply Date: 2018/11/27
More Info
After a tibial fracture, particularly a spiral comminuted fracture in the lower third of the tibia, the recovery process can be complex and requires careful management to ensure proper healing and to minimize the risk of complications. Given that you are now over 12 weeks post-injury and have not yet observed any signs of callus formation on your X-rays, it is understandable that you have concerns regarding weight-bearing activities and the overall healing process.
Weight Bearing and Activity Level
Your physician's recommendation to use a single crutch for walking, as long as you are not experiencing pain, is a common approach in rehabilitation after a fracture. The absence of pain is a positive indicator that your body may be adapting to the stress of weight-bearing. However, it is crucial to proceed with caution. The lack of visible callus formation on your X-rays does raise some concerns about the stability of the fracture site. Callus formation is a natural part of the healing process, indicating that the body is beginning to bridge the fracture gap with new bone tissue.
Concerns About the Absence of Callus Formation
The absence of callus formation at this stage could be due to several factors, including the nature of the fracture, the surgical technique used, and your individual healing response. It is essential to maintain communication with your orthopedic surgeon regarding your healing progress. If there is a concern about the stability of the fracture site, your doctor may recommend further imaging or adjustments to your rehabilitation plan.
Use of the Ankle Brace
Regarding the use of the pneumatic ankle brace, it is designed to provide support and protection to the injured area. While it is true that not wearing the brace may have allowed for more mobility, it could also have contributed to a lack of mechanical stability at the fracture site. Compression and support from a brace can help facilitate the healing process by providing a controlled environment for the fracture to heal. If you have been able to walk without pain while wearing the brace, it may be beneficial to continue using it, especially during weight-bearing activities.
Recommendations Moving Forward
1. Gradual Increase in Weight Bearing: If you are comfortable and pain-free while using one crutch, you might consider gradually increasing your weight-bearing activities. Start with partial weight-bearing and progress as tolerated. Always listen to your body; if you experience pain, reduce your activity level.
2. Continue Using the Brace: It may be wise to continue using the pneumatic brace during your rehabilitation, especially when you are engaging in weight-bearing activities. This will provide additional support and may help in the formation of callus.
3. Physical Therapy: Engaging in a structured physical therapy program can be beneficial. A physical therapist can guide you through exercises that promote strength, flexibility, and stability while ensuring that you do not overload the healing bone.
4. Follow-Up Imaging: Regular follow-up appointments with your orthopedic surgeon are crucial. If there is still no evidence of callus formation in the coming weeks, your doctor may consider additional interventions, such as adjusting your rehabilitation plan or further imaging studies.
5. Nutrition and Bone Health: Ensure that you are consuming a diet rich in calcium and vitamin D, as these nutrients are vital for bone healing. Discuss with your healthcare provider whether supplementation might be necessary.
In conclusion, while it is encouraging that you can walk with a crutch without pain, it is essential to proceed with caution given the lack of callus formation. Maintain open communication with your healthcare team, adhere to their recommendations, and consider the use of supportive devices to facilitate your recovery. Your proactive approach to your rehabilitation is commendable, and with careful management, you can work towards a successful recovery.
Similar Q&A
Post-Surgery Rehabilitation for Ankle Tibia Fractures: A Patient's Journey
Hello Dr. Hong, I fell from a height of 2.5 meters, and upon landing, I heavily impacted my left foot, resulting in a fracture on the lateral side of the distal tibia. I underwent surgery where two steel screws were inserted externally to stabilize the tibia. Two weeks post-surge...
Dr. Hong Ximing reply Orthopedics
After an ankle joint fracture, it is recommended to avoid weight-bearing for 6-8 weeks to maintain joint stability. It is advised to use assistive devices for partial weight-bearing to prevent affecting fracture healing and joint stability.[Read More] Post-Surgery Rehabilitation for Ankle Tibia Fractures: A Patient's Journey
Recovery Tips for Tibial Fracture and Lateral Ligament Injury
Hello Dr. Tsai: I was in a car accident on May 16th and underwent open reduction and internal fixation of a right tibial fracture and lateral collateral ligament repair on May 17th. It has been about 47 days since the surgery. I have been gradually undergoing rehabilitation and p...
Dr. Cai Shanglin reply Orthopedics
Six weeks after surgery, an initial X-ray will typically be taken to assess whether the plate has shifted or if there is any further displacement of the fracture. Your attending physician should explain these findings to you and inform you whether you can put weight on your right...[Read More] Recovery Tips for Tibial Fracture and Lateral Ligament Injury
Managing Pain and Discomfort After Tibial Fracture Surgery
Hello doctor, in February of this year, I had a tibial fracture in my left ankle and underwent surgery for internal fixation with a plate. It has been six months since the surgery, but my foot still experiences persistent soreness and numbness, especially when walking. I also hav...
Dr. Chen Yongxue reply Orthopedics
Hello, fractures typically allow for full weight-bearing approximately three months after surgery. In your case, it is possible that a lack of weight-bearing for some time has led to stiffness in the tendons and joints. Please visit an orthopedic outpatient clinic for further eva...[Read More] Managing Pain and Discomfort After Tibial Fracture Surgery
Understanding Fibula Fracture Recovery: Weight-Bearing Guidelines After Surgery
Doctor, my physician advised me not to put weight on my leg for six weeks after surgery. Does this mean that the bone is not ready to bear weight yet, or is it to allow the soft tissues to heal? Is six weeks the minimum time required, or could it take longer? That's why the ...
Dr. Hong Ximing reply Orthopedics
Six weeks after fibula surgery serves a protective function to prevent excessive activity that could affect the healing of soft tissues.[Read More] Understanding Fibula Fracture Recovery: Weight-Bearing Guidelines After Surgery
Related FAQ
(Orthopedics)
Tibial Fracture(Orthopedics)
Tibia And Fibula Fracture(Orthopedics)
Post-Fracture Rehabilitation(Orthopedics)
Knee Fracture(Orthopedics)
Tibia(Orthopedics)
Tibia(Rehabilitation)
Talus Fracture(Orthopedics)
Post-Clavicle Fracture Surgery(Orthopedics)
Ankle Fracture Recovery(Orthopedics)