Managing Scar Tissue After Fracture Surgery: Concerns and Solutions - Orthopedics

Share to:

Post-fracture surgical scars


Doctor, I had surgery for a fracture in my left upper arm last June, which left me with a fairly long scar.
I have a tendency to develop keloids.
The scar has turned into a keloid (or it seems to be a hypertrophic scar).
I will be returning to the hospital soon to have the internal fixation plate removed.
I would like to ask if reopening the original scar to remove the plate will cause the scar to become larger, more swollen, and more raised.
I have also been using scar gel to reduce the keloid, but the results have not been very noticeable, which is quite frustrating.
I know that steroid injections can help reduce it, but since the scar is located over a joint, is there a possibility that the keloid (or hypertrophic scar) could grow back?

Nai Mei, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2020/05/27

Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics


Could the surgeon remove the original scar during the surgery and then suture it? This way, we can see if it improves, although there is a possibility that it may return.

Reply Date: 2020/05/27

More Info


Managing scar tissue after fracture surgery, especially in the context of hypertrophic scars or keloids, can be a complex issue that requires careful consideration and management. Your concerns about the potential for your existing scar to worsen after the removal of the internal fixation plate are valid and deserve a thorough response.

Firstly, it is important to understand that scars, particularly hypertrophic scars and keloids, can behave unpredictably. Hypertrophic scars are raised scars that remain within the boundaries of the original wound, while keloids extend beyond the original injury site. Given your history of keloid formation, it is crucial to approach any surgical intervention with caution.

1. Surgical Considerations: When the surgeon removes the plate, they will likely need to make an incision along the existing scar. This can potentially lead to an increase in scar tissue formation, especially if the skin is under tension during the healing process. The risk of the scar becoming larger, more raised, or more prominent is indeed a concern, particularly in individuals with a predisposition to keloid formation. It is essential to discuss this with your surgeon, who may have strategies to minimize scar formation, such as using specific suturing techniques or tension-relieving methods.

2. Scar Management Post-Surgery: After the removal of the plate, it is advisable to continue with scar management techniques. While you mentioned using silicone gel, which is a common and effective treatment for hypertrophic scars, it may take time to see significant results. Consistent application is key, and it may be beneficial to combine this with other treatments. Options include:
- Pressure Therapy: Applying pressure garments can help flatten and soften scars over time.

- Steroid Injections: These can be effective in reducing the size and appearance of hypertrophic scars and keloids. However, as you noted, there is a possibility of recurrence, especially if the scar is located over a joint where movement can stimulate scar tissue formation.

- Laser Therapy: Certain types of laser treatments can help reduce the appearance of scars and improve skin texture.

- Microneedling: This technique can promote collagen remodeling and may help improve the appearance of scars.

3. Monitoring and Follow-Up: After the surgery, it is crucial to have regular follow-ups with your healthcare provider. They can monitor the healing process and the appearance of the scar. If you notice any changes or if the scar begins to thicken or become more prominent, it is important to address these concerns promptly.

4. Emotional and Psychological Support: Living with scars, especially those that are raised or disfiguring, can have emotional and psychological impacts. It may be beneficial to seek support from counseling or support groups for individuals dealing with similar issues.

In summary, while there is a risk that the scar may become larger or more pronounced after the removal of the internal fixation plate, careful surgical technique and proactive scar management can help mitigate this risk. Open communication with your surgeon about your concerns and preferences will be essential in developing a plan that addresses both the functional and aesthetic aspects of your recovery.

Similar Q&A

Managing Bone Thickening and Skin Issues After Tibia Fracture

I have a question about my right tibia. It was fractured in a car accident over a decade ago, and now that area of the bone has become very thick. Is there any way to restore the bone to its original thickness? Additionally, the surgical scar has become very thin and is easily in...


Dr. Zhan Xian reply Orthopedics
Hello, A-Ting. Based on your description, it is necessary to conduct relevant examinations such as physical therapy and imaging studies to rule out issues related to osteomyelitis or bone protrusions causing the wound problem. Please visit the orthopedic outpatient clinic!

[Read More] Managing Bone Thickening and Skin Issues After Tibia Fracture


Effective Scar Removal Solutions for Post-Surgery Confidence Boost

Hello Doctor: A few years ago, I had an accident that resulted in a humeral fracture, leaving me with a surgical scar of about 10 centimeters. Sometimes I feel it's very unattractive and it affects my confidence, making me hesitant to wear short sleeves. I would like to know...


Dr. Lü Mingchuan reply Plastic Surgery
Hello: It can be used for scar treatment... It is recommended to visit Changhua Hospital's plastic surgery department for management.

[Read More] Effective Scar Removal Solutions for Post-Surgery Confidence Boost


Managing Post-Accident Wounds: Treatment for Swelling, Blisters, and Scarring

Hello, doctor. In mid-July, I underwent surgery for a tibial fracture reduction and interlocking nail fixation following a car accident. During the period from the accident to the surgery, my leg swelled due to the fracture, resulting in multiple blisters in various areas. Curren...


Dr. Li Zhonghuai reply Surgery
Hello! The photos show that the wound is healing well, but you have a tendency to develop keloids. It is recommended to use scar gel promptly, wear long sleeves and long pants tightly when going out, apply sunscreen, and carry an umbrella for shade. If there is no improvement, co...

[Read More] Managing Post-Accident Wounds: Treatment for Swelling, Blisters, and Scarring


Scar Revision Surgery: Options, Procedures, and Recovery Explained

Hello, doctor. 1. I had a car accident over ten years ago that resulted in a fracture, and I have an 8 cm raised surgical scar on my thigh. Is it suitable for scar revision surgery? 2. Three years ago, I underwent laser lipolysis on my thigh at an aesthetic clinic. The doctor ...


Dr. Lu Daokuan reply Plastic Surgery
Since previous injuries have a tendency to form raised scars and the results of scar revision surgery are not very satisfactory, it should be considered carefully.

[Read More] Scar Revision Surgery: Options, Procedures, and Recovery Explained


Related FAQ

Post-Fracture Surgery

(Orthopedics)

Post-Fracture Rehabilitation

(Orthopedics)

Fracture Healing

(Orthopedics)

Leg Fracture

(Orthopedics)

Tibia And Fibula Fracture

(Orthopedics)

Bone

(Orthopedics)

Periostitis

(Orthopedics)

Ankle Fracture Recovery

(Orthopedics)

Talus Fracture

(Orthopedics)

Fracture

(Rehabilitation)