Blood sugar issues?
Hello Doctor: I have a follow-up question regarding TABATA.
My main concern is whether exercise needs to last at least 15 or 30 minutes to effectively control blood sugar levels.
Since TABATA workouts only take 4 to 8 minutes to complete (and are said to replace a typical 30-minute workout), I wonder if they are effective for blood sugar control.
Otherwise, if I do them every day, it feels like I'm not making any progress.
Most online information promotes the idea of exercising for 30 minutes, which raises my questions about timing.
Lin Sen, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2019/06/04
Dr. Xiao Yongxun reply Family Medicine
Dear Mr.
Lin Sen:
1.
According to the "Evidence-Based Guidelines for the Prevention and Management of Adult Obesity" published by Taiwan's Ministry of Health and Welfare in November 2018, high-intensity interval training (HIIT) is defined as aerobic exercise performed at an intensity of 80-100% of maximum heart rate for durations ranging from 1 to 4 minutes.
When compared to moderate-intensity continuous training, which is the previously recommended exercise model, the results indicate that short-term HIIT (less than 12 weeks) can improve maximal oxygen uptake, diastolic blood pressure, and fasting blood glucose levels in overweight or obese individuals.
Long-term HIIT (at least 12 weeks, three times a week) can improve waist circumference, body fat percentage, resting heart rate, systolic blood pressure, and diastolic blood pressure in overweight or obese individuals.
However, the fat loss effects of short-term HIIT are not superior to those of moderate-intensity aerobic exercise.
Nevertheless, from a time perspective, HIIT may require nearly 40% less time than moderate-intensity aerobic exercise, making it a more efficient weight loss method.
2.
Therefore, short-term HIIT is beneficial for controlling fasting blood glucose levels.
3.
However, I still recommend dietary adjustments and exercise management as a better approach for the general population.
Please be sure to discuss this in detail with your family physician.
Reply Date: 2019/06/04
More Info
The question of whether short, high-intensity exercises like Tabata can effectively control blood sugar levels is an important one, especially for individuals at risk of developing diabetes. Tabata training, a form of high-intensity interval training (HIIT), typically consists of 20 seconds of maximum effort followed by 10 seconds of rest, repeated for a total of 4 minutes. This method has gained popularity due to its efficiency in delivering significant fitness benefits in a short amount of time.
Research indicates that high-intensity interval training can indeed have positive effects on blood sugar control. Studies have shown that short bursts of intense exercise can improve insulin sensitivity and help lower blood glucose levels. For individuals with prediabetes or those at risk of developing type 2 diabetes, incorporating HIIT into their exercise routine may be beneficial. In fact, some studies suggest that HIIT can lead to improvements in fasting blood glucose levels and overall metabolic health, even when the duration of exercise is significantly shorter than traditional moderate-intensity workouts.
However, it is essential to consider the context of your overall health and fitness level. While Tabata workouts can be effective, they may not be suitable for everyone, especially those who are new to exercise or have certain health conditions. For individuals with prediabetes, it is often recommended to start with moderate-intensity activities such as walking, swimming, or cycling, gradually increasing intensity as fitness improves. This approach helps to minimize the risk of injury and ensures that the body can adapt to the demands of more intense workouts.
Regarding the duration of exercise, traditional guidelines have often emphasized the importance of at least 30 minutes of moderate-intensity exercise for optimal health benefits, including blood sugar control. The rationale behind this recommendation is that sustained physical activity helps to mobilize glucose from the bloodstream and improve insulin sensitivity over time. However, recent findings suggest that even shorter, high-intensity workouts can provide significant benefits, particularly when performed consistently.
It is also worth noting that the effectiveness of any exercise regimen in controlling blood sugar levels is influenced by various factors, including diet, overall lifestyle, and individual metabolic responses. For instance, while exercise contributes to about 20-30% of blood sugar control, dietary choices play a crucial role, accounting for approximately 40-50%. Therefore, a comprehensive approach that includes both regular physical activity and healthy eating is essential for managing blood sugar levels effectively.
In conclusion, while traditional exercise recommendations emphasize longer durations, short, intense workouts like Tabata can also be effective in controlling blood sugar levels, particularly when combined with a balanced diet and other healthy lifestyle choices. If you are considering incorporating Tabata into your routine, it may be beneficial to consult with a healthcare provider or a fitness professional to ensure it aligns with your health goals and fitness level. Regular monitoring of your blood sugar levels can also help you assess the effectiveness of your exercise regimen and make necessary adjustments.
Similar Q&A
Can Tabata Workouts Effectively Lower Blood Sugar Levels?
Hello Doctor: I am in the prediabetic stage, with blood sugar levels around 110, and I have not yet reached diabetes. Therefore, I want to establish a regular exercise routine to prevent the onset of diabetes. I have a question regarding the recent popularity of TABATA, a form of...
Dr. Liao Yaopan reply Family Medicine
Hello, different types of exercise have their own training components and varying intensities, which naturally lead to different fitness outcomes. It is advisable to incorporate various forms of exercise, including aerobic, cardiovascular, and strength training, based on appropri...[Read More] Can Tabata Workouts Effectively Lower Blood Sugar Levels?
Is Tabata Effective for Blood Sugar Control in Prediabetes?
Hello, doctor. I have prediabetes, with blood sugar levels around 110. I want to exercise regularly, and I've recently heard a lot about Tabata interval training, which claims that just 4 to 8 minutes of exercise can be equivalent to 30 minutes of other types of workouts. Ho...
Dr. Lin Jianliang reply Internal Medicine
There are currently limited studies on the effects of high-intensity interval training (HIIT) on blood glucose levels, but the results seem to indicate a generally positive impact. However, it is important to conduct a risk assessment before engaging in this type of exercise.[Read More] Is Tabata Effective for Blood Sugar Control in Prediabetes?
Can Tabata Workouts Effectively Lower Blood Sugar Levels?
Hello Doctor: I am in the prediabetic stage, with blood glucose levels around 110, and I have not yet developed diabetes. Therefore, I want to establish a regular exercise routine to prevent the onset of diabetes. I have a question regarding the recently popular TABATA interval t...
Dr. Xiao Yongxun reply Family Medicine
Dear Mr. Lin Sen: 1. TABATA is primarily a form of high-intensity interval training (HIIT); it involves performing maximum intensity exercise for 20 seconds, followed by a 10-second rest, repeated for a total of 8 rounds, resulting in an overall duration of about 4 minutes. It c...[Read More] Can Tabata Workouts Effectively Lower Blood Sugar Levels?
Understanding the Impact of Short vs. Long-Term High-Intensity Interval Training
Hello Doctor: I would like to ask a follow-up question regarding TABATA. I understand that short-term high-intensity interval training (less than 12 weeks) can improve maximum oxygen uptake, diastolic blood pressure, and fasting blood glucose levels in overweight or obese individ...
Dr. Xiao Yongxun reply Family Medicine
1. The "Evidence-Based Guidelines for the Prevention and Management of Adult Obesity," published by Taiwan's Ministry of Health and Welfare in November 2018, is a consensus reached through discussions among experts and scholars who reviewed global studies and repor...[Read More] Understanding the Impact of Short vs. Long-Term High-Intensity Interval Training
Related FAQ
(Family Medicine)
Diabetes Diet(Nutrition)
Diabetes(Internal Medicine)
Weight Loss(Family Medicine)
Hyperlipidemia(Family Medicine)
Health Supplements(Family Medicine)
Blood Test Report(Family Medicine)
Gout(Family Medicine)
Ankle(Family Medicine)
Diabetes(Surgery)