Pediatric Vision Screening
Hello Dr.
Tsai: My child is nearly 3 years old and underwent a vision test.
The computer refraction indicated astigmatism as high as 400 degrees.
However, during the examination with the ophthalmoscope, the doctor found that the astigmatism was only 200 degrees and advised us to monitor the situation.
Which data should we trust?
John, 40~49 year old female. Ask Date: 2022/06/10
Dr. Cai Wenyuan reply Ophthalmology
You can go to a medical center for an examination.
Reply Date: 2022/06/10
More Info
Understanding your child's vision test results can be quite challenging, especially when there are discrepancies between different tests. In your case, the initial computer-based vision test indicated a high level of astigmatism at 400 degrees, while the follow-up examination using a retinoscope showed only 200 degrees of astigmatism. This situation raises valid concerns about which measurement to trust.
Astigmatism is a common refractive error caused by an irregular shape of the cornea or lens, which leads to blurred or distorted vision. It is measured in diopters (D), and the higher the number, the more significant the astigmatism. In children, astigmatism can affect their visual development, so it's essential to monitor and address it appropriately.
When it comes to the differences in measurements, there are a few factors to consider:
1. Testing Methods: The computer-based vision test (often referred to as autorefractor testing) uses automated technology to estimate refractive errors, including astigmatism. While this method is quick and non-invasive, it may not always provide the most accurate results, particularly in young children who may not fully cooperate during the test. On the other hand, a retinoscope is a more traditional method where the eye doctor uses a light to assess how light reflects off the retina, allowing for a more direct measurement of refractive errors.
2. Child's Cooperation: Young children can be unpredictable during eye exams. If your child was not fully cooperative during the autorefractor test, it could lead to an overestimation of astigmatism. The retinoscope test, being more interactive and requiring the child to focus, might yield a more accurate result.
3. Variability in Measurements: It's not uncommon for different tests to yield varying results. Factors such as the child's mood, fatigue, or even the time of day can influence the measurements. Eye doctors often consider the best results from multiple tests to make a diagnosis.
4. Follow-Up Recommendations: Given the discrepancy, it is advisable to follow the doctor's recommendation to observe your child's vision over time. Regular check-ups are crucial, especially in early childhood, as vision can change rapidly during these formative years. If the astigmatism is confirmed to be significant, corrective lenses may be recommended to help your child see more clearly.
5. Consultation with an Eye Specialist: If you remain concerned about the differences in measurements or your child's vision, consider seeking a second opinion from a pediatric ophthalmologist. They can provide a comprehensive evaluation and help determine the best course of action.
In summary, while both tests provide valuable information, the retinoscope results may be more reliable in this instance. It's essential to continue monitoring your child's vision and follow up with your eye care provider to ensure their visual health is on track. Early detection and intervention can significantly impact your child's overall development and quality of life.
Similar Q&A
Understanding Poor Vision in Children: Essential Tests to Consider
The child's vision test showed both eyes at 0.2, but the clinic measured myopia and astigmatism as -25/-25 in the right eye and -75/-25 in the left eye. Even with corrective lenses, there was no improvement in vision. The clinic physician indicated that the poor vision is no...
Dr. Cai Wenyuan reply Ophthalmology
At least include a dilated fundus examination and retinal examination.[Read More] Understanding Poor Vision in Children: Essential Tests to Consider
Understanding Your Child's Vision: Addressing Nearsightedness and Astigmatism
My child will turn three in four days. A month ago, we visited an ophthalmologist because since birth, the lower eyelashes have been rubbing against the eyeball, causing excessive tearing and discharge. During that visit, the right eye was found to have a refractive error of -4.0...
Dr. Zhuang Yamin reply Ophthalmology
Dear Min-Hsin, Hello! The visual development of a three-year-old child is not yet complete, and a visual acuity of 0.7 is not considered abnormal. In simple terms, his current visual development status is normal (no amblyopia). However, due to the presence of significant refract...[Read More] Understanding Your Child's Vision: Addressing Nearsightedness and Astigmatism
Understanding Pediatric Vision Tests: A Guide for Parents
Hello Doctor, I would like to ask about my daughter who is in the third grade. The other day, she had an eye examination at Clinic A after school (without dilation) and the results showed that her right eye had myopia of -0.50 diopters and astigmatism of -0.25 diopters, while her...
Dr. Gao Pilin reply Ophthalmology
Hello Amy: 1. If you want to start treatment, just use the right eye. 2. If you do not wish to start treatment, you will need to have close follow-up examinations (measuring the prescription once a month). If there is an increasing trend, you should begin treatment; if it remains...[Read More] Understanding Pediatric Vision Tests: A Guide for Parents
Understanding Astigmatism in Children: A Guide for Parents
Hello, Director Tsai. My 5-year-old child was found to have astigmatism during a vision examination, with uncorrected vision of 0.5 in both eyes. With glasses, the right eye is 0.8 and the left eye is 0.7. The doctor mentioned it is amblyopia and recommended wearing glasses. Due ...
Dr. Cai Wenyuan reply Ophthalmology
Amblyopia should be treated as early as possible; if there are any doubts, it is advisable to seek a second opinion from another hospital or clinic.[Read More] Understanding Astigmatism in Children: A Guide for Parents
Related FAQ
(Ophthalmology)
Pediatric Vision Screening(Ophthalmology)
Eye(Pediatrics)
Refraction Test(Ophthalmology)
Amblyopia(Ophthalmology)
Visual Acuity Test(Ophthalmology)
Eye Examination(Ophthalmology)
Nystagmus(Ophthalmology)
Farsightedness(Ophthalmology)
Parallax(Ophthalmology)