Surgery Options for Carpal Tunnel Syndrome: What You Need to Know - Neurosurgery

Share to:

Surgical Issues in Carpal Tunnel Syndrome


Consulting a physician: If I have carpal tunnel syndrome but the symptoms are not yet severe (such as muscle atrophy, instability when holding objects, etc.), can I consider surgery? Both of my hands are affected (last year, nerve conduction studies showed 4.1 and 4.9).
I originally planned to have surgery last year, but after seeing that recovery takes a long time, I hesitated.
Is it possible to operate on both hands at once? Sometimes my hands are very numb, sometimes not at all; sometimes they are numb when I wake up in the morning, other times I wake up at night due to numbness, and sometimes it happens at any time, anywhere.
(My profession is a chef, and I need to handle knives frequently; usually, after a short time of using a knife, my hands start to feel numb.
Not to mention when I need to chop ingredients with bones, which directly impacts the median nerve… it makes me afraid to chop anything.) I found information online about traditional, endoscopic, and minimally invasive surgeries.
I am not considering traditional surgery due to the long recovery time.
Currently, I am considering endoscopic and minimally invasive surgery.
After endoscopic surgery, I understand I need at least one month of rest, but I am unsure how long it will take to return to work after minimally invasive surgery.
Other hospitals' websites say it takes 5 to 10 days for complete recovery, but they do not specify how long until I can return to work.

Ling Er, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2022/03/21

Dr. Lai Zhaokang reply Neurosurgery


Hello: Generally, conservative treatment is recommended, which includes adequate wrist rest, medication, physical rehabilitation, heat therapy, and wrist protection.
However, if you do not experience any improvement and nerve conduction studies show abnormalities, surgery can be considered to release the ligament that is compressing the nerve, thereby relieving the pressure on the nerve.
Regardless of whether you use endoscopic or other surgical methods, the size of the incision is not the main concern; the re-healing of the carpal tunnel structure will still take about a month.
Therefore, wrist protection for one month is necessary to avoid vigorous wrist movements.
(Humans are biological beings, and healing takes time, just like pregnancy which requires 9-10 months and cannot be expedited.) Your issue is related to how you use your wrist and the nature of your work, which you need to reflect on.
Best wishes // Dr.
Lai Chao-Kang, Neurosurgery.

Reply Date: 2022/03/21

More Info


When considering surgery options for Carpal Tunnel Syndrome (CTS), it's essential to weigh the severity of your symptoms against the potential benefits and risks of surgical intervention. Carpal Tunnel Syndrome occurs when the median nerve, which runs through the wrist, becomes compressed, leading to symptoms such as numbness, tingling, and weakness in the hand.
From your description, it seems that you are experiencing intermittent symptoms, which may not yet warrant surgical intervention. However, the decision to proceed with surgery often depends on the impact of the symptoms on your daily life and work, especially given your profession as a chef, which requires fine motor skills and the ability to use your hands without discomfort.


Surgical Options for Carpal Tunnel Syndrome
1. Open Carpal Tunnel Release: This is the traditional method where a larger incision is made in the wrist to cut the ligament pressing on the median nerve. Recovery can take several weeks, and you may need to avoid using your hand for a period.

2. Endoscopic Carpal Tunnel Release: This minimally invasive technique involves smaller incisions and the use of a camera to guide the surgery. Recovery time is generally shorter compared to the open method, with many patients returning to normal activities within a week or two. However, full recovery may still take longer, especially for someone in a physically demanding job.

3. Micro-invasive Techniques: These are newer methods that may offer even quicker recovery times, but they are not as widely available and may not be performed by all surgeons.


Considerations Before Surgery
- Severity of Symptoms: If you are experiencing muscle atrophy or significant weakness, surgery may be more strongly indicated. However, if your symptoms are manageable, conservative treatments such as splinting, physical therapy, or corticosteroid injections may be recommended first.

- Bilateral Surgery: While it is technically possible to perform surgery on both hands simultaneously, it is generally not recommended unless absolutely necessary. This is due to the increased recovery demands and the potential for functional limitations during the healing process.

