Post-Tonsillectomy: Why Do Tonsil Stones Still Occur? - Otolaryngology

Share to:

After tonsillectomy, stone formation may still occur?


Hello Doctor, I had my palatine tonsils removed in 2016 due to issues with tonsillar abscess, stones, and halitosis.
After the surgery, the halitosis persisted.
In November 2018, I began to notice a foul odor emanating from my mouth or nasal cavity (normally I cannot smell my own halitosis).
Shortly after, I found three small white substances resembling tonsil stones that fell out from either my mouth or nasal cavity; when crushed, they emitted a foul odor similar to tonsil stones.
I consulted the surgeon who performed my operation, and after a nasal endoscopy, the doctor stated that tonsil stones should not occur after the removal of the palatine tonsils, and other ENT specialists have echoed this opinion.

My question is, aside from the palatine tonsils, are there other areas in the oral cavity or nasal cavity that could produce similar stones? What examinations should I undergo when seeking help from a doctor? Additionally, I have issues with post-nasal drip.
My tongue occasionally feels numb, my mouth has a bitter taste, and I experience a persistent pain from my throat to my nasal area.
Despite multiple medical consultations, the issues remain unresolved.
I would greatly appreciate your assistance.
Thank you very much.

Xunqiu Xiezhu de Zhongnianren, 50~59 year old female. Ask Date: 2019/04/27

Dr. Zheng Jueyi reply Otolaryngology


Hello, if the nasal cavity has already been examined, it is recommended to visit a dentist to check for any stones or other dental issues.
Additionally, the numbness of the tongue and the bitter taste in the mouth, along with the pain from the throat to the nose, may be related to chronic pharyngitis.
It would be advisable to consult a gastroenterologist to check for issues such as gastroesophageal reflux disease.
Wishing you peace and good health.
Sincerely, Dr.
Cheng Jue-Yi, Director of the Department of Otolaryngology, Taoyuan General Hospital, Ministry of Health and Welfare.

Reply Date: 2019/04/27

More Info


Tonsil stones, or tonsilloliths, are calcified debris that can form in the crevices of the tonsils. While tonsillectomy, the surgical removal of the tonsils, is typically effective in eliminating the formation of these stones, some patients may still experience similar issues post-surgery. This can be perplexing, especially when the original problem of halitosis (bad breath) persists despite the removal of the tonsils.

Firstly, it’s important to understand that tonsil stones are primarily composed of bacteria, dead cells, food particles, and mucus that can accumulate in the tonsillar crypts. After a tonsillectomy, the tonsils are removed, but the throat still contains other structures that can harbor similar debris. For instance, the lingual tonsils, located at the base of the tongue, can also trap food particles and bacteria, potentially leading to the formation of stones or similar calcified debris. Additionally, the oropharynx and nasopharynx can also be sites where debris accumulates, especially if there are anatomical variations or chronic inflammation.

Regarding your specific symptoms, the presence of foul-smelling white material that resembles tonsil stones could indicate that you are experiencing a similar process in another area of your throat or nasal cavity. The fact that you have post-nasal drip (nasal mucus flowing down the back of the throat) can contribute to this issue, as it may lead to the accumulation of mucus and debris in the throat, which can become foul-smelling.

To address your concerns, it would be prudent to undergo a thorough evaluation by an Ear, Nose, and Throat (ENT) specialist. Here are some recommended steps and examinations you might consider:
1. Nasal Endoscopy: This procedure allows the doctor to visualize the nasal passages and sinuses directly. It can help identify any obstructions, chronic sinusitis, or other issues that might be contributing to your symptoms.

2. Throat Examination: A detailed examination of the oropharynx and larynx can help identify any residual tonsillar tissue or other anatomical issues that may be contributing to your symptoms.

3. Imaging Studies: A CT scan of the sinuses may be useful to evaluate for chronic sinusitis or other structural abnormalities that could be contributing to your symptoms.

4. Allergy Testing: If you have chronic post-nasal drip, it may be beneficial to evaluate for allergies that could be causing increased mucus production.

