Lumbar Spine Issues: When to Consider Surgery for Pain Relief

Vertebral arch issues

Last November, I experienced lower back pain due to a fall and sought medical attention.
The physician and neurosurgeon indicated that there were no significant issues and prescribed pain medication.
However, on February 25th of this year, I experienced severe lower back pain that prevented me from getting up, walking, or even turning over without pain.
After an examination, the X-ray diagnosis revealed that the lumbar spine flexion and extension lateral views showed a defect at the L5-S1 pars interarticularis, ruling out spondylolysis.
The lumbar spine two views confirmed a defect at the pars interarticularis of L5-S1.
The physician suggested that surgical treatment might be necessary, specifically a fusion surgery, and prescribed stronger pain medication while advising me to consider the surgery and arrange for an MRI.

Two days ago, I underwent an MRI, which revealed the following main findings: - L5/S1 left juxtafacet protruding disc with indentation on the underlying thecal sac and nerve root.
- L5 pars defect.

I would like to ask the physician if surgical treatment would be a better option in this situation, as I am currently reliant on pain medication.
If surgery is recommended, what type of surgical procedure might be performed? Thank you for your guidance, doctor.

Mr. Chen, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2019/03/08

Dr. Li Yongheng reply Orthopedics

Hello, if there is a fracture of the vertebral arch with associated nerve root compression, and symptoms of persistent pain continue despite medication treatment, surgical intervention is recommended.
The surgical approach often involves vertebral arch screw fixation combined with spinal fusion surgery.
Wishing you a speedy recovery.

Reply Date: 2019/03/08

More Info

When considering surgery for lumbar spine issues, particularly in cases like yours where there is a defect at the L5-S1 level and associated symptoms, it is crucial to weigh the benefits and risks of surgical intervention against conservative management options.
From your description, it seems that you have been experiencing significant pain and functional limitations due to a defect in the pars interarticularis at L5-S1, which could indicate spondylolysis, and a protruding disc that is affecting the nerve root. These findings can lead to symptoms such as severe lower back pain, radiating pain, numbness, or weakness in the legs, which can significantly impact your quality of life.

When to Consider Surgery
Surgery is typically recommended when:
1. Conservative Treatments Fail: If you have tried physical therapy, medications (including stronger pain relievers), and other non-surgical interventions without significant improvement in your symptoms, surgery may be warranted.

2. Severe Symptoms: If you experience debilitating pain that prevents you from performing daily activities, or if you have neurological symptoms such as weakness or numbness in the legs, surgical options should be considered.

3. Structural Issues: The presence of a significant structural defect, such as a defect in the pars interarticularis along with a protruding disc that is compressing nerve structures, often necessitates surgical intervention to relieve pressure and stabilize the spine.

Surgical Options
In your case, the recommended surgical approach appears to be spinal fusion. Here’s a brief overview of what that entails:
1. Spinal Fusion: This procedure involves joining two or more vertebrae together to eliminate motion at that segment of the spine, which can help alleviate pain. The surgeon may use bone grafts and instrumentation (like screws and rods) to stabilize the spine during the healing process.
2. Decompression Surgery: If the protruding disc is significantly compressing the nerve root, the surgeon may also perform a discectomy, which involves removing the portion of the disc that is pressing on the nerve. This can be done in conjunction with spinal fusion.

3. Minimally Invasive Techniques: Depending on the specifics of your case and the surgeon's expertise, there may be options for minimally invasive surgery, which can reduce recovery time and postoperative pain.

Risks and Considerations
While surgery can provide significant relief, it is not without risks. Potential complications include infection, bleeding, nerve damage, and the possibility that the surgery may not relieve pain as expected. Additionally, recovery can take time, and physical therapy is often necessary post-surgery to regain strength and mobility.

Conclusion
Given your current reliance on pain medications and the severity of your symptoms, it may be beneficial to consider the surgical option your doctor has suggested. However, it is essential to have a thorough discussion with your orthopedic or neurosurgeon about the expected outcomes, risks, and the specifics of the surgical procedure. You might also want to seek a second opinion if you feel uncertain about the recommended approach.

Ultimately, the decision should be made collaboratively with your healthcare provider, considering your specific circumstances, lifestyle, and preferences. It is crucial to address these issues promptly to prevent further deterioration of your condition and to improve your quality of life.

Similar Q&A

Chronic Spine Pain: When Is Surgery the Right Option?

I apologize for the inconvenience. I have been experiencing long-term spinal pain and have visited five different hospitals without satisfactory results or improvement. Recently, I went to China Medical University to see an orthopedic specialist, who informed me that my intervert...

Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
The diagnosis of intervertebral disc damage is not based on a single factor; it is essential to determine whether an MRI (Magnetic Resonance Imaging) has been performed. Back pain can be related to various factors, and the decision to undergo surgery requires both imaging studies...

Understanding Lumbar Pain: When to Consider Surgery for Hip Issues

Hello, Dr. Wang! Over the past year, I initially experienced soreness and pain on the outer side of my knee after walking for a long time. Six months later, I started to feel pain in my right lumbar region (specifically from the right side of my lower back, through my hip, down t...

Dr. Wang Jiacheng reply Orthopedics
It is recommended that you refer to the information provided by the Ministry of Health and Welfare, as follows: Shared Decision Making (SDM) encourages patients to bravely express their questions and thoughts, helping healthcare providers understand the patients' needs. It a...

Should I Consider Minimally Invasive Surgery for Disc Herniation?

Hello Doctor: I would like to ask if there are two clearly protruding discs that are affecting the nerves, but the cartilage has not yet ruptured, should minimally invasive surgery be considered from the beginning? Current status: I have experienced lower back pain for three mont...

Dr. Lai Zhaokang reply Neurosurgery
Hello: 1. An MRI is needed to assess the situation. 2. However, if you feel that your symptoms are manageable and do not affect your quality of life, you can initially try conservative treatment, including rest, a back brace, medication, and rehabilitation therapy, followed by co...

Understanding Leg Cramps: When to Consider Surgery for Nerve Issues

Doctor: I apologize for asking again, but if it concerns the fifth lumbar nerve, is it serious enough to require surgery?

Dr. Gao Chunde reply Neurology
There are many conservative treatment options available before considering surgery. If the examination does not reveal the issues I mentioned, then the treatment and diagnostic approach will need to be reassessed, and we will not jump straight to surgery.