Regarding vaccine efficacy?
Hello Doctor, I am a senior high school student.
I would like to ask: 1) Is the likelihood of experiencing long COVID symptoms after contracting COVID-19 high, meaning that they may never fully resolve? 2) I received my first dose of the BNT vaccine last September, but I have been hesitant to get the second dose because it significantly worsened my ankylosing spondylitis.
I really want to get the second dose like my classmates.
Now that more than six months have passed since last September, if I get the second dose (whether BNT or Moderna), will the increase in antibodies be negligible? Would I need to start over and receive two doses for it to be meaningful? 3) My classmates received their second dose nearly five months ago.
Considering the waning immunity over time, is it possible that while their vaccine protection is still better than mine, the difference is not as significant anymore? 4) Should I be very concerned that having only received one dose of the vaccine means that if I contract COVID-19, my symptoms will be more severe compared to my classmates who received their second dose a long time ago? Thank you, Doctor.
Zhong, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2022/04/18
Dr. Yang Zongyan reply Influenza
1) Is the rate of long COVID symptoms that may never improve high? Regarding long COVID symptoms, since there is currently no long-term data, whether it lasts a lifetime still depends on future studies, as the pandemic has only been ongoing for a few years.
2) I received my first dose of the BNT vaccine last September, but I have been hesitant to get the second dose because it noticeably worsened my ankylosing spondylitis.
I really want to get the second dose like my classmates.
I would like to ask the doctor, since it has been over six months since last September, if getting the second dose now (whether BNT or Moderna) will have a negligible effect on antibody enhancement.
Will I need to restart the two-dose series for it to be meaningful? What is the maximum interval between doses? Dr.
Huang from National Taiwan University mentioned that there isn't enough long-term data on COVID-19 vaccines, but based on studies of the HPV vaccine, where two doses are administered six months apart, research shows that administering the second dose 12 months later actually produces higher antibody levels than two doses given six months apart, indicating that immune memory can last a long time.
However, if BNT is not available now, mixing with Moderna or High-End vaccines is still an option.
3) My classmate received their second dose nearly five months ago.
Given the time decay, is it possible that their vaccine protection, while still better than mine, is not significantly different anymore? The effectiveness of receiving two doses is certainly better than just one, so it is still recommended to complete the two-dose series.
4) Should I be very concerned that having only received one dose of the vaccine means that if I contract COVID-19, it will be more severe than for my classmates who received their second dose a long time ago? No, it is advised to complete the two-dose vaccination series.
Reply Date: 2022/04/18
More Info
As a high school senior, it's understandable to have concerns about COVID-19 vaccines, especially regarding their efficacy and potential long-term effects. Let’s address your questions one by one.
1) Long COVID and its Persistence: Long COVID refers to a range of symptoms that can persist for weeks or months after the initial infection. The exact percentage of individuals who experience long-term effects is still being studied, but research suggests that a significant number of people do report lingering symptoms. However, the severity and duration of these symptoms can vary widely. While some individuals may experience long-term issues, many others recover fully. The ongoing research aims to provide clearer insights into the long-term implications of COVID-19.
2) Timing of the Second Vaccine Dose: You mentioned receiving your first dose of the BNT vaccine (Pfizer-BioNTech) in September and experiencing a worsening of your ankylosing spondylitis, which has understandably made you hesitant to get the second dose. It’s important to note that while the immune response may diminish over time, receiving the second dose is still beneficial. The immune system can still mount a response even after a delay. Current guidelines suggest that if you have not received your second dose within six months, it is advisable to get it, as it will significantly enhance your protection against COVID-19. If you are concerned about your condition, discussing this with your healthcare provider can help you make an informed decision.
3) Vaccine Efficacy Over Time: Your classmates who received their second dose five months ago may have a higher level of protection compared to you, but it’s important to recognize that vaccine efficacy does wane over time. However, studies show that even after some decline, vaccinated individuals still have better protection against severe illness compared to those who are unvaccinated. Therefore, while their protection may decrease, they are still likely to be better protected than someone who has only received one dose.