5. Salivary Gland Evaluation: Sometimes, issues with the salivary glands can lead to similar symptoms. A sialogram or ultrasound may be warranted if there are concerns about salivary stones or duct obstruction.

6. Oral Hygiene Assessment: Maintaining good oral hygiene is crucial. Regular dental check-ups and possibly consulting with a dental hygienist for professional cleanings can help reduce the bacterial load in your mouth.

7. Management of Post-Nasal Drip: Treatment options may include nasal saline irrigation, antihistamines, or nasal corticosteroids to reduce inflammation and mucus production.

In conclusion, while tonsillectomy typically resolves the issue of tonsil stones, other anatomical structures in the throat and nasal cavity can still harbor similar debris. A comprehensive evaluation by an ENT specialist is essential to identify the underlying cause of your symptoms and to develop an appropriate treatment plan. Your ongoing symptoms of throat pain, altered taste sensation, and nasal issues warrant further investigation to ensure that you receive the most effective care.

Similar Q&A

Should You Consider Tonsillectomy for Frequent Tonsil Stones?

Hello, doctor. I would like to inquire about my condition. I experience tonsil stones approximately every four days. Would you recommend a tonsillectomy in this case? Are there any techniques available to reduce postoperative pain? What potential complications or side effects sho...


Dr. Zheng Jueyi reply Otolaryngology
Hello, if you have persistent tonsil stones along with chronic tonsillitis, it is indeed worth considering a tonsillectomy. Currently, there are cold plasma ablation devices (coblation) and other surgical instruments that can reduce postoperative pain. Generally, there are no sig...

[Read More] Should You Consider Tonsillectomy for Frequent Tonsil Stones?


Understanding Tonsillectomy: What to Expect and Common Concerns

Hello Doctor, I visited the clinic today and the doctor recommended that I have my tonsils removed, which I agreed to. However, I forgot to ask the following questions, and I would appreciate your answers. My condition involves recurrent tonsillitis and frequent tonsil stones. ...


Dr. Li Jiaxuan reply Otolaryngology
1. The majority of the palatine tonsils will be excised. 2. Postoperatively, there will be significant pain. For 1-2 weeks, a softer diet is recommended. Initially, due to the repositioning of the uvula and surrounding mucosa (the M-shaped area at the back of the mouth), eating m...

[Read More] Understanding Tonsillectomy: What to Expect and Common Concerns


Understanding Tonsil Stones: Pain Management and Prevention Tips

It is normal to still experience pain after having a stone removed, even if it is less severe, as the body may still be healing from the procedure. Pain radiating to the left ear can occur due to nerve pathways. Regarding the recurrence of stones, they can indeed be prone to re...


Dr. Zheng Jueyi reply Otolaryngology
Hello, the stones may cause chronic inflammation and pain in the tonsil on that side. There are many reasons for the formation of stones, which may be related to individual constitution, oral hygiene, and dietary habits. This area is difficult to reach while brushing teeth, so it...

[Read More] Understanding Tonsil Stones: Pain Management and Prevention Tips


Clarification Needed on Tonsil Stones Inquiry from 9/22

Hello Dr. Cheng: I asked a question on 9/22 regarding tonsil stones, reference number <a href="https://adoctor.tw/article/112091">#112091</a>. I only directed my question to Dr. Cheng and have not asked other physicians. I find Dr. Cheng's response some...


Dr. Zheng Jueyi reply Otolaryngology
Hello: There are many causes of halitosis, and tonsil stones are one of the factors. If the primary cause is due to tonsil stones, surgical intervention can lead to significant improvement, but it cannot be guaranteed that surgery will completely resolve the halitosis. If you hav...

[Read More] Clarification Needed on Tonsil Stones Inquiry from 9/22


Related FAQ

Tonsil Stones

(Otolaryngology)

Post-Tonsillectomy

(Otolaryngology)

Tonsillitis

(Otolaryngology)

Post-Septoplasty

(Otolaryngology)

Lymphadenitis

(Otolaryngology)

Ankyloglossia

(Otolaryngology)

Tonsils

(Internal Medicine)

Post-Anal Surgery

(Surgery)

Laser Surgery

(Otolaryngology)

Cholesteatoma

(Otolaryngology)