Can a Motorcycle Accident Cause Rib Fractures and Pneumothorax Without Direct Impact? - Orthopedics

Share to:

Regarding the car accident, the other party's medical report indicates rib fractures and pneumothorax?


Hello, doctor.
I would like to ask a question regarding an accident.
In a T-bone motorcycle collision involving two motorcycles, where neither the vehicles nor the riders fell, and the point of impact was on the exhaust pipe without any direct impact to the person, can this cause rib fractures and pneumothorax? If so, would there be any external injuries such as bruising or contusions? Additionally, does this condition require hospitalization for observation or surgery? Thank you for your clarification.

Cai Ruichang, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2020/11/04

Dr. Zhan Xian reply Orthopedics


Hello Mr.
Tsai, rib fractures from a car accident are possible.
Whether hospitalization and surgery are necessary depends on the condition of the fracture, the presence of pneumothorax, and whether there are any other associated injuries.

Reply Date: 2020/11/04

More Info


In the context of motorcycle accidents, it is indeed possible for rib fractures and pneumothorax to occur without direct impact to the body. The mechanics of injury in such scenarios can be complex and involve several factors, including the forces exerted during the accident, the positioning of the rider, and the nature of the collision.

1. Mechanism of Injury: Rib fractures can occur due to direct trauma, such as a collision with another vehicle or object. However, they can also result from indirect forces, such as the sudden deceleration experienced during a crash. In your case, if the motorcycle came to a sudden stop or experienced a rapid change in speed, the force exerted on the thoracic cavity could potentially lead to rib fractures. This is especially true if the rider was leaning or positioned in a way that concentrated force on the ribs.

2. Pneumothorax: A pneumothorax, or collapsed lung, can occur when air leaks into the space between the lung and chest wall. This can happen due to rib fractures that puncture the pleura (the membrane surrounding the lungs). Even in the absence of direct impact, the forces from a crash can cause enough trauma to lead to a pneumothorax.
3. Signs and Symptoms: In many cases, rib fractures and pneumothorax may not present with visible external injuries such as bruising or swelling. However, patients may experience sharp pain in the chest, difficulty breathing, or a feeling of tightness. It is important to note that not all rib fractures will result in visible bruising, especially if the injury is internal.

4. Need for Hospitalization and Surgery: Whether hospitalization or surgery is required depends on the severity of the injuries. If a rib fracture is stable and there is no significant displacement or associated pneumothorax, conservative management may be sufficient. This typically involves pain management and monitoring. However, if a pneumothorax is present, especially if it is large or causing significant respiratory distress, hospitalization may be necessary. In some cases, a chest tube may be required to remove air from the pleural space and allow the lung to re-expand.

5. Diagnostic Imaging: To confirm the presence of rib fractures or pneumothorax, imaging studies such as X-rays or CT scans are often utilized. These can help visualize the extent of the injury and guide treatment decisions.

In summary, while direct impact is a common cause of rib fractures and pneumothorax, indirect forces from a motorcycle accident can also lead to these injuries. It is crucial to seek medical evaluation if there are any symptoms suggestive of these conditions, even in the absence of visible external injuries. Early diagnosis and appropriate management can significantly affect recovery outcomes. If you have concerns about your health following an accident, it is advisable to consult a healthcare professional for a thorough assessment.

Similar Q&A

Could Minor Accidents Lead to Internal Injuries? A Medical Perspective

Hello Doctor, about four or five years ago, shortly after I got my driver's license, I was riding my motorcycle when the car in front of me suddenly stopped at the roadside. Although the car wasn't going fast, I remember I had to brake suddenly and lightly bumped into t...


Dr. Hong Yuanbin reply Internal Medicine
Hello, based on your description, it seems that it is likely just a minor abrasion, which would result in some superficial injuries and should not cause any damage to internal organs. Therefore, if there are no symptoms, a full-body examination should not be necessary. Thank you ...

[Read More] Could Minor Accidents Lead to Internal Injuries? A Medical Perspective


Understanding Post-Crash Muscle Pain and Chest Discomfort After a Motorcycle Fall

Hello, doctor. I am a 20-year-old female. Two days ago, I had a motorcycle accident and fell at a speed of about 40-60 km/h. I have abrasions on my limbs, but there are no visible bruises or significant wounds on my torso, and I do not have any tenderness. However, I am experienc...


Dr. Zhan Xian reply Orthopedics
Factors such as bruises, muscle strains, and muscle cramps may be involved. If discomfort persists, please visit an orthopedic outpatient clinic.

[Read More] Understanding Post-Crash Muscle Pain and Chest Discomfort After a Motorcycle Fall


Post-Crash Chest Pain: Should You See a Pulmonologist or Internist?

Yesterday, I fell off my motorcycle after an emergency brake while carrying a passenger on the back seat. Both of us fell to the ground, and the person on the back landed on top of me. I have some abrasions on my body and face, and I felt pain in my chest from the impact. Could t...


Dr. Jian Shuntian reply Pulmonology
Hello, direct or indirect impact to the chest can potentially cause bleeding within the thoracic cavity or pleura. Please visit a thoracic specialist for a chest X-ray to confirm and receive further treatment. Thank you. This response is respectfully provided by Dr. Jian Shun-Tia...

[Read More] Post-Crash Chest Pain: Should You See a Pulmonologist or Internist?


Can I Ride a Motorcycle to Wuling After Spontaneous Pneumothorax Surgery?

Hello doctor, I would like to ask if it's safe for me to ride a motorcycle to Wuling and make a short stop before coming back down, considering that I had surgery for spontaneous pneumothorax around April and May of last year and my condition has been stable since then.


Dr. Zhang Ziyan reply Pulmonology
Hello, if you have a spontaneous pneumothorax without any other comorbidities or complications, and your postoperative follow-up shows no significant abnormalities, you may resume normal activities. However, if you experience symptoms similar to those of the previous pneumothorax...

[Read More] Can I Ride a Motorcycle to Wuling After Spontaneous Pneumothorax Surgery?


Related FAQ

Rib Fracture

(Orthopedics)

Chest Contusion

(Orthopedics)

Car Accident Injury

(Orthopedics)

Post-Clavicle Fracture Surgery

(Orthopedics)

Car Accident

(Family Medicine)

After Car Accident

(Surgery)

Rib Pain

(Family Medicine)

Chest Pain

(Pulmonology)

Neck Strain

(Orthopedics)

Radial Fracture

(Orthopedics)