- Recovery Time: For endoscopic and micro-invasive surgeries, many patients report returning to work within 5 to 10 days, but this can vary based on individual healing rates and the physical demands of your job. Given your role as a chef, you may need to consider how much hand use is required and whether you can adapt your work during recovery.


Alternative Treatments
Before opting for surgery, consider exploring non-surgical options such as:
- Wrist Splints: Wearing a splint, especially at night, can help alleviate symptoms by keeping the wrist in a neutral position.

- Activity Modification: Reducing repetitive wrist movements and taking frequent breaks can help manage symptoms.

- Physical Therapy: Engaging in exercises designed to strengthen the wrist and improve flexibility may provide relief.


Conclusion
In summary, while surgery can be an effective solution for Carpal Tunnel Syndrome, it is essential to evaluate the severity of your symptoms and how they impact your daily life. If your symptoms are not significantly affecting your ability to work or perform daily tasks, it may be worth considering conservative management strategies first. However, if you find that your symptoms are worsening or significantly hindering your work as a chef, consulting with a hand specialist to discuss surgical options may be the next best step. Always ensure that you have a thorough discussion with your healthcare provider about the risks, benefits, and expected recovery times associated with each surgical option.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Carpal Tunnel Syndrome: Treatment Options and Recovery

Hello, doctor. I am inquiring on behalf of my mother, who is around 50 years old and has carpal tunnel syndrome. Is it treatable? Are there medications available for treatment? If not, is surgery the only option? After surgery, will there be any side effects? Additionally, how lo...


Dr. Huang Yingzhe reply Neurology
Based on clinical symptoms and nerve conduction/electromyography reports, if the condition is not severe, you may try vitamin B1, vitamin B12, euclidian, or other circulation enhancers. If the pain and numbness are severe, local corticosteroids or anti-inflammatory medications ma...

[Read More] Understanding Carpal Tunnel Syndrome: Treatment Options and Recovery


Understanding Carpal Tunnel Syndrome: Surgery, Recovery, and Risks

Hello Doctor: I was recently diagnosed with carpal tunnel syndrome due to severe numbness in both hands. I underwent nerve conduction studies, which showed 4.1 for the left hand and 4.9 for the right hand, both of which are abnormal. I am currently undergoing rehabilitation but a...


Dr. Zhang Junwei reply Neurosurgery
1. The outpatient surgery is self-funded and typically requires one month of rest. 2. All options are available. 3. Any surgery carries risks.

[Read More] Understanding Carpal Tunnel Syndrome: Surgery, Recovery, and Risks


Understanding Carpal Tunnel Syndrome: Symptoms, Treatments, and Surgery Options

The neurology clinic diagnosed me with carpal tunnel syndrome and treated me with corticosteroids for one week, along with almost daily rehabilitation (including heat therapy, electrical stimulation, and laser therapy). As of my follow-up appointment on September 21, and now on O...


Dr. Zhang Junwei reply Neurosurgery
Based on your description, it seems to be carpal tunnel syndrome. If the outpatient examination confirms this, surgery can quickly resolve your issue!

[Read More] Understanding Carpal Tunnel Syndrome: Symptoms, Treatments, and Surgery Options


Understanding Carpal Tunnel Syndrome Surgery Costs and Insurance Coverage

My sister suddenly underwent surgery for carpal tunnel syndrome. The doctor said that the health insurance does not cover much, and we need to pay 50,000. What should we do? It seems like extortion. Please reply, thank you.


Dr. Xie Bojun reply Neurosurgery
Please discuss the details of the charges with the original surgeon. Thank you!

[Read More] Understanding Carpal Tunnel Syndrome Surgery Costs and Insurance Coverage


Related FAQ

Carpal Tunnel Syndrome

(Neurosurgery)

Carpal Tunnel Syndrome

(Neurology)

Fingers

(Neurosurgery)

Neurofibroma

(Surgery)

Feet

(Neurosurgery)

Severe Palmar Hyperhidrosis

(Neurosurgery)

Nerves

(Neurosurgery)

Palm

(Surgery)

Coccyx

(Neurosurgery)

Trigeminal Neuralgia

(Neurosurgery)