Should I undergo surgery for an anal fistula?
Dr.
Ke: Hello! The physician at the outpatient clinic told me I have an anal fistula.
Initially, it resolved after a week of antibiotics, but after some time, it became swollen again.
I went back to see the doctor, who said that surgery was necessary for the fistula.
However, since it was not a convenient time for me, the doctor suggested I continue with antibiotics.
I took them for a week and returned for a follow-up today, which is the second week.
I was prepared to schedule surgery with the doctor, but today the doctor examined me and said that the fistula is not prominent right now, so surgery is not needed at this time.
I mentioned to the doctor that I can still feel a small lump when I stand.
However, the doctor said that since the fistula is not obvious, surgery cannot be performed, and I do not need to continue taking antibiotics.
Should I go ahead with surgery or wait until it swells up again and then have the surgery without taking antibiotics? Or should I continue with antibiotic treatment until it proves ineffective and then proceed with surgery? I'm a bit confused.
I just had my gallbladder removed three weeks ago, and the gastroenterologist said that surgeries should ideally be performed when there is no inflammation, right? Should the fistula surgery wait until it is swollen? Thank you!
Liu Xiansheng, 50~59 year old female. Ask Date: 2021/08/09
Dr. Ke Fangxu reply Surgery
An anal fistula does not necessarily need to be surgically treated only during an acute infection; in fact, surgery may result in a quicker recovery when there is no infection present.
If the previous diagnosis is confirmed to be accurate, surgery can be performed at this time.
Reply Date: 2021/08/09
More Info
When considering surgery for an anal fistula, it's essential to understand the nature of the condition, the treatment options available, and the timing of surgical intervention. An anal fistula is an abnormal connection between the anal canal and the skin surrounding the anus, often resulting from an infection in the anal glands that leads to the formation of an abscess.
In your case, it seems that you initially experienced symptoms that were alleviated with antibiotics, but the fistula reappeared, indicating that while antibiotics can help manage symptoms, they do not resolve the underlying issue. The fact that your physician noted the fistula was not currently visible may suggest that it is in a dormant state, but this does not mean it has resolved completely.
Surgery is often recommended for anal fistulas because it is the most effective way to ensure complete healing and prevent recurrence. The timing of surgery is crucial; ideally, it should be performed when the fistula is not inflamed or infected. This is because performing surgery on an inflamed fistula can lead to complications, such as increased pain, prolonged healing time, and a higher risk of recurrence.
Your physician's decision to postpone surgery until the fistula is more pronounced may be based on the current assessment that the risks of surgery outweigh the benefits at this moment. However, if you continue to experience discomfort or if the fistula becomes more pronounced, it may be necessary to revisit the option of surgery.
It's also important to note that while antibiotics can help manage infections, they are not a long-term solution for a fistula. If the fistula becomes symptomatic again, it may be wise to consult your physician about scheduling surgery rather than relying solely on antibiotics.
In summary, the decision to proceed with surgery for an anal fistula should be based on the following considerations:
1. Current Symptoms: If you are experiencing discomfort or if the fistula becomes inflamed again, it may be time to reconsider surgical intervention.
2. Timing of Surgery: Ideally, surgery should be performed when the fistula is not inflamed to minimize complications and promote healing.
3. Consultation with Your Physician: Keep an open line of communication with your healthcare provider. Discuss your concerns and the possibility of surgery if symptoms persist or worsen.
4. Understanding the Condition: Educate yourself about anal fistulas and the surgical options available. This knowledge can empower you to make informed decisions about your treatment.
In conclusion, while antibiotics can provide temporary relief, they do not cure the underlying problem of an anal fistula. Surgery is often the best long-term solution, and the timing of that surgery is critical to ensure the best outcomes. If you have further questions or concerns, do not hesitate to reach out to your healthcare provider for personalized advice and guidance.
Similar Q&A
Understanding Anal Fistulas: Should You Consider Surgery or Manage Symptoms?
The current situation is that about a year and a half ago, I had an anal abscess, which caused severe pain and made it difficult to sit or stand. After consulting with a physician, I took antibiotics, and after the abscess ruptured and drained blood and pus, the pain subsided. Sh...
Dr. Ke Fangxu reply Surgery
I also believe that the first hospital is a scam. For young people with simple fistulas, I recommend surgery as a better option; otherwise, there is a risk that it could develop into a complex fistula over the next 50 years. If surgery is not desired, monitoring the condition is ...[Read More] Understanding Anal Fistulas: Should You Consider Surgery or Manage Symptoms?
Understanding Anal Fistula Surgery: Risks and Anesthesia Options Explained
Dr. Gao has diagnosed an anal fistula and recommends surgery. I would like to ask: 1. What are the risks associated with this surgery? 2. The doctor advocates for general anesthesia, but my research indicates that spinal or local anesthesia is commonly used. Is there a significan...
Dr. Hou Yongji reply Surgery
1. Anorectal surgeries (such as hemorrhoidectomy or fistulotomy) are generally considered minor procedures; however, due to the involvement of structures that control bowel function, careful attention to anatomical details is essential. Therefore, it is advisable to seek treatmen...[Read More] Understanding Anal Fistula Surgery: Risks and Anesthesia Options Explained
Understanding Risks of Anal Fistula Surgery: What You Need to Know
Hello Doctor, I was diagnosed with an anal fistula around October this year. However, I have been quite busy during the semester and plan to have the surgery during the winter break. I would like to ask if the surgery to remove the anal fistula carries a significant risk of fecal...
Dr. Ke Fangxu reply Surgery
Surgery for anal fistulas does not cause incontinence; this is a misconception that has been perpetuated over time. If a simple fistula is not treated, it may worsen into a complex fistula, which most physicians are reluctant to manage. Complete healing of the surgical wound typi...[Read More] Understanding Risks of Anal Fistula Surgery: What You Need to Know
Understanding the Necessity of Fistula Surgery: A Patient's Perspective
Previously, I experienced severe anal itching and visited a proctology clinic before the end of December. The doctor diagnosed me with a fistula but mentioned that my condition was relatively mild (seemingly very minor) and only prescribed anti-inflammatory medication. I was advi...
Dr. Ke Fangxu reply Surgery
The anal fistula indeed requires surgical excision for a complete cure; however, this type of surgery cannot be performed in a clinic and must be done in a hospital by a specialist under anesthesia. Therefore, please first visit a colorectal surgery outpatient clinic for a physic...[Read More] Understanding the Necessity of Fistula Surgery: A Patient's Perspective
Related FAQ
(Surgery)
Post-Anal Fistula Surgery(Surgery)
Fistula Surgery(Surgery)
Anal Prolapse(Surgery)
Rectovaginal Fistula(Surgery)
Chronic Anal Fissure(Surgery)
Anal Sex(Surgery)
Anal Abscess(Surgery)
Anal Lump(Surgery)
Anal Bleeding(Surgery)