Assessing COVID-19 Exposure Risks in Brief Interactions: A Pharmacist's Concern

Infectious potential, may I ask?

Hello, Doctor Hong.
I am a pharmacist.
Today, after driving my girlfriend to dinner, I went back to the hospital to help my grandmother pick up her medication.
I had it packaged and asked a colleague to leave it on the first floor for me to pick up.
I planned to leave quickly since I thought it would only take a few minutes.
I rolled down the passenger window and told the parking attendant that I would just be a moment to grab something.
However, when I returned, my girlfriend scolded me because she didn’t bring a mask, and neither did the parking attendant.
She asked why I didn’t remind him.
I told her it should be fine since our hospital doesn’t have negative pressure isolation and doesn’t admit COVID-19 patients.
Besides, it was only a brief conversation of less than a minute.
She pointed out that as a healthcare professional, I should be more cautious.

I would like to ask the doctor if I was indeed too careless and if I put my girlfriend at risk.
Although I later apologized and said that next time I would remind her to wear a mask when I roll down the window.
I’m also wondering if my girlfriend is at risk of contracting COVID-19 from this situation.
After dropping her off at home, she started checking her temperature and asked me if it was okay, wanting me to check mine as well.
She still seems upset.

I hope a doctor can explain the potential risks involved or if my understanding is truly flawed so that I can be more careful in the future.
I apologize for disturbing you during your holiday.
Thank you!

Mr. Chen, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2020/05/23

Dr. Hong Yuanbin reply Internal Medicine

Hello, there is currently no clear evidence regarding how long conversations need to last for transmission to occur.
According to the recommendations from Taiwan's Centers for Disease Control, social distancing should be maintained at least one meter apart, and wearing masks is advised.
Additionally, the current situation in Taiwan shows no community transmission, which means the risk of infection is relatively low.
In summary, neither you nor your girlfriend is likely to contract COVID-19 from this interaction.
However, her anger may stem from concern for your well-being.
Thank you for your question.

Reply Date: 2020/05/23

More Info

In assessing the risks of COVID-19 exposure during brief interactions, it's important to consider several factors, including the duration of contact, the environment, and the protective measures in place. Your situation, where you briefly interacted with a parking attendant while your girlfriend was in the car without a mask, raises valid concerns, especially given the ongoing pandemic.

Firstly, the risk of transmission of COVID-19 is significantly influenced by the duration of exposure. Short interactions, particularly those lasting less than a few minutes, are generally considered to pose a lower risk of transmission compared to prolonged contact. However, even brief encounters can carry some risk, especially if either party is asymptomatic or has not been vaccinated.

The environment also plays a crucial role. Outdoor settings, like the one you described, typically present a lower risk of transmission compared to enclosed spaces. The airflow outdoors helps disperse viral particles, reducing the likelihood of inhalation. However, if the parking attendant was in close proximity to your vehicle and speaking directly to you, there is still a potential risk, albeit lower than in an indoor setting.

Regarding the use of masks, they are a critical tool in reducing the transmission of respiratory viruses, including COVID-19. Your girlfriend's lack of a mask, combined with the parking attendant's absence of one, does increase the risk of exposure, even during a brief interaction. Masks are effective in blocking respiratory droplets that may contain the virus, and their absence can lead to a higher likelihood of transmission, especially if one of the individuals is unknowingly infected.

It's understandable that your girlfriend expressed concern about the situation. Her reaction reflects a heightened awareness of the risks associated with COVID-19, which is common among individuals who are more cautious or have underlying health conditions. It's commendable that you acknowledged her feelings and apologized, as communication and understanding are key in such situations.

In terms of your girlfriend's risk of contracting COVID-19 from this brief interaction, it is relatively low, especially if neither of you has exhibited symptoms or had known exposure to a confirmed case. However, it is always wise to monitor for any symptoms that may arise in the following days. If she develops any symptoms such as fever, cough, or loss of taste or smell, it would be prudent for her to get tested for COVID-19.

To mitigate future risks, consider the following precautions:
1. Always wear masks in situations where social distancing cannot be maintained, even for brief interactions.

2. Encourage others to wear masks as well, particularly in public settings.

3. Maintain physical distance whenever possible, even during short conversations.

4. Stay informed about local COVID-19 guidelines and recommendations, as these can change based on community transmission rates.

In conclusion, while the risk of COVID-19 transmission from your brief interaction was likely low, it is essential to remain vigilant and take appropriate precautions to protect yourself and those around you. Your willingness to learn from this experience and adapt your behavior is a positive step towards ensuring safety in the ongoing pandemic.

Similar Q&A

Assessing COVID-19 Exposure Risk After Close Contact with a Colleague

Hello Doctor, I was informed today that a colleague of mine has tested positive for COVID-19. I sat next to this colleague during a meeting for two hours two days ago, and we were very close to each other. Both of us were wearing masks during that time, but I am still very worrie...

Dr. Lin Zhebin reply Family Medicine
Hello: 1. Since both you and your colleague are wearing masks, the likelihood of contracting COVID-19 from your colleague is generally lower, but it cannot be said that there is no risk at all. 2. If you are concerned about contracting COVID-19, you can first check yourself using...

Am I at Risk? Expert Advice on COVID-19 Exposure Concerns

Hello, doctor. Recently, I've noticed that foreigners are very afraid of contracting COVID-19. Today, while I was on the MRT, I wasn't paying attention and suddenly someone sat down next to me. It turned out to be a blonde foreign woman. I was about a station's dis...

Dr. Hong Yuanbin reply Internal Medicine
Hello, based on your description, both parties were wearing masks, so the risk of infection should be very low. There is no need for special testing at this time unless symptoms of a cold develop later. Thank you for your inquiry.

Understanding COVID-19 Transmission Risks in Close Proximity Situations

I am concerned about the recent severe COVID-19 situation in Taipei and whether this scenario could lead to droplet transmission, especially since there are elderly individuals at home. Here’s the situation: while I was eating, a colleague who was not wearing a mask walked past m...

Dr. Lin Zhebin reply Family Medicine
Hello: Based on the situation you described, if your colleague has tested positive, there is still a possibility of transmission to you. Given the severity of the current pandemic, if you have concerns about exposure to a confirmed case or are experiencing any symptoms, it is adv...

Assessing COVID-19 Risks in Shared Spaces: Elevator Safety Concerns

Hello, today it seems that there are individuals returning from abroad who need to be quarantined in the building. I did not encounter them, but an elder in my family wanted to collect laundry and pressed the elevator button. When the door opened, they saw a lot of water on the f...

Dr. Hong Yuanbin reply Internal Medicine
Hello, based on your description, if the areas that were passed through have been disinfected and left to sit for an hour, the risk of infection should be relatively low. Currently, if patients are confirmed, they should be receiving treatment in the hospital. The situation you d...