Gallbladder Stones: To Operate or Not? Key Considerations and Timing - Internal Medicine

Share to:

Gallstones—Surgery or Not?


The patient has a 10-year history of gallbladder stones and has experienced occasional right upper abdominal pain after meals for the past 2 years.
There was one episode of fever and vomiting during an attack 2 weeks ago, which spontaneously subsided after supportive treatment at the hospital.
The patient has no history of diabetes, hypertension, or previous surgeries.
A recent ultrasound revealed several small stones in the gallbladder.
Is surgery necessary? When is the appropriate time for surgery? Can you recommend a good surgeon at your hospital? Thank you.

FRED, 60~69 year old female. Ask Date: 2002/11/25

Dr. Xiao Yongxun reply Internal Medicine


Dear FRED:
1.
The management of asymptomatic gallstones remains controversial.
The risk of developing symptoms or complications that require surgery is quite low, around 1 to 2 percent per year, in most asymptomatic gallstone patients.
2.
Recommendations for prophylactic cholecystectomy in gallstone patients are likely based on the assessment of several factors as follows: (1) the presence of symptoms that are frequent or severe enough to interfere with the patient’s daily routine; (2) a history of prior complications related to gallstone disease, such as acute cholecystitis, pancreatitis, or gallstone fistula; (3) the presence of an underlying condition that predisposes the patient to an increased risk of gallstone complications (e.g., calcified or porcelain gallbladder, cholesterolosis, adenomyomatosis, and/or a previous episode of acute cholecystitis regardless of current symptomatic status); (4) patients with very large gallstones (over 2 cm in diameter) and those with gallstones in a congenitally anomalous gallbladder may also be considered for prophylactic cholecystectomy; (5) although being under 50 years of age is a concerning factor in asymptomatic gallstone patients, few experts would currently recommend routine cholecystectomy for all young patients with silent stones.
3.
Additionally, both open cholecystectomy and laparoscopic cholecystectomy are viable surgical options for gallstone patients.
The choice of procedure depends on various considerations.
4.
At our hospital, (1) Dr.
Wei-Ping Wu is an excellent physician who will provide you with valuable advice regarding gallstone disease.
(2) Dr.
Ze-Cheng Wu is an expert surgeon capable of performing either open cholecystectomy or laparoscopic cholecystectomy based on the patient's condition.
5.
In conclusion, it is advisable to discuss the dilemma in detail with your doctors and ultimately make an informed decision.
Shiau, Yeong-shiun MD, MPH

Reply Date: 2002/11/25

More Info


When considering whether to operate on gallbladder stones (cholelithiasis), several factors must be taken into account, particularly in the context of your medical history and current symptoms. Based on the information provided, you have a history of gallstones for 10 years, with occasional right upper abdominal pain after meals for the past two years. You also experienced one episode of fever and vomiting two weeks ago, which resolved with supportive treatment. Importantly, you have no significant comorbidities such as diabetes or hypertension, and recent imaging has shown several small stones in your gallbladder.


Key Considerations for Surgery
1. Symptomatology: The presence of symptoms is a critical factor in deciding whether to proceed with surgery. In your case, the occasional abdominal pain after meals suggests that your gallstones may be causing some degree of discomfort. The recent episode of fever and vomiting raises concern for a potential complication, such as acute cholecystitis or pancreatitis, which could necessitate surgical intervention.
2. Risk of Complications: The risk of developing complications from gallstones, such as acute cholecystitis, pancreatitis, or choledocholithiasis (stones in the bile duct), increases with time and the presence of symptoms. While the annual risk of complications in asymptomatic patients is relatively low (around 1-2%), your history of symptoms may warrant a more proactive approach.

3. Timing of Surgery: The appropriate timing for surgery often depends on the severity and frequency of symptoms. If you are experiencing recurrent symptoms that interfere with your daily life or if there is a risk of complications, it may be advisable to consider laparoscopic cholecystectomy sooner rather than later. Conversely, if your symptoms are infrequent and manageable, a watchful waiting approach may be appropriate, but this should be closely monitored.

4. Surgical Options: Laparoscopic cholecystectomy is generally the preferred method due to its minimally invasive nature and quicker recovery time compared to open cholecystectomy. The choice of procedure should be discussed with a qualified surgeon who can evaluate your specific situation and recommend the best approach.


