Conservative Treatment for Elderly Patients with Shoulder Fractures - Orthopedics

Share to:

Seventy-year-old woman with a right clavicular fracture and a right scapular fracture?


On December 23, 2019, I fell from the third floor to the second floor, resulting in a right clavicular fracture and a right scapular fracture.
It has been 40 days since the injury.
Due to my age of 70 and having hypertension, diabetes, and a history of heart disease (old AMI), I am concerned about the need for a second surgery to remove the plates after the initial surgery.
Therefore, I am only using conservative treatment with a shoulder and elbow sling, without using a figure-eight bandage.
The angle of the fracture is too severe, and the doctor has determined that it cannot heal properly on its own.

I would like to ask:
1) If I do not undergo surgery, how much will the function of my right shoulder deteriorate in the future?
2) When can I start rehabilitation?
3) If I wait 60 days to have surgery, will the outcome be significantly worse?
4) If surgery is necessary, are there any self-funded options for plates that do not require removal?
Thank you for your professional explanation and advice.

Hailun, 70~79 year old female. Ask Date: 2020/02/04

Dr. Zhan Xian reply Orthopedics


Hello, an X-ray is needed to assess the location and degree of displacement of the fracture.
The timing for rehabilitation also requires evaluation through physical examination and imaging studies.
Only a small portion of the plate needs to be removed (whether covered by insurance or out-of-pocket).
The self-funded interlocking plate provides better fixation.
Please consult the orthopedic outpatient department!

Reply Date: 2020/02/04

More Info


When dealing with shoulder fractures in elderly patients, particularly those with additional health complications such as hypertension, diabetes, and a history of heart disease, conservative treatment is often the preferred approach. In your case, the patient has sustained a complex injury involving both the clavicle and scapula, and the decision to avoid surgery is understandable given the risks associated with anesthesia and surgical intervention in older adults.

1. Future Shoulder Function Without Surgery: If the decision is made to continue with conservative treatment, the prognosis for shoulder function largely depends on the nature of the fractures and the patient’s overall health. Given that the fracture has a significant angulation, there is a possibility that the bones may not heal in the correct alignment, leading to a condition known as malunion. This can result in chronic pain, limited range of motion, and functional impairment of the shoulder. The patient may experience difficulties with daily activities, such as reaching overhead or lifting objects, which can significantly impact their quality of life.

2. Timing for Rehabilitation: Rehabilitation should ideally begin as soon as the acute pain subsides and the patient is cleared by their physician. In many cases, gentle range-of-motion exercises can be initiated even while the patient is in a sling, as long as they do not exacerbate pain or cause further injury. Typically, physical therapy can start around 4 to 6 weeks post-injury, but this can vary based on the individual’s healing process and the physician’s recommendations. It is crucial to monitor the patient’s pain levels and functional abilities throughout this process.

3. Surgical Intervention After 60 Days: If surgery is considered after a delay of 60 days, the healing process may be more complicated. Delayed surgery can lead to the development of scar tissue and stiffness in the shoulder joint, which can hinder recovery. The outcomes may not be as favorable as if surgery had been performed earlier, especially if the bones have not healed properly. However, surgical options such as internal fixation can still be beneficial in restoring function, but the rehabilitation process may take longer and require more intensive therapy.

4. Non-removable Plates: There are surgical options that utilize plates and screws that do not require removal after healing. These are often made from materials that can remain in the body without causing issues. However, the decision to use such implants should be made in consultation with an orthopedic surgeon, who can provide insights based on the specific fracture type and the patient’s overall health.

In conclusion, while conservative treatment can be effective, it is essential to closely monitor the patient’s progress and be vigilant for any signs of complications. Regular follow-ups with the orthopedic specialist are crucial to assess healing and determine the appropriate time to initiate rehabilitation. If surgery becomes necessary, discussing the options for fixation devices that do not require removal can help alleviate some concerns about future procedures. Ultimately, the goal is to restore as much function as possible while considering the patient’s overall health and quality of life.

Similar Q&A

Managing Pain in Elderly Patients with Shoulder Fractures: Expert Advice

Hello Doctor, I would like to consult about an 84-year-old patient who suffered a comminuted shoulder fracture due to a fall. Currently, the patient is only using a sling for immobilization, but they are experiencing significant pain. The physician has only prescribed painkillers...


Dr. Wang Shouji reply Orthopedics
Hello: A comminuted fracture of the shoulder can be challenging to manage if the body cannot tolerate the risks of anesthesia. Loose fixation may lead to discomfort and stiffness in the limb. If the cardiopulmonary function is adequate and can withstand anesthesia, surgical fixat...

[Read More] Managing Pain in Elderly Patients with Shoulder Fractures: Expert Advice


Understanding Humeral Shaft Fractures in Elderly Patients: Care and Recovery

Hello Doctor: My grandmother (85 years old) fell and fractured the middle of her left humerus when she was admitted to the hospital. The doctor advised against surgery due to her age and poor recovery ability. She has been cared for for over a year, and a recent X-ray shows some ...


Dr. You Dianqi reply Orthopedics
Hello, the phenomenon you mentioned in medicine is called pseudoarthrosis. If there has been incomplete healing at the fracture site, this is a possibility. As for your grandmother, I would need to review some of her basic imaging before I can provide you with sound advice regard...

[Read More] Understanding Humeral Shaft Fractures in Elderly Patients: Care and Recovery


Managing Elderly Spine Fractures: Care Options and Rehabilitation Insights

Hello, Doctor: I would like to ask you about the issue of fractures in the elderly. My grandfather fell two days ago and injured his spine, resulting in a vertebral fracture near the coccyx. He is currently 80 years old, undergoing dialysis, and has diabetes. After evaluation, th...


Dr. Chen Yongxue reply Orthopedics
If it is a fracture of the coccyx, surgery is generally not necessary, as there are no important nerves in that area and no issues with nerve compression. Conservative treatment is sufficient, typically involving oral or topical analgesics. Once the internal bleeding subsides (ap...

[Read More] Managing Elderly Spine Fractures: Care Options and Rehabilitation Insights


Rehabilitation Challenges for Elderly Patients After Fractures at Age 80

1. For an elderly person (80 years old) who fractured a bone and is still experiencing pain in the muscles to the point of being unable to sleep, it is advisable to consult an orthopedic specialist. Since the individual is still unable to stand, a physical medicine and rehabilita...


Dr. Yang Zhengfan reply Orthopedics
Please visit the orthopedic outpatient clinic. Thank you!

[Read More] Rehabilitation Challenges for Elderly Patients After Fractures at Age 80


Related FAQ

Shoulder

(Orthopedics)

Clavicle Fracture

(Orthopedics)

Scapular Fracture

(Orthopedics)

Fracture Healing

(Orthopedics)

Shoulder

(Family Medicine)

Post-Fracture Rehabilitation

(Orthopedics)

Humeral Fracture

(Rehabilitation)

Closed Fracture

(Orthopedics)

Distal Humeral Fracture

(Orthopedics)

Clavicle

(Rehabilitation)