Choosing the Right Crown for Molars: Porcelain vs. Precious Metal Options - Dentistry

Share to:

Choosing Molars Braces


Due to the silver crown placed on the first upper molar during childhood having become exposed and experiencing issues such as cavities and gum recession, it needs to be redone.
However, I am unsure which material is more durable for the chewing area.
Which has better marginal fit, all-ceramic crowns or precious metal ceramic crowns? Currently, the dentist has advised that opting for a precious metal ceramic crown may not be as beneficial as choosing an all-ceramic crown.
Is this correct? Are all-ceramic crowns placed on molars less durable or more prone to wear against the lower teeth compared to precious metal ceramic crowns? Thank you.

Anna, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2019/02/11

Dr. Lin Jiayong reply Dentistry


Hello, typically, dental prosthetics made from precious metals are more suitable for areas with high occlusal forces, and the fit of precious metals is generally better.
However, all-ceramic crowns are more aesthetically pleasing and have better biocompatibility, making them less likely to cause periodontal disease or allergic reactions.
Nevertheless, it is still recommended to make the best decision based on the clinical situation.
Thank you, Lin Chia-Yung, Department of Dentistry, Taichung Hospital.

Reply Date: 2019/02/11

More Info


When it comes to choosing the right crown for molars, particularly in the context of porcelain versus precious metal options, there are several factors to consider, including durability, aesthetics, fit, and the specific dental needs of the patient.

Durability and Strength: Molars are subjected to significant forces during chewing, which means that the material used for crowns in these areas must be strong enough to withstand these pressures. Traditionally, precious metal crowns (such as gold) have been favored for their exceptional strength and durability. They are less likely to fracture or wear down over time compared to porcelain crowns. However, advancements in dental materials have led to the development of high-strength ceramics that can also be used for molars. These materials, such as zirconia, offer a good balance of strength and aesthetics.

Fit and Marginal Integrity: The fit of a crown is crucial for its longevity and the health of the surrounding tooth structure. Precious metal crowns generally provide excellent marginal integrity due to their malleability, allowing for a precise fit. On the other hand, porcelain crowns can also achieve a good fit, but the technique used during placement is critical. If not properly fitted, porcelain crowns may be more prone to chipping or wear, especially in high-stress areas like molars.

Aesthetics: While aesthetics may not be the primary concern for posterior teeth, it is still worth mentioning. Porcelain crowns offer a more natural appearance, closely resembling the color and translucency of natural teeth. This can be a significant factor for patients who are concerned about the visibility of metal crowns, especially if they have a high smile line or if the molars are visible when they talk or laugh.

Wear and Tear: There is a common concern regarding the wear of opposing teeth when using different crown materials. Precious metal crowns are less abrasive than porcelain crowns, which can lead to less wear on the opposing teeth. Conversely, some high-strength ceramics can be more abrasive, potentially leading to increased wear on adjacent natural teeth. Therefore, the choice of material should also consider the condition of the opposing dentition.

Clinical Recommendations: Your dentist's recommendation to consider a precious metal crown over a porcelain crown may be based on your specific dental situation, including the extent of decay, the structural integrity of the remaining tooth, and your chewing habits. If your molar has significant wear or if you are prone to grinding your teeth (bruxism), a precious metal crown may provide better longevity and resistance to fracture.

In conclusion, both porcelain and precious metal crowns have their advantages and disadvantages. If aesthetics are a priority and the molar is not subjected to extreme forces, a high-strength porcelain crown may be suitable. However, if durability and strength are paramount, especially in cases of heavy occlusion or bruxism, a precious metal crown may be the better choice. It is essential to have a thorough discussion with your dentist about your specific needs, preferences, and any concerns you may have regarding the materials before making a decision.

Similar Q&A

Choosing the Best Dental Crown After Root Canal Treatment: A Guide

Hello, Doctor! I have had root canal treatment on the third tooth from the back on the upper side, and now I need to choose a dental crown after completing the post. Among the following crown options: all-ceramic crown, porcelain-fused-to-metal crown, all-zirconia crown, and full...


Dr. Lin Jiayong reply Dentistry
Hello: The selection of orthodontic materials should be discussed in conjunction with the clinical situation (occlusal habits, working area, dental structure, operational difficulty, and economic factors). It is not necessarily better just because it is more expensive or newer; o...

[Read More] Choosing the Best Dental Crown After Root Canal Treatment: A Guide


Choosing the Right Dental Bridge Material: Zirconia vs. Metal Options

I would like to ask everyone, I am currently getting a dental bridge and initially wanted to have a full zirconia crown, but my dentist recommended a semi-precious metal crown (which can be porcelain-fused) instead. The reason is that if a full zirconia crown accidentally bites d...


Dr. Zeng Guanghui reply Dentistry
1. Considering strength issues, it is recommended to use traditional metal-ceramic crowns, while for the bridge, it is advisable to use a hygienic dental bridge for easier cleaning and maintenance. 2. If a single crown is needed, a full zirconia crown can be used. Dr. Tseng Guang...

[Read More] Choosing the Right Dental Bridge Material: Zirconia vs. Metal Options


Is Palladium in Dental Crowns Safe After Root Canal Treatment?

Hello, doctor. I would like to inquire about root canal treatment. Generally, dentists recommend placing a crown afterward. I found that crowns made from precious metals often contain "palladium," which I read online is classified as a heavy metal and may be harmful to ...


Dr. Zhang Xiangyuan reply Dentistry
Dear online friend, Based on your description, after root canal treatment, you are considering dental crowns. The choice of materials for crowns can vary the cost depending on the type of cast metal used. Generally, the metals used in dentistry are classified into three categor...

[Read More] Is Palladium in Dental Crowns Safe After Root Canal Treatment?


Understanding Costs and Material Choices for Dental Crowns and Inlays

Hello, Doctor. About a month or two ago, the filling on my last lower right tooth fell out. After evaluation, the doctor determined that it was not suitable to refill, but there was no need for a root canal treatment. Therefore, I opted for a porcelain inlay (out-of-pocket cost o...


Dr. Huang Tingfang reply Dentistry
Dear Anonymous Miss: Hello! Whether to perform a root canal treatment is determined by the physician, mainly due to symptoms such as pain when drinking hot water, sensitivity to touch, and continuous pain lasting over an hour. For the posterior teeth, you can choose a metal crown...

[Read More] Understanding Costs and Material Choices for Dental Crowns and Inlays


Related FAQ

Porcelain Crown

(Dentistry)

Molars

(Dentistry)

Enamel

(Dentistry)

Bruxism

(Dentistry)

Crown Lengthening

(Dentistry)

Silver Filling

(Dentistry)

Temporary Crown

(Dentistry)

Tooth Alignment

(Dentistry)

Teeth Grinding

(Dentistry)

Inquiry

(Dentistry)