Treatment Options for Hydrocephalus in Elderly Patients

Management of Hydrocephalus

Hello Doctor, my father-in-law is currently about 75 years old.
He suffered a brain injury and hydrocephalus from a car accident in 2004, and underwent ventriculoperitoneal shunt placement (initially with an adjustable shunt that was removed due to infection, and three months later, a non-adjustable shunt was placed on the other side of the brain, which remains in place to this day).
Over the past year, his physical condition has significantly deteriorated, especially in the last 2-3 months, with sudden changes including irritability, hypersomnia, difficulty walking (unable to lift his feet off the ground), urinary and fecal incontinence, and signs of dementia and amnesia.
Recent CT scans have confirmed hydrocephalus by two physicians, but the surgical recommendations from the doctors differ, leaving non-medical family members unsure of how to decide.

Doctor A recommends performing a lumbar-peritoneal shunt, citing a lower risk and smaller incision.
Doctor B suggests a ventriculopleural shunt, considering the previous infection with the shunt and potential absorption issues with the peritoneal drainage, recommending placement in the pleural cavity instead.

Could you please clarify:
(1) In what situations are these two types of shunt procedures, as well as the ventriculoatrial cerebrospinal fluid drainage surgery, typically indicated for patients?
(2) What is the likelihood of poor absorption with drainage in the pleural cavity? What risks or complications (such as fluid accumulation, adhesions, or others) might arise from placing a shunt in this location?
(3) Is it possible for my father-in-law's symptoms from the past 2-3 months to improve after surgery? Thank you, Doctor.

bubble, 40~49 year old female. Ask Date: 2021/03/05

Dr. Zhang Junwei reply Neurosurgery

Pleural cavity drainage is primarily concerned with pleural effusion.
The extent to which symptoms improve after drainage is not guaranteed.
While drainage can alleviate hydrocephalus, it cannot assist patients who already exhibit symptoms of dementia.

Reply Date: 2021/03/05

More Info

When considering treatment options for hydrocephalus in elderly patients, particularly in the case of your father-in-law, it is essential to understand the various surgical interventions available, their indications, and potential outcomes. Hydrocephalus, characterized by an accumulation of cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) in the brain's ventricles, can lead to increased intracranial pressure and a range of neurological symptoms, including cognitive decline, gait disturbances, and incontinence, as you've described.

Surgical Options for Hydrocephalus
1. Ventriculoperitoneal (VP) Shunt: This is the most common surgical procedure for treating hydrocephalus. It involves placing a catheter in the brain's ventricles that drains excess CSF into the peritoneal cavity, where it can be absorbed. This procedure is typically indicated for patients with communicating hydrocephalus, where there is no obstruction in the CSF pathways.

2. Lumboperitoneal Shunt: This involves placing a catheter in the lumbar region of the spine to drain CSF into the peritoneal cavity. It is often considered for patients with normal pressure hydrocephalus or when a VP shunt is not feasible due to prior infections or anatomical considerations.

3. Ventriculoatrial Shunt: This less common procedure drains CSF from the ventricles directly into the right atrium of the heart. It may be indicated in cases where other drainage sites are not suitable, but it carries a higher risk of complications such as cardiac arrhythmias.

Considerations for Your Father-in-Law
Given your father-in-law's history of hydrocephalus following a traumatic brain injury and the recent decline in his functional status, the choice between a lumboperitoneal shunt and a ventriculoperitoneal shunt should be carefully evaluated.
1. Indications for Each Procedure:
- Lumboperitoneal Shunt: This may be recommended if there are concerns about infection from previous VP shunt placements or if the anatomy of the peritoneal cavity is compromised. It is less invasive and may have a lower risk of complications related to the brain.

- Ventriculoperitoneal Shunt: This is generally preferred for most cases of hydrocephalus unless contraindicated. It effectively reduces intracranial pressure and can alleviate symptoms related to hydrocephalus.

2. Risks and Complications:
- Lumboperitoneal Shunt: Risks include infection, CSF leakage, and potential for inadequate drainage if the CSF absorption is poor. The likelihood of absorption issues can vary based on the patient's overall health and any previous abdominal surgeries.

- Ventriculoperitoneal Shunt: Risks include infection, shunt malfunction, and over-drainage, which can lead to subdural hematomas. Long-term complications may also include shunt blockage or the need for revision surgery.

3. Prognosis and Recovery:
- The symptoms your father-in-law is experiencing, such as irritability, sleepiness, and cognitive decline, may improve post-surgery, particularly if the hydrocephalus is effectively managed. However, the extent of recovery can depend on several factors, including the duration of symptoms prior to treatment, his overall health, and any underlying neurological conditions.

Conclusion
In making a decision, it is crucial to have a thorough discussion with the medical team regarding the potential benefits and risks of each surgical option. It may also be helpful to seek a second opinion from a neurosurgeon who specializes in treating hydrocephalus in elderly patients. Ultimately, the goal is to improve your father-in-law's quality of life and functional abilities while minimizing the risks associated with surgery. Regular follow-up and monitoring will be essential to assess the effectiveness of the chosen treatment and make any necessary adjustments.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Hydrocephalus: Treatment Options for Severe Cases in Elderly Patients

My mother is 84 years old. In early May of this year, she underwent surgery for a brain hemorrhage at Shin Kong Hospital. After being discharged, she had a urinary catheter in place, was conscious, and could still be fed. However, by mid-May, she began to exhibit signs of a gaze ...

Dr. Zhang Junwei reply Neurosurgery
Without a detailed physical examination and imaging reports, it is not possible to answer such questions online. It is recommended to consult a neurosurgery outpatient clinic for evaluation.

Understanding Hydrocephalus in the Elderly: Symptoms and Treatment Options

Hello, Doctor. My father (83 years old) was diagnosed with hydrocephalus last year, but during the New Year period, he exhibited symptoms such as reversed sleep-wake cycles, irritability, and delusions. Could you please tell me if hydrocephalus can be associated with dementia sym...

Dr. Peng Shiwei reply Neurology
The clinical manifestations of normal pressure hydrocephalus, in addition to gait instability, often include mild dementia and urinary incontinence. Early diagnosis of normal pressure hydrocephalus and prompt drainage of cerebrospinal fluid can significantly improve the patient&#...

Understanding Hydrocephalus in Elderly Patients: Is There No Treatment?

Dr. Ding, I would like to inquire: My father is 86 years old and has been diagnosed with hydrocephalus. However, the doctor mentioned that this is due to age-related brain degeneration causing spaces that lead to fluid accumulation. There is no medication available, and surgery i...

Dr. Ding Xianwei reply Neurosurgery
We apologize, but we need a CT scan and the patient's current condition in order to make a judgment. We recommend that you bring the information to our outpatient clinic for further discussion.

Alternative Treatments for Meningioma Surgery Complications: Hydrocephalus Insights

Hello, my mother is 67 years old and started experiencing urinary incontinence, facial drooping, unsteady walking leading to frequent falls, and difficulty swallowing liquids since last year. After undergoing examinations at the hospital, a 5 cm meningioma was discovered, with no...

Dr. Ding Xianwei reply Neurosurgery
I sincerely apologize, but without knowing the exact location of the meningioma and the overall condition, I am unable to provide much advice regarding your mother's treatment. Generally speaking, surgery is the best option for brain tumors when feasible. However, for certai...