Managing Pelvic Fractures After a Car Accident: Surgical vs. Conservative Care

Pelvic fracture from a car accident?

Hello, at the beginning of April, my spouse was involved in a car accident that resulted in a pelvic fracture, specifically a fracture below the left hip joint and a comminuted fracture of the left pubis.
The emergency physician and the orthopedic surgeon in the emergency department recommended bed rest at home without surgery.
Four days later, during a follow-up visit, the outpatient physician suggested surgery.
After consulting with other orthopedic clinics, they also recommended bed rest.
A month later, during another follow-up, the outpatient physician still suggested surgery, but stated that bed rest was also an option, although the fracture gap had widened.
Another physician indicated that surgery was unnecessary and that after six weeks, my spouse could gradually begin rehabilitation and standing.
After another month, during a follow-up and X-ray examination, it was noted that the fracture gap had further widened, and it was mentioned that standing was affecting the healing process.
Surgery was recommended soon, and we are currently considering it.
Please advise, thank you.

Peng Xiansheng, 40~49 year old female. Ask Date: 2020/06/04

Dr. You Dianqi reply Orthopedics

Hello, based on your description, it seems intuitive to consider whether your family member's fracture falls into the category of being operable or non-operable.
Have you thought about consulting a medical center to find a specialist in pelvic fractures? It would be beneficial to hear their professional opinion and evaluate the pros and cons of surgery versus non-surgical options before making a decision.

Reply Date: 2020/06/04

More Info

Managing pelvic fractures after a car accident can be a complex decision-making process that involves weighing the benefits and risks of surgical versus conservative care. In your case, your wife has sustained a significant injury, specifically a left-sided pubic bone fracture with a pelvic ring disruption. The management of such fractures can vary based on several factors, including the patient's overall health, the specific nature of the fracture, and the presence of any complications.

Surgical vs. Conservative Care
1. Conservative Management: This approach typically involves bed rest, pain management, and gradual mobilization as tolerated. It is often recommended for stable fractures that are not significantly displaced. The rationale behind this approach is to allow the body to heal naturally while minimizing the risks associated with surgery, such as infection, blood loss, and complications from anesthesia. However, conservative management may not be suitable for all types of pelvic fractures, especially if there is significant displacement or instability.

2. Surgical Intervention: Surgery may be indicated if the fracture is unstable or if there is significant displacement that could lead to complications, such as chronic pain, deformity, or impaired function. Surgical options may include internal fixation, where plates and screws are used to stabilize the fracture, allowing for earlier mobilization and potentially better long-term outcomes. The decision to operate is often influenced by the degree of displacement, the patient’s age, activity level, and overall health.

Factors to Consider
- Fracture Stability: If the fracture is stable and there is no significant displacement, conservative management may be appropriate. However, if the fracture is unstable and continues to displace, surgical intervention may be necessary to restore proper alignment and stability.

- Healing Progress: Regular follow-up appointments and imaging studies (such as X-rays) are crucial to monitor the healing process. If there is evidence of continued displacement or if the fracture is not healing as expected, surgery may become a more favorable option.

- Patient's Overall Health: The patient's age, comorbidities, and functional status should be considered. Younger, healthier patients may tolerate surgery better and may benefit more from surgical stabilization.

- Pain and Functionality: Persistent pain and functional limitations are significant factors. If conservative management is not alleviating pain or improving function, surgical options should be reconsidered.

Recommendations
Given the complexity of your wife's injury and the differing opinions from various healthcare providers, it is essential to have a thorough discussion with an orthopedic surgeon who specializes in pelvic fractures. Here are some steps you can take:
1. Seek a Second Opinion: If you have not already done so, consider consulting with a specialist in orthopedic trauma or a pelvic fracture expert. They can provide a more tailored assessment based on your wife's specific injury.

2. Discuss Imaging Results: Ensure that all imaging studies are reviewed, and discuss the implications of any changes in the fracture alignment over time. Understanding the healing trajectory is crucial in making an informed decision.

3. Evaluate Pain Management: If your wife is experiencing significant pain, discuss pain management strategies with her healthcare team. Effective pain control can improve her quality of life and may influence her ability to participate in rehabilitation.

4. Consider Rehabilitation: If conservative management is chosen, a structured rehabilitation program should be initiated as soon as it is safe to do so. Physical therapy can help improve mobility, strength, and function, which are critical for recovery.

5. Monitor for Complications: Be vigilant for any signs of complications, such as increased pain, swelling, or changes in mobility. If these occur, it may necessitate a reevaluation of the treatment plan.

In conclusion, the management of pelvic fractures is highly individualized. It is crucial to weigh the risks and benefits of surgical versus conservative care carefully. Open communication with healthcare providers and a thorough understanding of the injury will help guide the best course of action for your wife's recovery.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Complex Pelvic Fractures and Their Treatment Options

Dear Doctor, My husband is the patient who was involved in a car accident on January 28, 2022. The medical summary indicates that he sustained a comminuted fracture of the right acetabulum with mild displacement, as well as contusions and lacerations to the forehead, and a concu...

Dr. Wang Jiacheng reply Orthopedics
After a hip joint fracture, there is a possibility of developing arthritis many years later, which requires ongoing monitoring. As for bladder issues, it may be necessary to consult a urologist.

Understanding Pelvic Fractures: Surgical Options and Recovery Insights

Hello, doctor. I would like to ask about my sister. She was in a car accident and has a fracture in her pelvis and a broken small bone in her lower leg (which has been casted). However, she needs surgery for the pelvis. She also has an injury to her pancreas, and we are waiting f...

Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
The question you raised is difficult to answer without an X-ray for reference and without knowing which bone is fractured. If it is a simple fracture, the surgery is relatively straightforward. However, if it is a complex fracture or one near the hip joint, it becomes more challe...

Can Pelvic Fractures Be Repaired? A Case Study of Recovery Options

My sister was in a car accident, and her pelvis was run over by a garbage truck. The doctor diagnosed her with a shattered pelvis, and the section near the femur is almost completely broken. There is significant bleeding from the nerves, and she has already undergone surgery to c...

Dr. Zhou Lizhi reply Orthopedics
Pelvic fractures are a serious major trauma, and their impact extends beyond the pelvic bones themselves to include issues related to nerves, blood vessels, the reproductive system, and the presence of open wounds. Therefore, each patient's condition is different. If there i...

Pelvic and Lumbar Fractures from Car Accident: Recovery Insights

Hello, doctor. I had a car accident in mid-May that resulted in a pelvic fracture. Initially, I landed on my right hip, and I still experience soreness in the hip area (does this indicate that it has not healed yet?). I would like to know how long it will take before I can stop u...

Dr. Wang Shouji reply Orthopedics
Hello: The assessment of fracture healing requires reviewing X-rays and medical history, and then following the physician's recommendations. Changhua Hospital cares about your health. Wang Shou-ji.