Pneumothorax: Diagnosis, Treatment, and Military Service Implications - Pulmonology

Share to:

Diagnosis and Treatment of Pneumothorax


Seven years ago, I went to the emergency department of National Taiwan University Hospital due to a pneumothorax.
After several days of oxygen therapy and X-ray examinations, I was discharged in stable condition.
The hospital issued a diagnosis certificate for bilateral spontaneous pneumothorax.
Since then, I have experienced several episodes of mild pneumothorax that resolved on their own without medical intervention.
Now, at 24 years old, during my military service physical examination, I found out that due to revisions in the classification standards, having experienced bilateral spontaneous pneumothorax allows for exemption from service.
However, it is specified that the determination of spontaneous pneumothorax requires documentation showing that chest tube insertion was performed during the episode or a diagnosis certificate and medical records confirming abnormal pulmonary findings via computed tomography (CT) scan.
Since my previous treatment at National Taiwan University Hospital only involved X-ray examinations, the military service office required me to undergo a physical examination at Tri-Service General Hospital (including X-ray and CT scan).
The outpatient physician indicated that there are currently abnormal air bubbles on the right side and scarring on the left side.
Tri-Service General Hospital issued a diagnosis certificate for bilateral spontaneous pneumothorax, and the military service office initially ruled me exempt from service based on this.
However, during the review process, they requested confirmation based on the definition of spontaneous pneumothorax in the military classification standards to verify whether the CT scan images showed scarring left after the pneumothorax on the left side.
Tri-Service General Hospital responded that "the CT scan images cannot and do not determine pneumothorax scarring; they can only confirm that there are no abnormal air bubbles seen on the left side in this imaging." As a result, the military service office changed their ruling to active duty due to non-compliance with the exemption standards.

My questions are: 1.
Given the recurrent pneumothorax, is surgical treatment recommended? 2.
If the CT scan can only visualize abnormal air bubbles during an active episode and cannot detect the scarring left by previous pneumothorax, how did Tri-Service General Hospital diagnose bilateral spontaneous pneumothorax? Was it diagnosed based on the X-ray findings?

Mr. Yang, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2022/06/16

Dr. Yang Wenda reply Pulmonology


In my personal opinion, I would like to respond as follows: 1.
For recurrent pneumothorax with abnormal air bubble expansion visible on CT scans, surgical treatment is recommended.
2.
Regarding the second question, I cannot speak on behalf of Tri-Service General Hospital and the military service department; it may be necessary to submit old X-rays and a diagnosis report from National Taiwan University Hospital for re-evaluation.

Reply Date: 2022/06/16

More Info


Pneumothorax, commonly referred to as a collapsed lung, occurs when air enters the pleural space—the area between the lung and the chest wall. This condition can arise spontaneously or as a result of medical procedures, such as central venous catheter placement or thoracentesis (the procedure to remove fluid from the pleural space). The term "procedure pneumothorax" specifically refers to pneumothorax that occurs as a complication of a medical procedure.

Symptoms of Pneumothorax
The symptoms of pneumothorax can vary depending on the size of the pneumothorax and the individual's overall health. Common symptoms include:
1. Sudden Chest Pain: This pain is often sharp and may be localized to one side of the chest.

2. Shortness of Breath: Patients may experience difficulty breathing or a feeling of tightness in the chest.

3. Rapid Breathing: Increased respiratory rate can occur as the body attempts to compensate for reduced lung capacity.

4. Cyanosis: In severe cases, a bluish tint may appear on the lips or fingertips due to lack of oxygen.

5. Decreased Breath Sounds: A healthcare provider may note diminished breath sounds on the affected side during a physical examination.


Diagnosis
Diagnosis typically involves imaging studies. A chest X-ray is often the first step, which can show the presence of air in the pleural space. A CT scan may be used for a more detailed view, especially if the pneumothorax is small or if there are concerns about other lung conditions.


Treatment Options
The treatment for pneumothorax depends on its size and the severity of symptoms:
1. Observation: Small pneumothoraces may resolve on their own without intervention. Patients are often monitored with follow-up X-rays.

2. Needle Aspiration: For larger pneumothoraces or if the patient is symptomatic, a needle may be inserted into the pleural space to remove the air.

3. Chest Tube Insertion: If the pneumothorax is large or if the patient is in respiratory distress, a chest tube may be placed to continuously drain air from the pleural space.

