The accuracy issues of computer-based vision testing?
Hello Doctor, thank you for your response! I took my child to the ophthalmology clinic for an examination, where they performed a fundus examination, OCT, and slit lamp examination.
I informed the clinic doctor about my child's eye condition, and after the examination, the doctor concluded that the eyes were stable and normal.
However, there was still no conclusion regarding the appearance of shadows, and it was suggested that it might be caused by the dilating drops.
1.
I would like to ask if such a condition could be caused by the cornea, such as keratoconus.
It seems that astigmatism is not easily increased, but this time it increased by 25 degrees, and myopia increased by 75 degrees in just two months.
Could this be an early symptom of keratoconus? What tests should be done to rule out keratoconus?
2.
Later, due to the increase in prescription, I went to an optical shop to get new glasses.
I found that during the previous examination at the clinic (using the E chart), the corrected vision for both eyes was between 0.9-1.0 (I have been monitoring for a year and a half).
However, this time at the optical shop, the owner used a numerical vision chart, and the corrected vision for my child was less than 0.8, at most 0.7.
The owner mentioned a possibility of amblyopia.
My child is now 8 years old; is there still a chance for correction?
3.
Could the underlying cause of the shadow in the eye be responsible for the decrease in vision? Thank you, Doctor, for your patience in answering many questions! I have been monitoring my child's eye condition for a year and a half and have noticed many issues! I really appreciate your thorough responses, thank you!
Response from Dr.
Gao Pi-Lin, Ophthalmology:
Hello,
1.
You can perform a corneal topography, but mild astigmatism is less likely to be the cause.
2.
Since the previous vision was 0.9-1.0, there is still a possibility of recovery, but it is essential to wear the correct glasses.
Sometimes, dilation can also affect vision.
3.
This is unclear.
If you do not want to use dilation drops, you may consider wearing orthokeratology lenses, which can help control myopia and astigmatism.
--------------------------------------------
Doctor, I apologize for the trouble.
My child is 8 years old and has been using a low-dose 0.125% dilating agent in both eyes.
Previously, due to the issue of shadows in my child's eyes, we visited a new clinic where the computer refraction (without additional dilation drops) showed right eye -2.50 with astigmatism 2.25, and left eye -1.00 with astigmatism 2.25.
The next day, when I went to the optical shop for new glasses, the computer refraction results were right eye -2.50 with astigmatism 2.00, and left eye -0.75 with astigmatism 2.50.
Both places conducted the refraction at 3 PM.
However, today, when I visited the original clinic for follow-up, the computer refraction (without additional dilation drops) showed right eye +0.50 with astigmatism 2.50, and left eye -1.00 with astigmatism 2.25, which was done at 12 PM.
1.
May I ask, since my child is using a long-acting 0.125% dilating agent every night, does this mean that additional dilation drops are needed during the refraction?
2.
Among these three refraction results, which one is more accurate? Since my child is considering orthokeratology lenses, the left eye results are similar, but the right eye varies significantly from +0.50 to -2.50.
Could this lead to over-correction or under-correction issues?
3.
Is this discrepancy due to the different measurement times affecting the efficacy of the dilating drops? I understand that there will be some variability in computer refraction results, but since my child needs orthokeratology lenses and the right eye has a significant difference in myopia, I am concerned about potential adverse outcomes.
Thank you for your assistance!
Xiao Wu, 0~9 year old female. Ask Date: 2021/10/07
Dr. Gao Pilin reply Ophthalmology
Hello, regarding your questions: 1.
If the pupils are dilated and do not respond to light, there is no need to administer drops.
2.
The refractive error is quite similar; the equivalent spherical power calculated from the right eye +50 astigmatism -250 and -25 astigmatism -200 is actually comparable.
There shouldn't be significant issues with the orthokeratology lenses.
There may be some variability due to differences in the machines.
Reply Date: 2021/10/07
More Info
Understanding the accuracy of computerized eye exams for children is crucial, especially given the complexities involved in pediatric eye care. Children’s eyes are still developing, and their refractive errors can change rapidly. Here’s a comprehensive look at the issues raised in your questions.
1. Corneal Issues and Keratoconus: The concern about whether the child’s symptoms, such as increased astigmatism and myopia, could be indicative of keratoconus is valid. Keratoconus is a progressive condition where the cornea thins and bulges into a cone shape, leading to distorted vision. While increased astigmatism can be a sign of keratoconus, it is not the only cause. The increase in astigmatism by 25 degrees and myopia by 75 degrees over two months is significant and warrants further investigation. To rule out keratoconus, a corneal topography test is recommended. This test provides a detailed map of the cornea's shape and can help identify any irregularities characteristic of keratoconus.
