Post-Circumcision Care: Can I Use White Medicine Instead of Betadine? - Urology

Share to:

Post-circumcision care


Hello, doctor.
I would like to ask if I can use hydrogen peroxide instead of Betadine when changing the dressing? Also, will using saline solution and hydrogen peroxide to clean and wipe the wound cause the sutures from the circumcision surgery to become loose?

Wang Ou, 10~19 year old female. Ask Date: 2020/06/30

Dr. Du Shixi reply Urology


Hello: 1) Yes, as long as there are no alcohol components, it will be less irritating.
2) Both are fine, but they will take longer to soften.
Make sure to dry off after use.
Wishing you good health.

Reply Date: 2020/06/30

More Info


After a circumcision, proper wound care is crucial for healing and preventing infection. The question of whether to use white medicine (often referring to a topical antiseptic like silver sulfadiazine) instead of Betadine (povidone-iodine) is a common concern among patients and caregivers.

Betadine is a broad-spectrum antiseptic that is effective against bacteria, viruses, and fungi. It is often used in surgical settings for skin preparation and post-operative care due to its efficacy in reducing the risk of infection. On the other hand, white medicine, while it may have some antiseptic properties, is not as widely recommended for surgical wounds as Betadine.

Using white medicine instead of Betadine may not provide the same level of protection against infection. If you are considering this substitution, it is essential to consult with your healthcare provider first. They can provide guidance based on the specific circumstances of your healing process and any potential allergies or sensitivities you may have to the ingredients in these products.

Regarding the use of saline solution and white medicine for cleaning and wiping the wound, it is generally safe to use saline for wound care. Saline is isotonic and helps to keep the wound moist, which can promote healing. However, it is crucial to avoid excessive manipulation of the wound, as this can disrupt the healing process and potentially lead to complications.

When it comes to the concern about the sutures softening, it is important to follow your doctor's instructions regarding wound care. Most sutures used in circumcision are designed to be absorbable and will dissolve on their own over time. However, if the wound is excessively wet or manipulated, it could potentially affect the integrity of the sutures. Therefore, it is advisable to keep the area clean and dry, applying any topical treatments as directed by your healthcare provider.

In summary, while white medicine may have some antiseptic properties, it is not a direct substitute for Betadine in post-operative care following circumcision. Always consult with your healthcare provider before making any changes to your wound care regimen. They can provide personalized recommendations based on your specific situation, ensuring that you promote optimal healing and minimize the risk of infection.

Similar Q&A

Post-Circumcision Skin Tear: Infection Risks and Healing Concerns

On July 28, I had a circumcision. Today, after masturbating (just rubbing the glans), there is a small abrasion at the site of the circumcision, with a little bit of bleeding. I have applied Betadine and covered it with a bandage. Should I be concerned about infection? Will it he...


Dr. Zhang Chengye reply Urology
Hello: There is a possibility of infection, depending on whether you maintained hygiene during the disinfection process. It is advisable to observe the situation for a few days. If there is no improvement or if the pain persists, please seek medical attention as soon as possible....

[Read More] Post-Circumcision Skin Tear: Infection Risks and Healing Concerns


Post-Vasectomy Wound Care: Understanding Complications and Best Practices

On December 7, I underwent laser no-scalpel vasectomy, which resulted in two wounds. On December 18, the left wound opened up and bled. During this period, I finished my medication. In the first few days post-surgery, I applied Betadine to the wound and covered it with an adhesiv...


Dr. Du Shixi reply Urology
Hello: Based on personal experience, most wounds heal completely within 7 days. If they exceed 7 days, they may reopen, which could be related to individual health factors. For superficial wounds, it is important to keep the area clean; a scar will form, similar to a abrasion, an...

[Read More] Post-Vasectomy Wound Care: Understanding Complications and Best Practices


Post-Circumcision Care: Recommended Ointments and Treatments

Hello doctor, I recently underwent a circumcision surgery, and I would like to ask what other medications can be applied to the wound besides antibiotic ointment?


Dr. Du Shixi reply Urology
Hello: You can use antibiotic ointment. Be careful not to get it wet for the first few days after surgery; if it does get wet, make sure to dry it thoroughly. Keep the wound protected. Minimize erections; it is safe only after about two weeks when the wound is fully healed. Wishi...

[Read More] Post-Circumcision Care: Recommended Ointments and Treatments


Managing Post-Circumcision Infection: Tips for Faster Healing

Hello Doctor, today is the 10th day after my circumcision. Currently, I have one suture site that has developed a wound infection (or is it inflammation? I can't quite remember what you said). Other than that, the healing is going well. The infection (inflammation) appears a...


Dr. Du Shixi reply Urology
Hello: 1. Due to my long-term habit of using e-cigarettes (4% Nicotine Salts), and having maintained this habit for the past 10 days post-surgery (I started to control it today), I am wondering if my wound infection (inflammation) could be related to this, considering the impac...

[Read More] Managing Post-Circumcision Infection: Tips for Faster Healing


Related FAQ