4. Surgery: In cases of recurrent pneumothorax or if there is a persistent air leak, surgical options may be considered. Procedures such as pleurodesis (where the pleura is artificially adhered to prevent future pneumothoraces) or bullectomy (removal of blebs or blisters on the lung surface) may be performed.


Military Service Implications
In your case, the military service implications of having a history of pneumothorax can be significant. The military may require specific documentation to determine fitness for service. The criteria for exemption from military service due to pneumothorax often include evidence of prior episodes, particularly if they required invasive treatment like chest tube placement or if imaging studies show abnormalities.


Addressing Your Questions
1. Surgical Treatment Recommendation: If you have experienced recurrent pneumothorax, surgical intervention may be advisable. Surgery can help prevent future episodes and address any underlying lung issues. A thorough evaluation by a thoracic surgeon would be beneficial to discuss the risks and benefits of surgery in your specific case.

2. CT Scan Limitations: It is true that CT scans are primarily used to identify current air leaks or pneumothorax. They may not always show scarring or pleural changes from previous episodes. The diagnosis of bilateral spontaneous pneumothorax could have been made based on your clinical history and the findings from your previous X-rays. The presence of air in the pleural space on imaging, along with your symptoms, would support this diagnosis.

In conclusion, managing pneumothorax involves understanding its symptoms, diagnosis, and treatment options. If you have ongoing concerns about your health and military service status, it is crucial to maintain open communication with your healthcare providers and the military medical board to ensure that all relevant medical information is accurately represented.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Pneumothorax: Symptoms, Treatment, and When to Seek Help

I am a poor student who previously studied abroad. During my first episode of pneumothorax, I was unaware of my condition and ended up sleeping for two to three days. At that time, I didn't have insurance, and as you know, a trip to the hospital or calling an ambulance in No...


Dr. Yang Wenda reply Pulmonology
Hello Justmike: After recovering from a pneumothorax, it is common to experience occasional chest pain during periods of physical exertion, changes in weather, or increased mental stress. Generally, pain relief medication should only be taken when the pain is severe. If you exper...

[Read More] Understanding Pneumothorax: Symptoms, Treatment, and When to Seek Help


Understanding Pneumothorax: Treatment Options and Expert Advice

I would like to ask about my brother, who is currently serving in the military. Last week, he suddenly experienced chest pain and later underwent an examination in Yilan. The doctor recommended immediate hospitalization for surgery, as the X-ray results indicated bilateral pneumo...


Dr. Jiang Zhenyuan reply Pulmonology
The symptoms of pneumothorax often include sudden chest pain. My brother was diagnosed with bilateral pneumothorax during an examination in Yilan, and the hospital recommended surgery, likely due to clinical judgment indicating that surgery was necessary to prevent potential risk...

[Read More] Understanding Pneumothorax: Treatment Options and Expert Advice


Understanding Pectus Excavatum: Treatment Options and Implications

Hello doctor, how should pectus excavatum be treated? What are the potential consequences if it is left untreated? Is it true that one may be exempt from military service? I experience a feeling of pressure in my left chest when sleeping on my left side; could this be related to ...


Dr. Shang Dongfu reply Surgery
Hello: 1. The severity of pectus excavatum varies, and it should be assessed through imaging and functional evaluations conducted by a qualified physician to make an accurate judgment. 2. The criteria for military service must also refer to the relevant regulations set by the Min...

[Read More] Understanding Pectus Excavatum: Treatment Options and Implications


Understanding Spontaneous Pneumothorax: Risks of Wearing Protective Masks

I am currently an active-duty military member, but I experienced a spontaneous pneumothorax before enlisting. During training exercises, I have to wear a protective mask, which makes me feel quite uncomfortable and gives me a sensation of wanting to breathe more easily. I am unsu...


Dr. Xu Jialin reply Pulmonology
Previous occurrences of pneumothorax do not affect respiratory function and do not typically result in feelings of breathlessness. However, patients with a history of pneumothorax should be vigilant for signs of recurrence. Therefore, if you experience significant chest pain and ...

[Read More] Understanding Spontaneous Pneumothorax: Risks of Wearing Protective Masks


Related FAQ

Pneumothorax

(Pulmonology)

Aspiration Pneumonia

(Pulmonology)

Gerd

(Pulmonology)

Computed Tomography

(Pulmonology)

Respiratory Distress Syndrome

(Pulmonology)

Pulmonary Obstruction

(Pulmonology)

Chest Tightness

(Pulmonology)

Lung Nodule

(Pulmonology)

Throat

(Pulmonology)

Cold Medicine

(Pulmonology)