2. Variability in Vision Testing: The discrepancies in vision test results from different locations can be attributed to several factors, including the equipment used, the testing conditions, and the child's cooperation during the exam. The fact that the child’s vision was recorded as 0.9-1.0 in one setting and below 0.8 in another suggests that the testing conditions may have varied. It’s essential to ensure that the child is comfortable and cooperative during the exam, as stress or fatigue can affect results. If the child has been diagnosed with amblyopia (commonly referred to as "lazy eye"), there is still potential for improvement, especially at the age of 8. Treatment options may include corrective lenses, patching therapy, or vision therapy, depending on the severity of the condition.
3. Impact of the Black Shadow: The appearance of black shadows in the child’s vision could be related to several factors, including the effects of the dilating drops used during the exam. These drops can temporarily alter vision and may cause visual disturbances. However, if the shadows persist, further evaluation is necessary to rule out any underlying retinal issues or other ocular conditions. It’s crucial to monitor these symptoms closely and report any changes to the eye care provider.
4. Use of Cycloplegic Drops: Regarding the use of cycloplegic drops (like the 0.125% solution mentioned), these are typically used to temporarily paralyze the ciliary muscle, allowing for a more accurate measurement of refractive error. If the child is already using these drops regularly, additional drops may not be necessary for routine exams, but this should be confirmed with the eye care provider.
5. Accuracy of Measurements: The variations in the refractive measurements you provided indicate that there may be inconsistencies in how the tests were conducted or interpreted. The right eye's readings, in particular, show a significant fluctuation, which could lead to over-correction or under-correction if not addressed properly. It’s essential to have a comprehensive eye exam, including cycloplegic refraction, to obtain the most accurate prescription for corrective lenses.
In conclusion, computerized eye exams can provide valuable information, but they are not infallible. The variability in results underscores the importance of comprehensive eye examinations conducted by experienced professionals. Regular follow-ups and appropriate testing are key to ensuring the child’s visual health and addressing any concerns promptly. If there are ongoing issues or uncertainties, seeking a second opinion from a pediatric ophthalmologist may also be beneficial.
Similar Q&A
Essential Vision Screening for Toddlers: What Parents Need to Know
Hello, Doctor. I saw in the news that children should have their first vision screening by the age of three, so I took my child to an ophthalmologist this morning. My child just turned three and was not very cooperative, so we only performed a computer-based vision test (I told h...
Dr. Gao Pilin reply Ophthalmology
Hello Wendy: For a three-year-old child, it is important to first teach them to recognize the vision chart before assessing their eyesight. The results of vision tests for three-year-olds can vary significantly, sometimes by several diopters. To obtain an accurate measurement, cy...[Read More] Essential Vision Screening for Toddlers: What Parents Need to Know
Understanding Discrepancies in Children's Vision Test Results
Hello Doctor, my child is currently nine years old. Yesterday, at a large hospital, a vision test was conducted, and the nurse recorded a visual acuity of 0.3 with a refraction of approximately -1.00 diopters and -1.25 diopters (with astigmatism). After administering a cycloplegi...
Dr. Cai Wenyuan reply Ophthalmology
Hello, the data from the eye examination (prior to dilation) can indeed vary. It is important to pay attention to children's eye habits and to conduct regular follow-ups. Wishing you safety and health. Sincerely, Dr. Tsai Wen-Yuan, Director of Ophthalmology, Taoyuan General ...[Read More] Understanding Discrepancies in Children's Vision Test Results
Understanding Poor Vision in Children: Essential Tests to Consider
The child's vision test showed both eyes at 0.2, but the clinic measured myopia and astigmatism as -25/-25 in the right eye and -75/-25 in the left eye. Even with corrective lenses, there was no improvement in vision. The clinic physician indicated that the poor vision is no...
Dr. Cai Wenyuan reply Ophthalmology
At least include a dilated fundus examination and retinal examination.[Read More] Understanding Poor Vision in Children: Essential Tests to Consider
Understanding Amblyopia in Children: Seeking Clarity on Vision Issues
A 5-year-old child underwent a vision examination and was found to have a visual acuity of 0.8 in both eyes, along with hyperopia of +2.75 diopters and astigmatism of -1.00 diopters. Two general ophthalmologists diagnosed the child with amblyopia, although one mentioned that the ...
Dr. Cai Wenyuan reply Ophthalmology
Hello, it is not surprising to have different opinions due to being on the fringe. In my view, if the data is accurate, I still recommend corrective lenses as a precaution. Wishing you safety and health. Sincerely, Dr. Tsai Wen-Yuan, Director of the Ophthalmology Department, Taoy...[Read More] Understanding Amblyopia in Children: Seeking Clarity on Vision Issues
Related FAQ
(Ophthalmology)
Eye(Pediatrics)
Fundus Examination(Ophthalmology)
Amblyopia(Ophthalmology)
Vision Discrepancy(Ophthalmology)
Visual Field Test(Ophthalmology)
Nearsightedness(Ophthalmology)
Refraction Test(Ophthalmology)
Eyes(Family Medicine)
Pupil(Ophthalmology)