Concerns About Multiple Panoramic X-Rays and Thyroid Cancer Risk - Dentistry

Share to:

A panoramic X-ray should be performed during each evaluation?


I had a panoramic X-ray taken in March 2021 (while wearing a protective apron), and the doctor recommended orthodontic treatment to close the gap from my missing tooth.
Then in April, I had panoramic X-rays taken on two consecutive days (the second clinic said the dosage was low, so there was no need for concern about consecutive exposure, but I later found online that there is still a risk of thyroid cancer).
Each clinic only accepted their own X-rays and did not accept images from other clinics.
On April 6, one clinic took a panoramic X-ray without having me wear a protective apron, stating that they only required protection for smaller films and that it was not necessary for panoramic X-rays.
They suggested a dental bridge as the treatment option.
On April 7, another clinic took a panoramic X-ray (while I was wearing a protective apron) and recommended dental implants as the treatment option.
After visiting three clinics, I found that the most suitable treatment options for my missing tooth were three different plans, which made me feel that having multiple panoramic X-rays did not lead to a consolidated plan that was best for me.
Additionally, the inconsistency in wearing protective aprons was concerning.

Furthermore, any subsequent localized orthodontic treatment, whether it leads to a dental bridge or an implant, would require additional X-rays with higher doses.
No one clearly explained whether my wisdom teeth could be extracted; one clinic outright said they would not extract them and advised me to go to another clinic for that before they could assist with the implant.
This situation makes me anxious that if I go to another clinic for wisdom tooth extraction, I will likely need to have another panoramic X-ray taken.
Is it really acceptable to have so many X-rays within a year? Could this increase my risk of thyroid cancer, especially since each clinic claims their panoramic X-ray dosage is low and does not accept images from other clinics?
I feel uneasy about having undergone so many X-rays for just one missing tooth.
Should I wait until next year to address the missing tooth? I am also concerned whether the "consecutive two-day imaging (with one day without a protective apron)" might have already caused harm.
Is there anything I should eat or drink to help protect my body? Thank you.

Mami, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2021/04/07

Dr. Lin Jiayong reply Dentistry


Hello: The radiation dose from dental X-rays is indeed very low, and it is common practice to take X-rays prior to treatment at a new clinic to avoid disputes.
What you mentioned is standard procedure in dentistry.
If you are concerned about the risk of cancer, you can strongly request to wear a protective apron.
If you prefer not to have another X-ray taken, you can request the X-rays taken by the clinic and bring them to the next clinic for consultation on your treatment plan.
Whether there is any harm cannot be definitively answered at this time; it can only be monitored and followed up.
If you are in poor health or have a systemic disease, it is advisable to seek treatment at a medical center for greater peace of mind.
This is a response from Lin Chia-Yung, Department of Dentistry, Taichung Hospital, Ministry of Health and Welfare.

Reply Date: 2021/04/07

More Info


Your concerns about the potential risks associated with multiple panoramic X-rays and their connection to thyroid cancer are understandable, especially given the frequency and circumstances of your imaging procedures. Let's break down the information regarding radiation exposure, its associated risks, and some recommendations for your situation.


Understanding Radiation Exposure from X-Rays
X-rays are a form of ionizing radiation, which means they have enough energy to remove tightly bound electrons from atoms, potentially leading to cellular damage. However, the amount of radiation exposure from dental X-rays, including panoramic X-rays, is relatively low. For example, a single panoramic X-ray typically delivers a dose of about 0.01 to 0.02 millisieverts (mSv). In comparison, a single chest X-ray delivers about 0.1 mSv, while a CT scan of the abdomen can deliver around 10 mSv.


Cumulative Radiation and Cancer Risk
The risk of developing cancer from radiation exposure is cumulative, meaning that repeated exposures can increase the risk over time. However, the risk associated with dental X-rays is generally considered to be very low. According to the American Dental Association and other health organizations, the risk of developing cancer from dental X-rays is significantly outweighed by the benefits of diagnosing and treating dental issues.

For context, studies suggest that the additional cancer risk from a single dental X-ray is extremely small, often compared to the risk of winning a small lottery. The risk of thyroid cancer specifically from dental X-rays is not well-established, but it is generally accepted that the risk is minimal, especially when proper protective measures, such as lead aprons, are used.


Your Specific Situation
In your case, you mentioned having multiple panoramic X-rays over a short period, with some taken without protective gear. While it is advisable to wear protective clothing during X-ray procedures, the absence of a lead apron for a single session is unlikely to result in significant harm. The cumulative dose from the X-rays you've described is still within a range that is generally considered safe.

