the Safety and Alternatives of Silver Amalgam Fillings - Dentistry

Share to:

Silver amalgam dental filling


Dear Dr.
Tseng,
I would like to ask you some questions regarding "silver amalgam fillings":
1.
Some medical information and dentists indicate that the composition of silver amalgam is mercury alloy (amalgam), which can release mercury vapor (or metal toxins) that may affect human health.
Some European countries have even completely banned the use of silver amalgam as a filling material.
Additionally, there are some dental clinics in our country offering so-called "mercury removal" treatments, which involve excavating the patient's previous silver amalgam fillings and replacing them with other materials (such as composite resin).
I would like to know your opinion on the safety of "silver amalgam fillings." Is the information mentioned above correct or misleading?
2.
Furthermore, I have previously had "silver amalgam fillings," totaling eight, all located in the posterior molar region.
Should I have these silver amalgam fillings removed and replaced with other filling materials (such as composite resin)? If I do not have them removed, will the silver amalgam in my mouth have any impact on my health?
3.
Based on your practical treatment experience, what is the current proportion of "silver amalgam fillings" used in our country? Is "silver amalgam" still one of the main materials used for dental fillings in our country?
Thank you, Dr.
Tseng.

Axiang, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2020/04/24

Dr. Zeng Guanghui reply Dentistry


Hello, Ah-Hsiang:
1.
Silver amalgam does release trace amounts of mercury vapor during the initial setting phase, but once the amalgam is fully hardened, it no longer releases mercury.
The potential adverse effects of these trace mercury vapors are still debated, with differing opinions on the matter.
2.
The hardness of silver amalgam is still superior to that of composite resin; however, over time, there may be concerns regarding metal corrosion, which could lead to cracks in the restoration.
If corrosion or cracks are observed, it is advisable to excavate and refill the cavity.
3.
Silver amalgam has both advantages and disadvantages.
Its higher hardness makes it suitable for larger cavities, but it is less aesthetically pleasing and can corrode over time.
Even though composite resins are now widely used, silver amalgam still has its place in dental applications.
Dr.
Tseng Guang-Hui, Nantou Hospital

Reply Date: 2020/04/24

More Info


The topic of silver amalgam fillings, commonly referred to as "silver powder" in some regions, raises important questions regarding safety and health implications. Silver amalgam is a dental material composed primarily of mercury, silver, tin, and copper. While it has been used for over 150 years due to its durability and cost-effectiveness, concerns about mercury exposure have led to debates about its safety.

1. Safety of Silver Amalgam Fillings: The primary concern regarding silver amalgam is the mercury content. Mercury is known to be toxic, and there are fears that it can release mercury vapor, especially when fillings are placed or removed. However, numerous studies, including those conducted by the American Dental Association (ADA) and the World Health Organization (WHO), have concluded that the levels of mercury released from amalgam fillings are generally low and not considered harmful to the majority of the population. The ADA states that amalgam is a safe and effective material for dental restorations. However, some European countries have moved towards banning or restricting the use of amalgam due to precautionary principles, particularly for vulnerable populations such as children and pregnant women.

2. Alternatives to Silver Amalgam: There are several alternatives to silver amalgam fillings, including composite resins, glass ionomer cements, and resin ionomer materials. These materials are often preferred for aesthetic reasons, as they can be matched to the color of natural teeth. However, they may not be as durable as amalgam, especially in areas subject to heavy chewing forces. The choice of material often depends on the location of the cavity, the patient's dental and medical history, and personal preferences.

3. Need for Removal of Existing Silver Amalgam Fillings: If you have existing silver amalgam fillings and are concerned about their safety, it is essential to consult with a qualified dentist. In general, if the fillings are intact and not causing any issues, there may be no need to remove them. The process of removing amalgam can release more mercury vapor than leaving them in place, which could pose a risk if not done correctly. If you are experiencing problems with your fillings, such as decay or discomfort, your dentist can evaluate whether replacement with a different material is necessary.

4. Current Use of Silver Amalgam in Dentistry: While the use of silver amalgam has declined in some areas due to aesthetic preferences and health concerns, it remains a commonly used material in many dental practices, particularly for posterior teeth where strength is crucial. The exact percentage of amalgam use can vary by region and practice, but it is still considered a viable option for many patients.

In conclusion, while silver amalgam fillings do contain mercury, the consensus among dental professionals is that they are safe for most individuals when used appropriately. If you have concerns about your fillings, it is best to discuss them with your dentist, who can provide personalized advice based on your dental health and preferences. Regular dental check-ups are essential to monitor the condition of your fillings and overall oral health.

Similar Q&A

Concerns About Silver Fillings: Risks and Alternatives for Dental Care

Hello, doctor! I have three teeth filled with silver amalgam, but I have a problem where they tend to fall out or sink (especially the molars) approximately every two years, possibly due to long-term wear from chewing. I have some concerns: 1. I found information online stating...


Dr. Zeng Guanghui reply Dentistry
1. There is no scientific evidence indicating that the vapor produced during the removal of silver amalgam has any impact on human health, as long as the medical facility has proper ventilation and the removal process is handled carefully, it will not harm the healthy tooth struc...

[Read More] Concerns About Silver Fillings: Risks and Alternatives for Dental Care


Is Silver Filling Safe? Debunking Myths About Dental Mercury

Hello, doctor: I heard that silver fillings contain heavy metals and mercury, and it is best to remove them and replace them with composite resin to avoid poisoning or dementia. Is this statement correct?


Dr. Huang Zhicheng reply Dentistry
Dear Uof: Hello, silver amalgam is a relatively stable dental filling material, and some negative reports are based on individual cases or coincidences. However, due to its mercury content, dentists now avoid using it out of caution. If it needs to be removed and replaced, it sho...

[Read More] Is Silver Filling Safe? Debunking Myths About Dental Mercury


Alternative Solutions for Covering Silver Fillings in Molars

Doctor: May I ask, in the past, silver amalgam was used to fill molars, but now I find the appearance too noticeable. Are there other options available for covering it? Thank you!


Dr. Qiu Qiongyao reply Dentistry
Hello David: The silver filling can be removed and replaced with a resin filling. If the silver filling is too large, it is recommended to protect it with a crown. It is advisable to visit a qualified dental facility for a more accurate assessment.

[Read More] Alternative Solutions for Covering Silver Fillings in Molars


Understanding Dental Fillings: Risks, Materials, and Best Practices

(1) Is it really dangerous to use silver powder for dental fillings? (2) The resin filling I had before fell out, and some of the resin remains, but there is secondary decay inside. Is this due to the material or the technique? Would going to a larger hospital provide more assura...


Dr. Lin Qingye reply Dentistry
Hello Miss Chen, (1) The materials used for dental treatments must be non-toxic and harmless as a primary requirement. The use of "silver powder" for dental fillings has been established in dental practice for many years, and its safety and stability are well recognize...

[Read More] Understanding Dental Fillings: Risks, Materials, and Best Practices


Related FAQ

Silver Filling

(Dentistry)

Dental Filling

(Dentistry)

Bruxism

(Dentistry)

Toothpaste

(Dentistry)

Gum

(Dentistry)

Retainer

(Dentistry)

Halitosis

(Dentistry)

Enamel

(Dentistry)

Lost Filling

(Dentistry)

Occlusal Splint

(Dentistry)