Should You Get a Second CT Scan for Kidney Tumor Concerns?

Abdominal ultrasound examination revealed a tumor in the kidney?

Hello, doctor.
During a company health check, an abdominal ultrasound revealed a kidney tumor (1.1 cm).
I subsequently went to a large hospital for a CT scan, and the physician indicated that it did not appear to be a tumor and advised me to be reassured.
I would like to ask if I should go to another hospital for another CT scan for confirmation, or if the current CT technology is reliable enough that a repeat scan is unnecessary.
Thank you.

Yu, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2021/01/16

Dr. Jian Weihong reply Urology

A CT scan should not be performed at another hospital due to concerns about radiation exposure and costs; generally, it is recommended to wait at least a few months between scans (since renal tumors typically change slowly, intervals of over a year may be acceptable).
The differences in CT equipment, examination techniques, and interpretations among hospitals are usually minimal, although there can still be some variation.
Seeking a second opinion at another hospital is permissible, but it typically involves bringing the imaging data to the new facility for the physician there to re-evaluate, rather than repeating the scan.
Alternatively, follow-up examinations can be conducted after some time, with ultrasound often being prioritized for these follow-ups.

Reply Date: 2021/01/16

More Info

When it comes to kidney tumors, the decision to seek a second opinion or undergo additional imaging tests, such as a CT scan, can be a significant concern for patients. In your case, you have already undergone an abdominal ultrasound that indicated a kidney tumor measuring 1.1 cm, followed by a CT scan at a larger hospital where the physician suggested that it does not appear to be a tumor and reassured you.
First and foremost, it is essential to understand that while modern imaging techniques, including CT scans, are highly advanced and can provide detailed insights into the structure of organs, they are not infallible. There are instances where small tumors or atypical lesions may be missed or mischaracterized. Therefore, if you still have concerns about the initial findings or the interpretation of the CT scan, seeking a second opinion can be a prudent choice.
Here are some considerations regarding your situation:
1. Understanding the Nature of the Lesion: The fact that the lesion was initially detected via ultrasound and later evaluated with a CT scan raises the question of its nature. If the CT scan indicated that it does not appear to be a tumor, it would be beneficial to understand what the physician based this conclusion on. Was it the size, shape, or characteristics of the lesion? Detailed communication with the physician about these aspects can provide clarity.

2. Second Opinions: Seeking a second opinion is a common practice in medicine, especially when it comes to potential malignancies. It is your right as a patient to seek further evaluation, and most physicians understand this. When approaching another healthcare facility, you can request copies of your imaging studies and reports from the previous hospital. This will allow the new physician to review your case without the need for repeat imaging unless deemed necessary.

3. Imaging Techniques: While CT scans are highly reliable, they do have limitations. Factors such as the size of the lesion, its location, and the quality of the imaging can affect the accuracy of the diagnosis. If there is still uncertainty or if the lesion changes over time, follow-up imaging may be warranted.
4. Monitoring and Follow-Up: If the lesion is indeed benign or not concerning, your physician may recommend a follow-up plan that includes periodic imaging to monitor any changes. This is often done to ensure that if there is any growth or change in characteristics, it can be addressed promptly.

5. Consulting a Specialist: If you are still uncertain, consider consulting a urologist or an oncologist who specializes in kidney tumors. They can provide a more in-depth evaluation and may suggest additional tests or monitoring strategies based on the latest guidelines and research.

In conclusion, while the reassurance from your CT scan is valuable, your peace of mind is equally important. If you feel uncertain or anxious about the findings, seeking a second opinion or further evaluation is a reasonable step. It is always better to be thorough, especially when it comes to potential health concerns. Remember, your health and well-being should always be the priority, and you have the right to seek the best possible care.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Kidney Tumors: When to Worry and What to Expect

Hello Dr. Du, I apologize for bothering you again with my concerns. 1. Last August, I consulted you regarding a 0.6 cm tumor found during a kidney ultrasound at Shudian Urology. The doctor advised me to follow up in a year. Recently, I have been experiencing nighttime dry mouth...

Dr. Du Shixi reply Urology
Hello: 1) This is the standard procedure. 2) Adrenal tumors are difficult to assess and diagnose. It is recommended to consult a urology department at a medical center, as regular monitoring is essential due to the size of 2.9 cm (it is uncertain whether it will grow larger). Wis...

Navigating Urology Concerns: Seeking Guidance for My Mother's Health

Urgent~ My mother was treated for tuberculosis in the intensive care unit last year and has since been referred to Kaohsiung Medical University for ongoing follow-up. She no longer needs medication, but recently she has been experiencing chest discomfort and persistent phlegm. A ...

Dr. Pan Zhenqin reply Urology
Based on your description, it appears to be a kidney tumor unexpectedly discovered during a routine examination. If the physician suspects it to be malignant, it is likely renal cell carcinoma. These tumors that are found incidentally are generally not very large, and surgical re...

Should You Remove a Benign Kidney Tumor? Key Considerations and Risks

Hello Doctor: Recently, an ultrasound and a CT scan revealed a tumor approximately 2.5 cm in size on my right kidney. A biopsy confirmed it is benign. My questions are: 1. Is there a possibility that it could turn malignant, and should it be removed to avoid future complications?...

Dr. Lai Yicheng reply Oncology
Mr. Santos replied: 1. Regular follow-up is sufficient, with an ultrasound every three months and a CT scan annually. 2. The accuracy of the biopsy is reliable. 3. Essentially, please consult with your physician regarding the necessity of removal, as benign removal is not mandato...

Understanding Renal Cysts: Should You Be Concerned at a Young Age?

Hello Doctor, I had an abdominal ultrasound at a general family medicine clinic last year, and the only issue found was a 2 cm cyst on my right kidney. At that time, the family medicine doctor advised me to follow up once a year. Recently, during my follow-up examination, I disco...

Dr. Du Shixi reply Urology
Hello: Ultrasound can be used for diagnosis, and most cases require long-term observation. Most do not resolve on their own. In the case of polycystic kidney disease, it is important to monitor whether the cysts increase in number. The risk of cancer transformation is low. You ca...