Does a secondary fracture displacement require a second surgery?
Thank you, Dr.
Wang, for taking the time to answer.
My brother had an accident while riding a motorcycle last June, resulting in a closed femoral fracture.
Due to insufficient femoral diameter, intramedullary nailing could not be performed, so a titanium alloy plate was used for fixation along with artificial bone grafting.
Three months post-surgery, there was still a slight gap, but today in February, while riding again, he unfortunately sustained another closed femoral fracture above the original injury site.
This time, a health insurance-approved steel plate was used for fixation.
However, during the follow-up visit for suture removal, after reviewing the postoperative X-ray, I noticed that the alignment is not as aesthetically pleasing as the first time, showing a shape that resembles __| ̄.
The attending physician mentioned that it would not affect his mobility and that the callus would encapsulate, so there is no need for excessive concern.
However, from the X-ray, it appears rather pessimistic and abnormal, which is why I would like to ask Dr.
Wang about the following:
1.
Is a second surgery necessary?
2.
What could be the possible reasons for this outcome?
3.
As the attending physician stated, will it truly not affect mobility or cause leg length discrepancy?
4.
If a second surgery is not required, could you provide guidance on the subsequent rehabilitation direction or goals?
Erci Guzh fracture, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2019/03/06
Dr. Wang Shouji reply Orthopedics
Hello: According to the X-ray, the fracture at the lower end has healed, while the upper fracture may be limited by the lower plate, resulting in a discrepancy.
The healing status will depend on the extent of soft tissue detachment from the periosteum during surgery.
However, due to the significant degree of discrepancy, it is not possible to assess whether deformity of the thigh will occur based solely on one X-ray.
In the second surgery, the stability observed on the X-ray will be poorer, and weight-bearing should be avoided.
If possible, re-fixation with a longer plate should be considered.
If the lower fracture has stabilized, the original plate at the lower end can be removed to prevent interference with the fixation of the second fracture.
Changhua Hospital cares about your health.
Wang Shou-ji.
Reply Date: 2019/03/06
More Info
When it comes to misaligned bone fractures, the decision to undergo a second surgery is often complex and depends on several factors, including the type and severity of the fracture, the alignment of the bones, and the overall healing process. In your brother's case, he experienced a closed femoral fracture that was initially treated with a titanium alloy plate and bone grafting. After a subsequent injury, he underwent another surgery with a different plate. The X-ray results showing misalignment can understandably cause concern, but let's break down the considerations regarding the need for a second surgery and the implications of the current situation.
1. Need for a Second Surgery: The necessity for a second surgery largely depends on the degree of misalignment and whether it affects the function of the limb. If the misalignment is minor and does not compromise the stability of the bone or the surrounding structures, a second surgery may not be required. Your brother's surgeon indicated that the misalignment would not affect his athletic ability or lead to discrepancies in leg length, which is a positive sign. However, if there is significant displacement or if the bone is not healing properly, a second surgery might be warranted to realign the bone and ensure proper healing.
2. Possible Causes of Misalignment: Several factors can contribute to misalignment after a fracture. These include inadequate initial stabilization, the nature of the fracture itself (e.g., comminuted fractures may be more prone to misalignment), and the healing process. In some cases, the bone may not heal in the correct position due to movement during the healing phase or insufficient fixation. Additionally, the quality of the bone (e.g., osteoporosis or other conditions) can also impact healing and alignment.
3. Impact on Function and Leg Length: The surgeon's reassurance that the misalignment will not affect your brother's function or lead to leg length discrepancies is crucial. Generally, as long as the bone heals adequately and the joint mechanics remain intact, minor misalignments may not result in functional deficits. However, it is essential to monitor for any changes in pain levels, mobility, or function, as these could indicate complications.
4. Rehabilitation Goals: If a second surgery is not necessary, rehabilitation will focus on restoring strength, flexibility, and function to the affected limb. The rehabilitation process typically includes physical therapy aimed at improving range of motion, strengthening the muscles surrounding the joint, and gradually increasing activity levels. The goals of rehabilitation should be tailored to your brother's specific needs, considering his previous injuries and current condition. It is essential to work closely with a physical therapist who can develop a personalized program that addresses his recovery goals while ensuring safety and effectiveness.
In conclusion, while the concern about misalignment is valid, the decision for a second surgery should be made in consultation with the orthopedic surgeon, who can assess the X-ray findings and your brother's clinical status. If surgery is not required, a structured rehabilitation program will be vital for restoring function and ensuring a successful recovery. Regular follow-ups with the healthcare provider will help monitor progress and make any necessary adjustments to the treatment plan.
Similar Q&A
Concerns About Misaligned Second Metatarsal Fracture Recovery
Hello doctor, I would like to ask about my condition. It has been over two months since my surgery on June 10th, and my bone recovery has not been ideal. Additionally, it has shifted and is now misaligned. The doctor mentioned during my follow-up visit that there shouldn't b...
Dr. You Dianqi reply Orthopedics
Hello Mr. Wu, since each individual's condition and recovery status vary, it is advisable to consult your original treating (surgical) physician for their opinion. If you still have concerns, you may bring your personal medical records and relevant examination data to anothe...[Read More] Concerns About Misaligned Second Metatarsal Fracture Recovery
Do I Need Surgery for My Open Comminuted Fracture Recovery?
Sixty-seven days ago, I suffered an open comminuted fracture above the knee on my thigh due to a car accident. Currently, I have a cast for stabilization, and the doctor did not perform surgery at the time. The doctor mentioned waiting for the bone to heal on its own and to under...
Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
It is essential to review the X-ray images to make the most accurate assessment. If a fracture has not healed properly or is misaligned, surgery may be necessary. In adults, it is common for femoral fractures to require surgical intervention. I am not familiar with your specific ...[Read More] Do I Need Surgery for My Open Comminuted Fracture Recovery?
Post-Fracture Treatment Options: Can Surgery Correct Misalignment?
Hello, doctor. A few months ago, I fell and fractured my left pinky finger. After treatment, I still feel limited movement at the fracture site three months later. I went back to the hospital for an X-ray and found that the healing was misaligned. The lateral X-ray showed that th...
Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
If a fracture heals improperly and affects function, surgical intervention may be necessary to re-fixate it. If it does not impact function, surgery may not be required. Aside from surgery, there are no other methods to correct the alignment.[Read More] Post-Fracture Treatment Options: Can Surgery Correct Misalignment?
Can a Deformed Toe Joint Be Corrected After a Fracture?
Hello, doctor. The second joint of my second toe has a gap and is misaligned. However, I did not seek medical attention immediately and only had an X-ray taken after a month. At that time, the orthopedic doctor advised me not to move it and to let the bone heal on its own. Now, t...
Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
Toe fractures typically heal within two months. If there is no pain, surgical treatment is not necessary. Surgical intervention may not restore the toe to its original condition prior to the fracture.[Read More] Can a Deformed Toe Joint Be Corrected After a Fracture?
Related FAQ
(Orthopedics)
Post-Tibial Fracture Surgery(Orthopedics)
Dislocation(Orthopedics)
Post-Clavicle Fracture Surgery(Orthopedics)
Fibula Fracture(Orthopedics)
Femoral Fracture(Orthopedics)
Tibia(Orthopedics)
Fracture Healing(Orthopedics)
Ankle Fracture(Orthopedics)
Spinal Fracture(Orthopedics)