However, if you are feeling anxious about the number of X-rays you've had, it may be beneficial to discuss your concerns with your dentist or healthcare provider. They can provide reassurance and help you understand the necessity of each imaging procedure. If you feel that the frequency of X-rays is excessive, you might consider seeking a second opinion or discussing alternative diagnostic methods that involve less radiation, such as ultrasound or MRI, where applicable.


Recommendations for Your Health
1. Discuss with Your Dentist: Have an open conversation about your concerns regarding radiation exposure and the necessity of additional X-rays. They can explain the rationale behind each imaging decision and help you weigh the risks and benefits.

2. Consider Timing: If you feel overwhelmed by the number of procedures, it might be reasonable to delay non-urgent dental work until you feel more comfortable.

3. Healthy Lifestyle: While there is no specific food or drink that can "protect" you from radiation exposure, maintaining a healthy lifestyle can support your overall well-being. A balanced diet rich in antioxidants (fruits, vegetables, whole grains) can help your body repair itself and maintain good health.

4. Regular Check-Ups: Continue to have regular dental check-ups to monitor your oral health, but feel empowered to ask questions and express your concerns about any recommended imaging.

In conclusion, while it is important to be mindful of radiation exposure, the risk associated with the number of dental X-rays you've had is likely very low. Open communication with your healthcare providers can help alleviate your concerns and ensure that you receive the best care possible.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Dental X-Rays: Risks, Safety, and Alternatives

Hello Dr. Chang, I would like to ask you about the recent report regarding a study from the UK that suggests patients who undergo dental X-rays more than ten times have a significantly higher risk of developing thyroid cancer compared to the general population. How credible is ...


Dr. Zhang Fudi reply Radiology
Hello John: The thyroid gland is located in the center of the neck, in front of the trachea, and is considered a relatively superficial organ. Additionally, the thyroid is more sensitive to radiation compared to other tissues in the body. If dental treatment requires multiple X-r...

[Read More] Understanding Dental X-Rays: Risks, Safety, and Alternatives


Should You Worry About Radiation Exposure from Recent Medical Imaging?

Hello: In January of this year, I had a CT scan of my head due to stones found during a tonsil examination. In April, I had a dental X-ray of my front teeth (not a full mouth series). Should I be concerned about the radiation exposure from these procedures? I had a thyroid nodule...


Dr. Wang Yifen reply Radiology
According to the website supported by the American Society of Radiologic Technologists, the radiation dose from a single head CT scan is approximately 2 millisieverts (mSv), while a single dental X-ray has a radiation dose of about 0.005 mSv. Therefore, the total radiation dose f...

[Read More] Should You Worry About Radiation Exposure from Recent Medical Imaging?


The Impact of Neck X-rays on Thyroid Health: What You Need to Know

I have heard that the thyroid gland is more sensitive to X-rays. Previously, when I had a neck X-ray, it was directly aimed at my neck, and I am a bit concerned about whether my thyroid might have issues in the future.


Dr. Wang Yifen reply Radiology
Hello, according to the International Commission on Radiological Protection (ICRP) report 103, doses below 100 millisieverts (including single or multiple exposures) do not cause clinically significant functional impairment. Following your doctor's instructions for radiation...

[Read More] The Impact of Neck X-rays on Thyroid Health: What You Need to Know


Concerns About Excessive X-Ray Exposure: What You Need to Know

Hello Doctor: Earlier this year, around February, I started experiencing frequent shoulder and neck pain, feeling uncomfortable no matter how I lay down. I suspected it might be related to my cervical spine or vertebrae. I consulted an orthopedic doctor who ordered X-rays: one la...


Dr. Sun Shengyi reply Radiology
Ms. Liang underwent a total of six spinal X-rays. The lumbar spine images had a higher dose, with two lateral views approximately 1.5 mSv (millisieverts), while the cervical spine images totaled about 1.0 mSv for four views. Currently, the equipment is very effective in controlli...

[Read More] Concerns About Excessive X-Ray Exposure: What You Need to Know


Related FAQ

Oral Tumor

(Dentistry)

Papillary Thyroid Carcinoma

(Breast and Thyroid)

Hyperthyroidism

(Breast and Thyroid)

Bruxism

(Dentistry)

Oral

(Dentistry)

Halitosis

(Dentistry)

Breast Calcification

(Breast and Thyroid)

Breast Examination

(Breast and Thyroid)

Malocclusion

(Dentistry)

Pain

(Dentistry)