Can Brain Imaging Tools Help Diagnose Mental Health Symptoms?

Q: Can Brain Imaging Tools Help Diagnose Mental Health Symptoms?

Hello everyone： I answered your questions in person during the follow-up appointment yesterday (February 24)! Dr. <br>Wu En-Liang

Is there an imaging device in peach therapy that can directly determine the type of symptoms in the brain?

As per the inquiry, if there is a possibility, can it be done? I sincerely request your assistance in determining (2) the severe disability assessment - I really appreciate your help: Two weeks ago, during the evaluation by the social worker, my brother mostly indicated that he is at a moderate level.
Does that mean we must only rely on his self-report? He feels fine and previously had no intention of seeing a doctor, despite prolonged persuasion.
Is his subjective awareness only a reference point? Over two years ago, he was assessed as moderate at Songde, and after discharge, he was unable to attend the referral to the occupational workshop.
Not long after, he relapsed and began taking the sleeping medication prescribed at home, increasing the dosage over time, and his personality became increasingly violent.
He showed no respect for his grandmother's home, repeatedly losing control and damaging household items and appliances, ultimately culminating in a tragic incident where he severely assaulted our mother, nearly resulting in death.
Over these two years, I have observed a worsening condition, exacerbated by the increased intake of sleeping pills.
In late November last year, a diagnosis from Xinguang indicated signs of brain injury and degeneration, which led them to suggest the guardianship under the Mental Competence Protection Act and advised me to seek a reassessment for severe disability at Chang Gung.
However, my brother consistently lacks insight into his condition.
During the last consultation on February 10, he expressed that he does not believe he needs to take Lian Da, preferring to continue with the sleeping medication, Guanshi.
The social worker mentioned that ultimately, it will return to your assessment; she is only responsible for the second phase, filling out the forms based on my brother's responses.
Therefore, could I request you to objectively determine if he has reached the severe level (with deterioration in occupational and social functioning, requiring long-term psychiatric rehabilitation treatment to maintain the most basic self-care abilities in daily life, and needing a guardian)? For moderate level: (development of work capabilities in sheltered employment).
Three years ago, after the diagnosis by the doctor at Songde, a referral to Xinglong Workshop was written before his discharge, believing he could attend the workshop.
After three years of observation, he has never stepped into this sheltered employment path, and the situation appears to be worsening.
Currently, due to the supervision and medication management by Kangjia, his life is relatively stable; without Kangjia, everything would likely fall apart, and he would stop seeing doctors altogether.

Azuo, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2022/02/24

Dr. Wu Enliang reply Psychiatry

Hello everyone: I answered your questions in person during the follow-up appointment yesterday (February 24)! Dr.
Wu En-Liang

Reply Date: 2022/02/24

More Info

Brain imaging tools, such as MRI (Magnetic Resonance Imaging) and PET (Positron Emission Tomography), can indeed play a role in the assessment of mental health symptoms, although their utility varies depending on the specific condition being evaluated. These imaging techniques can provide valuable insights into brain structure and function, which may help in diagnosing certain mental health disorders.

MRI is particularly useful for examining the structural aspects of the brain. It can identify abnormalities such as tumors, lesions, or structural changes associated with conditions like schizophrenia, depression, and anxiety disorders. For instance, studies have shown that individuals with schizophrenia may exhibit changes in brain volume or alterations in specific brain regions, which can be detected through MRI scans. However, it is important to note that while MRI can reveal structural abnormalities, it does not directly diagnose mental health disorders. Instead, it serves as a complementary tool alongside clinical assessments and psychological evaluations.

On the other hand, PET scans provide insights into brain metabolism and activity. They can help visualize how different areas of the brain function in real-time by tracking the distribution of radioactive tracers that bind to specific receptors or metabolic processes. This can be particularly useful in understanding conditions like depression, where altered brain metabolism may be observed. However, PET scans are more commonly used in research settings rather than routine clinical practice due to their high cost and the need for specialized equipment.

In the context of your brother's situation, it seems that there are significant concerns regarding his mental health and behavior. The history of violent behavior, substance misuse (in this case, overuse of sleep medications), and the lack of insight into his condition are critical factors that need to be addressed. While imaging studies may provide additional information about any underlying brain changes, they should not be the sole basis for determining the severity of his mental health condition.

The assessment of mental health disorders often relies heavily on clinical evaluations, including interviews with the patient, observations of behavior, and input from family members or caregivers. In your brother's case, the social worker's assessment of his condition as moderate may reflect their observations and interactions with him. However, it is essential to consider the broader context of his behavior and history, including the escalation of violent incidents and the impact on his daily functioning.

For the purpose of disability evaluation or determining the need for long-term care, a comprehensive assessment that includes both clinical evaluations and any relevant imaging studies may be beneficial. It is crucial to work closely with mental health professionals who can provide an objective assessment of your brother's condition and recommend appropriate interventions. This may include therapy, medication management, and support for daily living skills.

In summary, while brain imaging tools can provide valuable information regarding brain structure and function, they should be used in conjunction with thorough clinical assessments to diagnose and evaluate mental health conditions. In your brother's case, it may be beneficial to pursue a comprehensive evaluation that considers both his clinical history and any potential imaging studies to better understand his mental health needs and determine the appropriate level of care.

Similar Q&A

The Role of SPECT and PET Scans in Treating Mental Illness

Hello Dr. Chang Che-Hung! I have read several books on mental disorders, and they mention that standard EEG and CT scans are not helpful in the treatment of psychiatric illnesses. Only PET and SPECT scans can provide insights. However, PET and SPECT are not covered by health insu...

Dr. Zhang Zhehong reply Psychiatry
SPECT and PET scans can be used to study the effects of drugs on brain receptor changes, which is helpful for understanding brain function, psychiatric symptoms, and new drug development. However, they are expensive. The concentration of drugs in the blood is currently a commonly...

Can Brain Perfusion CT Detect Schizophrenia and Other Mental Disorders?

I was diagnosed with suspected atypical schizophrenia in the psychiatric department, and then I was referred to the neurology department. The neurologist arranged for me to undergo a brain CT scan. I would like to know if a brain CT scan (perfusion imaging) can detect schizophren...

Dr. Wu Enliang reply Psychiatry
Online users have noted that this examination cannot detect schizophrenia, but it can identify other brain lesions. A brain perfusion CT scan utilizes lipophilic tracers that can penetrate the blood-brain barrier, allowing assessment of blood flow perfusion in the frontal lobe, p...

How Sensory Perception Affects Thoughts in Neurological Disorders

If you are experiencing symptoms such as feeling that your thoughts are affecting your emotions when looking around, having a foreign body sensation in your forehead, and noticing that the information you receive influences your thoughts, it is advisable to consult a neurologist....

Dr. Jiang Junyi reply Neurology
Hello: Schizophrenia may be caused by dysfunction in brain activity. Since most patients with schizophrenia develop symptoms under stress, psychological stress may be a trigger for this condition. The exact cause of schizophrenia has not yet been determined, but it is believed to...

Comparing MRI and NIRS for Brain Health in Schizophrenia Patients

Hello, doctor. I have been diagnosed with unspecified psychotic disorder and have been on medication for two years. Recently, I would like to get my brain checked for any degeneration. I would like to know which examination, MRI or NIRS, would provide clearer information. Since s...

Dr. Xue Gengming reply Psychiatry
It is advisable for you to consult with your attending physician regarding the above situation. Thank you, and wishing you good health!