Recommendations
- Consultation with a Surgeon: It is crucial to have a detailed discussion with a surgeon who specializes in gallbladder surgery. Based on your history and current symptoms, they can provide tailored advice on whether surgery is necessary and the timing of the procedure. In your hospital, Dr. 吳維平 and Dr. 吳澤誠 are recommended for their expertise in managing gallbladder diseases.

- Monitoring Symptoms: Keep a record of your symptoms, noting their frequency and severity. If you experience any new or worsening symptoms, such as increased abdominal pain, jaundice, or persistent vomiting, seek medical attention promptly.

- Lifestyle Considerations: While awaiting further evaluation, consider dietary modifications to reduce the risk of gallbladder attacks. A low-fat diet may help minimize symptoms, as high-fat meals can trigger gallbladder contractions and pain.


Conclusion
In summary, the decision to operate on gallbladder stones should be based on a careful assessment of your symptoms, the risk of complications, and a thorough discussion with a qualified surgeon. Given your history of gallstones and recent symptoms, it may be prudent to consider surgical intervention sooner rather than later, especially to prevent potential complications. Always prioritize open communication with your healthcare providers to ensure the best possible outcome for your health.

Similar Q&A

Gallbladder Removal: When Is Surgery Necessary for Gallstones?

Hello, doctor. I have gastroesophageal reflux disease, and recently I've experienced right upper abdominal pain twice within a week. The emergency department diagnosed me with gallstones leading to cholecystitis, but my blood tests are normal. I would like to know your opini...


Dr. Hu Guozheng reply Gastroenterology and Hepatology
The primary treatment for symptomatic gallstones is cholecystectomy. If a physician assesses that a patient is not suitable for surgery, extracorporeal shock wave lithotripsy combined with medication can be considered. Additionally, lifestyle and dietary modifications are necessa...

[Read More] Gallbladder Removal: When Is Surgery Necessary for Gallstones?


Understanding Gallstones: Symptoms, Risks, and Surgical Options

I discovered this two years after giving birth. At that time, I was experiencing unexplained back pain, which led to further examinations. A CT scan revealed that I had two types of stones, and my gallbladder wall was somewhat thick (I don't know how thick). The surgeon reco...


Dr. Chen Jianhong reply Gastroenterology and Hepatology
Hello! The symptoms mentioned in the letter are quite vague, so it is advisable to promptly visit a hepatobiliary specialist for a detailed examination. If it is indeed necessary to remove the gallbladder due to gallstones, it will not affect digestive function. Menstruation shou...

[Read More] Understanding Gallstones: Symptoms, Risks, and Surgical Options


Should Surgery Be Considered for Gallbladder Atrophy?

Hello Dr. Chen: My father previously experienced severe pain in the upper abdomen and first went to Hospital A for an ultrasound, which revealed a thickened gallbladder. The physician at Hospital A recommended surgery. He then went to Hospital B for further evaluation, where it w...


Dr. Chen Qifeng reply Gastroenterology and Hepatology
Hello, the prerequisite for an ultrasound examination of the gallbladder is fasting for at least 6-8 hours. If the examination reveals thickening of the gallbladder wall or atrophy while fasting, it often suggests the presence of gallstones along with chronic cholecystitis. In th...

[Read More] Should Surgery Be Considered for Gallbladder Atrophy?


Understanding Gallstone Risks: Movement and Growth Without Surgery

Thank you, Dr. Chen, for your response. I would like to ask the doctor again, if surgery is not performed, will there always be a risk of 1) gallstones falling into the bile duct? 2) stones in the gallbladder increasing in size over time? Thank you. -----------------------------...


Dr. Chen Shidian reply Gastroenterology and Hepatology
Hello Mr. A-Jie, 1. Currently, there is no definitive research confirming the likelihood. Generally speaking, the probability is not high. 2. Gallstones can increase in size over time, but the likelihood of developing cholecystitis is not necessarily correlated with the size o...

[Read More] Understanding Gallstone Risks: Movement and Growth Without Surgery


Related FAQ

Gallstones

(Surgery)

Gallbladder

(Surgery)

Gallstones

(Gastroenterology and Hepatology)

Gallbladder Removal Surgery Consultation

(Surgery)

Abdomen

(Internal Medicine)

Gallbladder Polyps

(Gastroenterology and Hepatology)

Pancreatitis

(Internal Medicine)

Stones

(Urology)

Gerd

(Internal Medicine)

Gastrointestinal Pain

(Surgery)