Transmission of cold or pneumonia?
Hello, doctor.
Today I took my niece to Taipei, and we wore masks on the train.
However, the man and woman across from us seemed to intentionally take off their masks when they coughed and sneezed...
I want to ask if there is a possibility that we could get infected.
As soon as the train stopped, I quickly took my niece off the train to switch carriages.
It feels so frustrating why they would take off their masks when they were supposed to wear them.
😭
Mita, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2020/08/27
Dr. Hong Yuanbin reply Internal Medicine
Hello, based on your description, the ability for droplet transmission at a distance should be relatively low, so your risk of infection should be low.
Thank you for your question.
Reply Date: 2020/08/27
More Info
When it comes to catching respiratory infections like the common cold or pneumonia while using public transport, there are several factors to consider. First and foremost, it is important to understand how these viruses are transmitted. The common cold is primarily caused by viruses such as rhinoviruses, while pneumonia can be caused by various pathogens, including bacteria and viruses. Both can be spread through respiratory droplets when an infected person coughs, sneezes, or talks.
In your situation, where you were on a train and noticed individuals removing their masks while coughing and sneezing, there is indeed a potential risk of exposure to respiratory pathogens. However, the risk of transmission is influenced by several factors:
1. Distance and Duration of Exposure: The closer you are to an infected person and the longer you are exposed, the higher the risk of transmission. Since you quickly moved to another car, this likely reduced your exposure time.
2. Mask Usage: You mentioned that you and your niece were wearing masks. Properly worn masks can significantly reduce the transmission of respiratory viruses. Masks act as a barrier to prevent respiratory droplets from entering the air and being inhaled by others. However, if someone removes their mask while coughing or sneezing, they can still release droplets into the air, which can be inhaled by those nearby.
3. Ventilation: Public transport systems, like trains, often have ventilation systems that can help disperse and dilute airborne pathogens. Good ventilation can reduce the concentration of infectious droplets in the air.
4. Personal Health: Your overall health and immune system play a significant role in your susceptibility to infections. If you and your niece are generally healthy, your risk of contracting an illness may be lower.
Given these factors, while there is a possibility of exposure, the actual risk of contracting a cold or pneumonia from a brief encounter with individuals who are not wearing masks is relatively low, especially since you took precautions by wearing masks and quickly distancing yourselves.
To further minimize your risk of infection while using public transport, consider the following recommendations:
- Continue Wearing Masks: Especially in crowded or enclosed spaces, wearing a mask can provide an additional layer of protection against respiratory infections.
- Practice Good Hygiene: Regular handwashing with soap and water or using hand sanitizer can help reduce the risk of infection. Avoid touching your face, especially your eyes, nose, and mouth, with unwashed hands.
- Maintain Distance: Whenever possible, try to maintain physical distance from individuals who are coughing or sneezing, even if they are wearing masks.
- Stay Informed: Keep an eye on local health advisories, especially during cold and flu season or when there are outbreaks of respiratory illnesses in your area.
- Monitor Symptoms: If you or your niece develop any symptoms of respiratory illness, such as a cough, fever, or difficulty breathing, it is important to seek medical advice and possibly get tested for infections like COVID-19 or influenza.
In conclusion, while there is a potential risk of catching a cold or pneumonia on public transport, taking appropriate precautions can significantly reduce that risk. Your quick actions to move away from the situation were wise, and maintaining good hygiene and mask-wearing practices will further protect you and your niece in the future.
Similar Q&A
Concerns About Respiratory Infections from Coughing Strangers
Hello Dr. Yang: Today, while waiting for the bus at the bus stop, I turned to walk to the other side when a female passerby (or fellow passenger) directly coughed several times in front of me. From the sound, it seemed like she had phlegm, and she was not wearing a mask or coveri...
Dr. Yang Wenda reply Pulmonology
Hello: Here are brief answers to your three questions: 1. The situations in which you encounter patients with coughs are in open spaces with wind and airflow, where any infectious droplets are quickly dispersed or diluted. Additionally, the contact time is brief, so the risk of...[Read More] Concerns About Respiratory Infections from Coughing Strangers
Outdoor Cough Etiquette: Protecting Your Child's Health
Hello Doctor, During lunchtime, I accompanied my younger sister home from school, and on the way, we encountered a man who was coughing without wearing a mask and sprayed towards us. When we got home, I quickly told my sister to wash her hands and rinse her mouth before watchin...
Dr. Xiao Yongxun reply Family Medicine
Dear Ms. Mei: 1. Covering your mouth and nose while coughing to prevent droplet spread is a basic etiquette and a measure for infectious disease protection. Unfortunately, there are still a very small number of individuals who do not pay attention to this. Currently, we are faci...[Read More] Outdoor Cough Etiquette: Protecting Your Child's Health
Understanding Cold Symptoms: Transmission Risks and Safety Tips
I have been experiencing a severe cough with phlegm, nasal congestion, and a runny nose, but I do not have a fever. I would like to ask the doctor a few questions regarding transmission: 1. If my boyfriend and I are studying in the study room and both of us are coughing while c...
Dr. Lü Bingcheng reply Traditional Chinese Medicine
Q1. If I cough while studying with my boyfriend in the study room without wearing a mask but covering my mouth, is there a risk of transmitting the cold to him? A1. There is still a risk of transmitting the cold to your boyfriend. Q2. Is it safer to sit face-to-face or side-by...[Read More] Understanding Cold Symptoms: Transmission Risks and Safety Tips
Understanding Tuberculosis Transmission: Common Myths and Facts
Hello, Doctor. I apologize for interrupting you during your busy schedule. I have some questions regarding tuberculosis (TB) and I hope you can help me. Thank you. 1. Can tuberculosis be transmitted through objects, books, clothing, or public transportation handles? For example,...
Dr. Yang Wenda reply Pulmonology
Hello: Tuberculosis (TB) is primarily transmitted through airborne droplets. You need not worry excessively about the risk of transmission through objects that the patient has touched, as it is extremely low. If you are in the same space as the patient, normal breathing can poten...[Read More] Understanding Tuberculosis Transmission: Common Myths and Facts
Related FAQ
(Internal Medicine)
Cold(Internal Medicine)
Infection Risk(Internal Medicine)
Common Cold(Family Medicine)
Contagion(Internal Medicine)
Pneumonia(Pulmonology)
Vaccination(Internal Medicine)
Infection Inquiry(Internal Medicine)
Covid-19 Transmission(Internal Medicine)
Cold(Otolaryngology)