Navigating Cancer Care: Seeking Second Opinions and Treatment Options

Interdisciplinary treatment issues?

My father originally had a small tumor in his lungs and would regularly visit the Pulmonology department for check-ups.
Recently, due to sudden significant weight loss, he was referred by a new physician for a PET scan.
After reviewing the report, the new physician found inflammatory responses in two areas of the lungs and two areas in the abdomen.
After evaluation, the new physician recommended a bronchoscopy with biopsy for the lungs and also suggested consulting with Hematology for related tests.
The original attending physician in Pulmonology has left, and there is not a good communication rapport with the new attending physician.

Given my father's advanced age, his body may not be able to undergo surgery.
If invasive tests are performed without the possibility of treatment, could this lead to other complications? Would it be advisable to consult with an Oncologist to evaluate and discuss how to conduct comprehensive examinations and potential subsequent treatments? What would you recommend? Thank you.

Sheng, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2020/07/16

Dr. Hu Ziren reply Oncology

1.
It is recommended to perform a biopsy first to determine the cause (benign or malignant, lung cancer or other), and then discuss whether further treatment is necessary.

2.
You may consider referring to an oncology specialist for further evaluation.

Reply Date: 2020/07/16

More Info

Navigating cancer care can be a daunting experience, especially when dealing with complex medical situations and the emotional weight of a loved one's health. Your father's recent health developments, including the discovery of inflammatory responses in his lungs and abdomen, warrant careful consideration and a multi-disciplinary approach to ensure he receives the best possible care.

Given your father's age and the potential risks associated with invasive procedures, it is crucial to weigh the benefits and drawbacks of any recommended tests or treatments. A bronchoscopy, while a valuable diagnostic tool for assessing lung issues, does carry risks, particularly for older patients or those with compromised health. These risks can include bleeding, infection, or complications related to anesthesia. Therefore, it is essential to have a thorough discussion with the healthcare team about the necessity of this procedure and whether it will provide actionable information that could lead to effective treatment options.

In your situation, seeking a second opinion from an oncologist is a wise choice. An oncologist specializes in cancer treatment and can provide insights into the overall management of your father's condition, including the potential need for systemic evaluations and treatments. They can also help assess whether the findings from the bronchoscopy are critical for determining a treatment plan or if alternative, less invasive diagnostic methods could be employed.

Additionally, consulting with a hematologist, as suggested by the new physician, could be beneficial if there are concerns about blood-related issues or if the inflammatory responses might indicate a hematological condition. Hematologists can provide a comprehensive evaluation of blood counts and other related parameters, which may be crucial in understanding your father's overall health status.

When considering the coordination of care among different specialties, it is essential to ensure that all healthcare providers are communicating effectively. This can help avoid unnecessary procedures and ensure that any treatment plan is cohesive and tailored to your father's specific needs. You might want to request a care conference or a meeting with all involved specialists to discuss your father's case comprehensively. This approach can clarify the rationale behind each recommendation and help you make informed decisions regarding his care.

Moreover, if your father is experiencing significant weight loss and other symptoms, it may be worthwhile to explore supportive care options. Palliative care specialists can assist in managing symptoms, improving quality of life, and providing emotional support for both your father and your family during this challenging time. They can work alongside oncologists and other specialists to ensure that your father's comfort and preferences are prioritized.

In summary, navigating cancer care involves careful consideration of diagnostic and treatment options, particularly in older patients with complex health issues. Seeking a second opinion from an oncologist, discussing the necessity and risks of invasive procedures, and ensuring effective communication among all healthcare providers are crucial steps. Additionally, exploring supportive care options can enhance your father's quality of life during treatment. Always advocate for your father's health and well-being, and do not hesitate to ask questions or seek clarification from his medical team.

Similar Q&A

Seeking Second Opinions in Oncology: A Guide for Patients

Hello Dr. Yang. My father was recently diagnosed with a tumor approximately 2 cm in size in his kidney due to hematuria at New Taipei City Keelung Chang Gung Memorial Hospital. I will summarize his condition as follows: a 2 cm tumor in the kidney, with no evidence of metastasis, ...

Dr. Yang Youhua reply Oncology
If your father has renal cell carcinoma and it is only two centimeters, surgical removal is very important. Subsequent treatment should consider "immunotherapy" to enhance personal immune function. If it is transitional cell carcinoma, chemotherapy and radiation therapy...

Navigating Treatment Options for Stage IV Colorectal Cancer with Lung Metastasis

Thank you for taking the time to respond to my inquiry on March 8th. Currently, I have white spots in both lungs, so surgery is not an option. After three months of treatment with second-line medications, there has been no change. The tumor I had surgically removed tested positiv...

Dr. Chen Sirong reply Oncology
Fen/45/1 I apologize! My personal expertise is in radiation oncology and palliative care, so your question should be directed to a physician specialized in chemotherapy for a more accurate response, which is why my reply is delayed. Essentially, your attending physician's ad...

Navigating Breast Cancer Treatment Options for a 90-Year-Old Grandmother

Recently, it was discovered that my 90-year-old grandmother has stage II breast cancer, PR+ER+Her2+(currently undergoing FISH testing). I would like to ask: 1. If examinations show no metastasis, but due to her age and the inherent risks of surgery, she chooses to forgo surgica...

Dr. Chen Sirong reply Oncology
Meg, 30 years old, female. 1. After examination, there is no metastasis, but due to age and the inherent risks of surgery, she chooses to forgo surgical intervention. Can she opt for direct hormonal therapy and targeted therapy with government insurance coverage for trastuzumab...

Navigating Treatment Decisions: Balancing Trust and Medical Opinions in Oncology

Thank you, Dr. Wu, for your response. I think you may have misunderstood my point. My attending physician wants me to be discharged, but the infectious disease doctor insists that I continue treatment. Personally, I trust my attending physician more, but being in the hospital lim...

Dr. Wu Jingtang reply Breast and Thyroid
Dear Miss Len, I apologize for the misunderstanding! Theoretically, the treatment of infections should reach a certain level before discontinuing medication (I tend to rely on the expertise of infectious disease specialists) to avoid the development of antibiotic resistance! How...