4) Concerns About COVID-19 Severity: It’s natural to worry about the severity of COVID-19 if you have only received one dose of the vaccine. While it is true that fully vaccinated individuals generally have a lower risk of severe illness, hospitalization, and death from COVID-19, having even one dose of the vaccine still provides some level of protection. However, it is advisable to complete the vaccination series to maximize your immunity. If you do contract COVID-19, being fully vaccinated can help reduce the severity of the disease.
In summary, while concerns about long COVID and vaccine efficacy are valid, the benefits of vaccination—especially completing the two-dose series—far outweigh the risks. Vaccines are designed to enhance your immune response and protect you from severe outcomes. If you have specific health concerns, particularly related to your ankylosing spondylitis, consulting with your healthcare provider is crucial. They can provide personalized advice based on your medical history and current health status. Remember, staying informed and proactive about your health is key to navigating these challenging times.
Similar Q&A
COVID-19 Vaccine Concerns for Young Adults with Health History
Hello Doctor, I would like to inquire about COVID-19 vaccination. I am 22 years old and in March of this year, I was diagnosed with some cysts in my breast (some of which have slight calcification) during a visit to a breast surgeon. The doctor advised me to return for a follow...
Dr. Liao Yaopan reply Family Medicine
Hello, there are currently no specific contraindications for the vaccine for you. It is recommended to complete the vaccination as soon as possible; any brand is a good choice. Online consultations are not equivalent to in-person medical visits and cannot provide diagnoses or tre...[Read More] COVID-19 Vaccine Concerns for Young Adults with Health History
Navigating COVID-19 Vaccination: Concerns About Doses and Future Implications
Hello, Doctor. Currently, the pandemic is severe. Some say that most of the viruses are mild, while the government is very proactive in encouraging the public to get vaccinated, even deciding to move towards administering a fourth dose... I would like to ask, most people have rec...
Dr. Xiao Yongxun reply Family Medicine
Dear Sir/Madam: 1. The current recommendation from the epidemic command center to administer three doses of the COVID-19 vaccine is based on research reports from domestic and international experts and the consensus of top medical and public health professionals in the country....[Read More] Navigating COVID-19 Vaccination: Concerns About Doses and Future Implications
Should Seniors with Health Issues Get the COVID Vaccine?
Hello, Director. My elderly family member is nearly eighty years old. Due to the negative news reported by the media, they previously decided against getting vaccinated. However, after reassessing the situation, they now believe that, given their issues with hypertension, diabete...
Dr. Xiao Yongxun reply Family Medicine
Dear Ms. Mtyofcyc: 1. Patients with hypertension, diabetes, heart disease, liver disease, and other conditions are generally advised to receive the COVID-19 vaccine. This is especially true for males over the age of 65, and those residing in nursing or long-term care facilities ...[Read More] Should Seniors with Health Issues Get the COVID Vaccine?
Measles Vaccine Concerns: Risks for Young Adults and Hospital Visits
Hello, doctor. Recently, the measles outbreak has caused public panic, and young adults in their 20s have been identified as a high-risk group. However, the Ministry of Health and Welfare has urged that vaccines be prioritized for frontline healthcare workers and those in need, w...
Dr. Liao Zhongxin reply Internal Medicine
Dear readers, In response to the sudden increase in demand for the self-paid MMR vaccine, the Centers for Disease Control (CDC) has urged prioritization of vaccination for high-risk groups (CDC Circular No. 351, April 24, 2018). 1. Due to recent public concern regarding the me...[Read More] Measles Vaccine Concerns: Risks for Young Adults and Hospital Visits
Related FAQ
(Influenza)
Covid-19 Vaccine(Pediatrics)
Influenza Vaccine(Otolaryngology)
Vaccination(Pediatrics)
Covid-19 Vaccination(Internal Medicine)
Covid-19 Vaccine(Obstetrics and Gynecology)
Fever(Influenza)
After Covid-19 Vaccination(Cardiology)
Covid-19(Otolaryngology)
Vaccine(Family Medicine)